CA Day celebration 2024 Easy Office
LCI Learning

Need tax advice


10 May 2012 I have a business idea about stock trading.

I want to know tax and law complication on it.

Idea:

Employees will be having their Demat+ trading account on their respective pan cards. But, they will be doing trading for company and with company money. Whatever profit or loss they incur will be of company. they will be provided with fixed salary and bonus with respect to profit.

In this scene, my queries are:

1. is this legal if employees are made to pay tax on profit incur on thier pancards

2. What will be different taxes if its a small firm and if a big firm

Please reply


10 May 2012 it is illegal..

10 May 2012 Your idea is "wonderful" for "tax payable/loss born by employees" for the company but for your surprise; it is illegal.
.
By the way; may I ask one query ( I presume I also have "right" to ask "unusual" query ) :
.
What is your qualification ?


10 May 2012 Can this be made legal by method of contract or affidvit between employee and company?

Please suggest smthing..

one more thing i m in no mood to steal tax r anything like that.

Major issue is that a company cant open Multiple Stock trading account accounts which is the basic requirement of this idea.

So i go for employee.

In the end govenment is getting taxes why it is matter that the account on employee or company.




You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries




Answer Query