Penalty paid to govt. department
This query is : Resolved
12 June 2012
Dear Sir,
We have paid some amt as penalty to govt. department Like to sale tax Department on self assessment cases, is that allowed as exp in P&L a/c or disallowed ?.
If we get Same problem with Service Tax and Income tax then what to consider allow or disallow ?.
Waiting ans.
Regards
Keshav
We have paid some amt as penalty to govt. department Like to sale tax Department on self assessment cases, is that allowed as exp in P&L a/c or disallowed ?.
If we get Same problem with Service Tax and Income tax then what to consider allow or disallow ?.
Waiting ans.
Regards
Keshav
12 June 2012
Penalty for non payment of sales tax is not a business expenditure.
Citation :- CIT Vs. Bharat Steel Tubes Ltd (1996) 86 Taxman 358 (Del)
But supreme court in Malwa Vanaspati's case said if the payment is embedded with a compensatory characteristic,then it is a business expenditure.
To have a better understanding the concerned act and the reason of payment has to be analysed.
Citation :- CIT Vs. Bharat Steel Tubes Ltd (1996) 86 Taxman 358 (Del)
But supreme court in Malwa Vanaspati's case said if the payment is embedded with a compensatory characteristic,then it is a business expenditure.
To have a better understanding the concerned act and the reason of payment has to be analysed.
Message likes :
1 times
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Tax implications of gift to maternal uncle
- Closure of a PVT LTD company
- 26QB correction - no data available error for fully consumed/processed with default
- Real estate business by a partnership firm where both of the partners are SC/ST
- ROC filings for the first year of incorporation
- When I Login E-invoice portal with waybill user id and pw, it is showing 3011 error data
- TDS on Purchase of Immovable Property in case of Co Owner
- How to open attachment in 23ac xbrl
- Cement Brick HSN code and GST Rates
- Partnership deed reconstitution in how much stamp paper in uttar pradesh
- Input Tax Credit Puf panels
- Unable to convert User role from Registered user to Business user on MCA V3 portal
- Please help with SAC Codes (6 digits) for below mentioned services provided by Chartered Accountant
- Need to send letter to GST dept. For claimed missed ITC
- Printing Press under Composition Scheme
- 140-A Tax Wrongly Paid PAN No
- CSR funding for private limited companies
- SAC codes for Chartered Accountant
- Professional tax deduction monthly
- Cross charges verses Isd methof
CAclubindia
