08 April 2012
Will section 44 AD applicable to Professional also. As in section only word business in specifid. Is the meaning of word business is enough to include the professionals also.
08 April 2012
Yes, it applies to professional also.
As per IT act, Business itself means business & profession.
Querist :
Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
08 April 2012
but business and profession are seperately defined in the act and moreover, the intention of the act as in the case of Section 28va, where it state not to carry any activity related to business. and then in another clause it specially mentioned not to share any knowledge, right, forumula etc in relation to any buss or profession. Creates doubht in mind
08 April 2012
For F.Y 2012-13, the professionals, broker, commission & agency business will not be covered under 44AD as per Recent amendments of Budget 2012-13.
If you are asking for F.Y 2011-12, i think it will be covered u/s 44AD as clear from the this year budget amendments.
Hope query clears now
Now Cheers
Querist :
Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
08 April 2012
For F.Y 11-12, there is confusion. But as u said budget for 12-13 clearely state professionals are not included may be it is made to clear the status of 44AD and remove the ambiguity of such section
09 April 2012
AS PER SUPREME COURT DECISION IN G K CHOKSHI CASE BUSINESS DOES NOT INCLUDE PROFESSION SO SECTION 44AD WILL NOT APPLY TO PROFESSION CA MANOJ GUPTA JODHPUR 09828510543