Section 44 ad
This query is : Resolved
05 July 2013
An assessee carrying on a business eligible under section 44 AD and at the same time receving commission from other source of income so will he be disallowed under section 44 AD or will he be allowed for the eligible business and taxed for commission seperately??
05 July 2013
For eligible business 44AD will be applicable & Commission income can be shown as regular business income.
Message likes :
1 times
05 July 2013
But in the Act the language is assessee must be eligible and assessee is ineligible if he is carrying on a proffession or receiving brokerage?? Sir Please elaborate on this point
05 July 2013
But in the Act the language is assessee must be eligible and assessee is ineligible if he is carrying on a proffession or receiving brokerage?? Sir Please elaborate on this point
05 July 2013
An assessee is always an eligible assessee (EA) even if he carries on an ineligible business.
.
Please check the definition of "eligible assessee". It has nothing to do with the EB.
.
Similar is the case with the eligible business (EB) .
.
When ever EA and EB combines section applies to that extent only.
.
In sub-section (6) a person carrying on agency business has been excluded by mentioning that the section shall not apply to such person.
.
In such a situation for EB the person is EA but as commission is not EB vide the para above, the section can not be applied to that extent.
.
So you can say , we have to adopt fragmented approach for the same person.
.
An assessee is always an eligible assessee (EA) even if he carries on an ineligible business.
.
Please check the definition of "eligible assessee". It has nothing to do with the EB.
.
Similar is the case with the eligible business (EB) .
.
When ever EA and EB combines section applies to that extent only.
.
In sub-section (6) a person carrying on agency business has been excluded by mentioning that the section shall not apply to such person.
.
In such a situation for EB the person is EA but as commission is not EB vide the para above, the section can not be applied to that extent.
.
So you can say , we have to adopt fragmented approach for the same person.
.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Tax implications of gift to maternal uncle
- Closure of a PVT LTD company
- Real estate business by a partnership firm where both of the partners are SC/ST
- 26QB correction - no data available error for fully consumed/processed with default
- ROC filings for the first year of incorporation
- TDS on Purchase of Immovable Property in case of Co Owner
- When I Login E-invoice portal with waybill user id and pw, it is showing 3011 error data
- How to open attachment in 23ac xbrl
- INCOME TAX AMOUNT PAID BUT NOT REFLECTING IN PORTAL
- Exemption under section 54 and Exemption on it
- Input Tax Credit Puf panels
- Unable to convert User role from Registered user to Business user on MCA V3 portal
- Please help with SAC Codes (6 digits) for below mentioned services provided by Chartered Accountant
- Need to send letter to GST dept. For claimed missed ITC
- Printing Press under Composition Scheme
- 140-A Tax Wrongly Paid PAN No
- CSR funding for private limited companies
- SAC codes for Chartered Accountant
- Professional tax deduction monthly
- Cross charges verses Isd methof
CAclubindia
