Penalty

This query is : Resolved

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

18 July 2013 dear sir;s
we are a leading manufacturer of printing ink in india, there was an E.A conducted fro the period 1jan12 to Dec12, & there are certain audit poitns where it was noted the credit was wrongly availed on, now the add.com audit note is receivd & ther are demanding the reversal of cenvat credit & demanding interest & penlty for the erroneous availment, hence we paid the interest alone & now the range supdt.m, is asking us to work out the penalty also & pay to the dept.,, please help us in resolving this

Arun Kumar Singh

Arun Kumar Singh (Expert)
Follow

18 July 2013 Sir,
If you will provide the letter of audit objection to any professional then solution will come out. visit on my profile and send the letter.

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

05 August 2013 please reply

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma online

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

09 August 2024 In your situation, you have been asked to reverse the wrongly availed CENVAT credit along with interest and penalty. Here’s a structured approach to address the issue and resolve it effectively:

### **1. **Review the Audit Points**

- **Understand the Discrepancies**: Review the audit points and the audit note to understand the exact nature of the erroneous CENVAT credit availment.
- **Assess the Credit**: Identify the amount of CENVAT credit that was incorrectly availed and ensure it matches with what was noted in the audit.

### **2. **Reversal of CENVAT Credit**

- **Reverse the Credit**: Ensure that you have reversed the incorrect CENVAT credit in your books and notified the authorities of the same.
- **Documentation**: Maintain documentation of the reversal for future reference and to provide evidence of compliance.

### **3. **Calculate the Penalty**

The penalty for erroneous availment of CENVAT credit can be assessed under various provisions, primarily:

- **Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act**: This section deals with the penalty for short payment or non-payment of duty due to fraud, willful misstatement, or suppression of facts. The penalty could be equal to the amount of duty evaded or up to 100% of the duty if the act is deemed to be intentional.

**Calculation of Penalty:**
- **If the Error is Non-Willful**: Penalty may be up to 10% of the duty involved or a minimum of ₹5,000.
- **If the Error is Willful**: Penalty could be equal to the amount of CENVAT credit wrongly availed or up to 100% of the duty evaded.

- **Section 27 of the Central Excise Act**: If applicable, this section deals with penalties related to the incorrect filing of returns and documentation.

### **4. **Paying the Penalty**

- **Determine the Penalty Amount**: Based on the nature of the error (willful or non-willful), calculate the appropriate penalty amount. Refer to the audit note and any relevant provisions to ensure accurate calculation.
- **Make Payment**: Pay the penalty amount as directed by the Range Superintendent.

### **5. **Address the Issue with the Authorities**

- **Communicate with the Authorities**: If you believe the penalty amount or the assessment is not aligned with the actual error, communicate with the authorities to clarify and resolve any discrepancies.
- **Submit Compliance Proof**: Provide proof of the reversal of CENVAT credit and the payment of interest and penalty to the department.

### **6. **Future Compliance**

- **Review Procedures**: Implement robust internal controls and procedures to prevent such errors in the future.
- **Training**: Provide training to staff on CENVAT credit rules and compliance requirements to avoid similar issues.

### **7. **Consult a Tax Professional**

- **Expert Advice**: Given the complexities involved in calculating and handling penalties, consult with a tax professional or legal advisor who specializes in Central Excise matters. They can provide precise calculations, ensure compliance with the provisions, and assist in negotiating with the authorities if needed.

### **Checklist for Resolving the Issue**

1. **Review and Understand Audit Findings**
2. **Reverse Incorrect CENVAT Credit**
3. **Calculate and Pay Interest**
4. **Determine and Pay Penalty**
5. **Communicate and Submit Documentation to Authorities**
6. **Implement Preventive Measures**
7. **Seek Professional Guidance**

By following these steps and ensuring accurate calculation and compliance, you can resolve the issue with the authorities effectively.