Managerial Remuneration
This query is : Resolved
13 June 2011
In case of a private limited company (not a subsidiary of a public ltd company), are there any restictions for the remuneration paid to its directors.
The articles do not provide any restrictions.
Is Sch XIII applicable to such companies
The articles do not provide any restrictions.
Is Sch XIII applicable to such companies
14 June 2011
A private limited company which is on loss is giving Rs. 1 lakhs as monthly remuneration to its director.
Can this expense be allowed.
The details will be disclosed in the notes to accounts. Is there any other point to be verified during audit
Can this expense be allowed.
The details will be disclosed in the notes to accounts. Is there any other point to be verified during audit
03 August 2024
For a private limited company, especially one that is not a subsidiary of a public limited company, the regulations regarding managerial remuneration can be somewhat less stringent compared to public companies. Here's a detailed breakdown addressing your queries:
### **Regulations and Restrictions on Managerial Remuneration:**
1. **Applicability of Schedule XIII:**
- **Schedule XIII of the Companies Act, 1956:** This schedule provided guidelines on managerial remuneration, including limits and conditions for public companies and certain private companies.
- **Private Limited Companies:** Schedule XIII was generally not applicable to private limited companies. Private companies were often allowed more flexibility in determining remuneration, particularly if they were not subsidiaries of public companies.
2. **Current Legal Framework:**
- **Companies Act, 1956:** Under the Companies Act, 1956, Schedule XIII was applicable to public companies and private companies that were subsidiaries of public companies. For other private companies, the restrictions were less stringent.
- **Companies Act, 2013:** The Companies Act, 2013, replaced the Companies Act, 1956, and introduced new provisions. Under the Companies Act, 2013:
- **No Specific Schedule XIII:** Schedule XIII has been replaced, but the new act has its own provisions for managerial remuneration.
- **Private Companies:** Private companies have more flexibility, but they must still ensure that remuneration is reasonable and justifiable, especially if the company is in loss.
3. **Remuneration in Loss-Making Companies:**
- **Managerial Remuneration:** Even if a private company is making a loss, it can still pay remuneration to its directors. However, the remuneration must be reasonable and justified based on the company’s financial position.
- **Accounting and Disclosure:** The expense for remuneration must be properly accounted for and disclosed in the financial statements. The disclosure in the notes to accounts should include the total remuneration paid and any relevant details.
4. **Audit Considerations:**
- **Verification Points During Audit:**
- **Reasonableness of Remuneration:** Ensure that the remuneration is reasonable and not excessive given the financial position of the company. Even though Schedule XIII may not apply, remuneration should still be fair and justifiable.
- **Approval Process:** Check if the remuneration was approved by the Board of Directors and documented in the minutes of the meetings. For private companies, this is more of a corporate governance issue rather than a legal requirement.
- **Compliance with Articles of Association:** Verify if the Articles of Association (AOA) of the company specify any limits or conditions on the payment of remuneration, even if they are not currently restrictive.
- **Disclosure:** Confirm that the remuneration and any related party transactions are properly disclosed in the notes to the financial statements.
### **Summary:**
- **No Specific Restrictions:** For a private limited company that is not a subsidiary of a public company, there are no specific statutory restrictions on remuneration under Schedule XIII of the Companies Act, 1956, or its successor provisions in the Companies Act, 2013. However, remuneration must still be reasonable and justifiable.
- **Disclosure and Audit:** Proper disclosure in the notes to accounts is required, and during an audit, the focus should be on the reasonableness of the remuneration, proper approval, and adherence to corporate governance practices.
**Recommendation:**
- **Consult Professionals:** It is advisable to consult with a legal or financial professional to ensure that all aspects of managerial remuneration are compliant with current regulations and best practices. This can help address any potential issues and ensure transparency in financial reporting and corporate governance.
### **Regulations and Restrictions on Managerial Remuneration:**
1. **Applicability of Schedule XIII:**
- **Schedule XIII of the Companies Act, 1956:** This schedule provided guidelines on managerial remuneration, including limits and conditions for public companies and certain private companies.
- **Private Limited Companies:** Schedule XIII was generally not applicable to private limited companies. Private companies were often allowed more flexibility in determining remuneration, particularly if they were not subsidiaries of public companies.
2. **Current Legal Framework:**
- **Companies Act, 1956:** Under the Companies Act, 1956, Schedule XIII was applicable to public companies and private companies that were subsidiaries of public companies. For other private companies, the restrictions were less stringent.
- **Companies Act, 2013:** The Companies Act, 2013, replaced the Companies Act, 1956, and introduced new provisions. Under the Companies Act, 2013:
- **No Specific Schedule XIII:** Schedule XIII has been replaced, but the new act has its own provisions for managerial remuneration.
- **Private Companies:** Private companies have more flexibility, but they must still ensure that remuneration is reasonable and justifiable, especially if the company is in loss.
3. **Remuneration in Loss-Making Companies:**
- **Managerial Remuneration:** Even if a private company is making a loss, it can still pay remuneration to its directors. However, the remuneration must be reasonable and justified based on the company’s financial position.
- **Accounting and Disclosure:** The expense for remuneration must be properly accounted for and disclosed in the financial statements. The disclosure in the notes to accounts should include the total remuneration paid and any relevant details.
4. **Audit Considerations:**
- **Verification Points During Audit:**
- **Reasonableness of Remuneration:** Ensure that the remuneration is reasonable and not excessive given the financial position of the company. Even though Schedule XIII may not apply, remuneration should still be fair and justifiable.
- **Approval Process:** Check if the remuneration was approved by the Board of Directors and documented in the minutes of the meetings. For private companies, this is more of a corporate governance issue rather than a legal requirement.
- **Compliance with Articles of Association:** Verify if the Articles of Association (AOA) of the company specify any limits or conditions on the payment of remuneration, even if they are not currently restrictive.
- **Disclosure:** Confirm that the remuneration and any related party transactions are properly disclosed in the notes to the financial statements.
### **Summary:**
- **No Specific Restrictions:** For a private limited company that is not a subsidiary of a public company, there are no specific statutory restrictions on remuneration under Schedule XIII of the Companies Act, 1956, or its successor provisions in the Companies Act, 2013. However, remuneration must still be reasonable and justifiable.
- **Disclosure and Audit:** Proper disclosure in the notes to accounts is required, and during an audit, the focus should be on the reasonableness of the remuneration, proper approval, and adherence to corporate governance practices.
**Recommendation:**
- **Consult Professionals:** It is advisable to consult with a legal or financial professional to ensure that all aspects of managerial remuneration are compliant with current regulations and best practices. This can help address any potential issues and ensure transparency in financial reporting and corporate governance.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- Inventory of finished goods
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- RCM INVOICING FROM NOV-2024
- Confusion around Form 26QB fields
- Sale of property furniture sale
- REGARDING 25 AS DATE OF PAYMENT AND DATE OF BOOKING
- Quiery in relation to GST liability in case of an advocate who has obtained GST registration.
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- TDS under section and rate of TDS
- GST input on scooter purchased
- TDS under section 194Q and TCS under section 206C
- GST input on car insurance and repairs
- GST input on Diwali gift to employee
- GST input on Mobile Handset
- Material and freight in same invoice
- TDS under section 194J inclusive of reimbursement of expenses
- TDS on Material and Labour in same invoice
- Should I be worried about and rectify reporting Jan,Feb ,March 2024 foreign salary in schedule FA?
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
