Payment to truck owner through gta whether allowed or not.
This query is : Resolved
17 April 2018
We are receiving bills from Transporter say GTA. Bills are booked under reverse charge.
Now Transporter says Sir Please do not Deduct TDS from our account and arrange payment in the name of Truck Owner. Truck owner is submitting his ITR accordingly.
Query:
A-Can Payment be made to Truck Owner against the bills of Transporter i.e. GTA??
B- If Payment can be made then can TDS not be deducted if declaration given by Truck owner with PAN that he is depositing TDS himself??
Now Transporter says Sir Please do not Deduct TDS from our account and arrange payment in the name of Truck Owner. Truck owner is submitting his ITR accordingly.
Query:
A-Can Payment be made to Truck Owner against the bills of Transporter i.e. GTA??
B- If Payment can be made then can TDS not be deducted if declaration given by Truck owner with PAN that he is depositing TDS himself??
17 April 2018
Payment can't be made to Truck Owner against the bills of Transporter i.e. GTA
Message likes :
1 times
17 April 2018
A - No... We can't pay to truck owner if bill is in the name of transporter.
B - As per A no way for deduct TDS.
Message likes :
1 times
27 April 2018
Why Payment can not be made to Lorry Owner. Original RC copy is received, Name of payee matched with Lorry owner as per RC. Is there any legal restriction on doing so??
Please help as I am in between to take decision to implement system.
Please help as I am in between to take decision to implement system.
27 April 2018
Dear.,
But., Your 1st query not cleared as per 2nd query... Am I right?
But., Your 1st query not cleared as per 2nd query... Am I right?
27 April 2018
The Truck Owner and the GTA owner is same and the GTA name is also the Truck owner's name then no more restriction for the Payment... You can pay as per Your view...
In case both (GTA and Truck Owner) are different then it's not applicable as per Your query...
First of clear these details...
In case both (GTA and Truck Owner) are different then it's not applicable as per Your query...
First of clear these details...
Message likes :
1 times
28 April 2018
If truck owner raise the bill to you then you can pay directly to truck owner.
Message likes :
1 times
28 April 2018
Transporter and Lorry Owner are different. Bilty is being raised by Transporter and Vehicle owner is supposed to get payment. We want to make payment directly to Vehicle owner. We will deduct TDS from Transporter.
For Eg ABC Transport arranges a Lorry from Andhra Pradesh to Uttar Pradesh. Ramesh is lorry owner. At the time of Unloading Ramesh asks for payment. We do NEFT after taking necessary papers to Ramesh.
We book entry as below
Freight Inward Dr
To ABC Transport
To TDS Payable
After NEFT to Ramesh we do
ABC Transport Dr
To Bank
Can we do So???
what is legal challenge??
For Eg ABC Transport arranges a Lorry from Andhra Pradesh to Uttar Pradesh. Ramesh is lorry owner. At the time of Unloading Ramesh asks for payment. We do NEFT after taking necessary papers to Ramesh.
We book entry as below
Freight Inward Dr
To ABC Transport
To TDS Payable
After NEFT to Ramesh we do
ABC Transport Dr
To Bank
Can we do So???
what is legal challenge??
Message likes :
1 times
28 April 2018
First of generally Transporter give the services by his vehicles or rented* vehicles (In case it's from nearest transporter or lorry. Some lorry with Driver may be driver is the owner of lorry or anybody)
AFter completing supplies Lorry owner or Driver will be ask payment from the Service receiver.
We consider the Driver / Lorry Owner is the Transporter's staff and we paid the payment. Most of the cases we paid cash upto Rs. 30K. In case we paid cash no more confusion. Bcoz, We book directly to the Transporter's name.
Here,
You are paid to Ramesh. As per your reply You paid as NEFT to Ramesh. It think after considered with the transporter. So, no more problems about the transactions.
But,
If you are transferred the amount to Ramesh's Bank account then your entry is wrong as per my view...
AFter completing supplies Lorry owner or Driver will be ask payment from the Service receiver.
We consider the Driver / Lorry Owner is the Transporter's staff and we paid the payment. Most of the cases we paid cash upto Rs. 30K. In case we paid cash no more confusion. Bcoz, We book directly to the Transporter's name.
Here,
You are paid to Ramesh. As per your reply You paid as NEFT to Ramesh. It think after considered with the transporter. So, no more problems about the transactions.
But,
If you are transferred the amount to Ramesh's Bank account then your entry is wrong as per my view...
28 April 2018
As per my view.,
If you are transferred the amount to Ramesh account....
i) Booking the expenditure with A Journal :
Dr. Transporting / Freight A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. ABC Transporter A/c - Rs. XXX
ii) Payment :
Dr. Mr. Ramesh A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. Bank A/c - Rs. XXX
iii) Adjustment Journal :
Dr. ABC Transporter A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. Mr. Ramesh A/c - Rs. XXX
Note :
Main think detailed narration is required in transfers...
TDS not applicable if Contract - Transporter who has provided valid PAN.
If No / Invalid PAN then will be deduct @ 20% TDS u/s 194C
>>> GOOD LUCK <<<
If you are transferred the amount to Ramesh account....
i) Booking the expenditure with A Journal :
Dr. Transporting / Freight A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. ABC Transporter A/c - Rs. XXX
ii) Payment :
Dr. Mr. Ramesh A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. Bank A/c - Rs. XXX
iii) Adjustment Journal :
Dr. ABC Transporter A/c - Rs. XXX
Cr. Mr. Ramesh A/c - Rs. XXX
Note :
Main think detailed narration is required in transfers...
TDS not applicable if Contract - Transporter who has provided valid PAN.
If No / Invalid PAN then will be deduct @ 20% TDS u/s 194C
>>> GOOD LUCK <<<
Message likes :
1 times
30 April 2018
Thanks for your valuable time and reply
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Presumptive tax individual
- Non receipt of net payment but TDS filed later and ITR revised return not filed
- Form 26b submission
- Difference in invoice
- GST implication in case of Proprietor
- Interest On TDS under section 201(1A)
- TDS u/s 194IB
- Due diligence of NBFC (To raise Investment from Lender)
- Regarding recollect the GST Pre-Deposit made for appeal
- Trade Union Income Heads Classification
- Residential Real Estate Project
- TDS ON CLEARING & FORWARDING CHARGES BY A CHA
- Wrong name entered in CSR-1 of a Society
- Regarding ITAT Appeal
- Clerical mistake in GSTR 1 entered
- Director's remuneration and RPT
- Amendment in GSTR1A
- GST adjudication monetary limit
- BSR AND CHALLAN SERIAL NUMBER IN CASE OF BANK ATTACHMENT ?
- CA FINAL Group-1 Completed
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
