Letting out of buildings as cinema hall and shopping mall
This query is : Resolved
04 August 2011
Dear Sir,
Please tell me whether I am Correct or not with the understanding of the below concepts.
Rental Income earned through letting out of Buildings as cinema halls is not taxable U/H "Income from House property" as the rental income is composite and inseperable in nature ie letting out of building is inseparable to letting out of furniture in the cinema hall. Therefore entire rental income will be taxed U/H "Profits and Gains from business or profession" or "Income from other Sources"
But whereas letting out of buildings to shopping malls like Big Bazaar, Spencers is taxable U/H "Income from House property" as though the income is composite in nature it is just letting out of building and provision of services like escalators, lift etc. So the composite income is now bifurcated into two parts as rental income from house property and income earned from provision of services. Therefore rental income earned from letting out of building is taxable under "Income from House property" and income earned from provision of services (like lift facilities provided) is taxable under "Income from other Sources".
One more query - can Rental income earned by the apartment owner is also to be treated in the same manner as rental income earned from shopping malls above.
Kindly confirm on the above queries.
Thank you
Gopi
Please tell me whether I am Correct or not with the understanding of the below concepts.
Rental Income earned through letting out of Buildings as cinema halls is not taxable U/H "Income from House property" as the rental income is composite and inseperable in nature ie letting out of building is inseparable to letting out of furniture in the cinema hall. Therefore entire rental income will be taxed U/H "Profits and Gains from business or profession" or "Income from other Sources"
But whereas letting out of buildings to shopping malls like Big Bazaar, Spencers is taxable U/H "Income from House property" as though the income is composite in nature it is just letting out of building and provision of services like escalators, lift etc. So the composite income is now bifurcated into two parts as rental income from house property and income earned from provision of services. Therefore rental income earned from letting out of building is taxable under "Income from House property" and income earned from provision of services (like lift facilities provided) is taxable under "Income from other Sources".
One more query - can Rental income earned by the apartment owner is also to be treated in the same manner as rental income earned from shopping malls above.
Kindly confirm on the above queries.
Thank you
Gopi
04 August 2011
Great Query i am appreciate. IF the income received by the owner for giving their building for cinema it cover under U/h House property instead of PGBP. Generally PGBP cover income earn frm business or any profession. bt above case their is no any circumstances or Composite rent is Income from other sources
Message likes :
2 times
04 August 2011
Hi Ravi,
Composite income is a complex concept, we need a comprehensive answer to understand these queries.
Let us wait for the other experts opinion who have answered my earlier queries with a great ease.
Thank you.
Composite income is a complex concept, we need a comprehensive answer to understand these queries.
Let us wait for the other experts opinion who have answered my earlier queries with a great ease.
Thank you.
Message likes :
1 times
04 August 2011
Composite rent concept need to be view in 2 ways
1. Where the Composite rent can be inseparable , which is letting of building and other assets cannot be done separately ex. A having building along with furniture, machinery, lift etc. when the building cannot take for rent only for building, tenant need to take together and need to pay rent so such as case Income need to be treated either Income from business or Income from other sources
2. where the building & other assets like lift, furniture can be let out separately then the income from building need to treated as Income from HP & Income from other assets need to be considered as Income from othersources
1. Where the Composite rent can be inseparable , which is letting of building and other assets cannot be done separately ex. A having building along with furniture, machinery, lift etc. when the building cannot take for rent only for building, tenant need to take together and need to pay rent so such as case Income need to be treated either Income from business or Income from other sources
2. where the building & other assets like lift, furniture can be let out separately then the income from building need to treated as Income from HP & Income from other assets need to be considered as Income from othersources
Message likes :
2 times
04 August 2011
Hi Ramesh,
Thanks for the brief description of the concept "composite rent".
Please tell us whether the concept of composite rent being separable (ie letting of building can be done without letting out the furniture in the building)can be applied to a cinema hall.
Can we say that rental income from cinema hall is chargeable U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources" or do we need to go through the tenancy agreement to find out whether it is inseperable or not.
I am asking this query only out of academic interest.
Thank you all.
Thanks for the brief description of the concept "composite rent".
Please tell us whether the concept of composite rent being separable (ie letting of building can be done without letting out the furniture in the building)can be applied to a cinema hall.
Can we say that rental income from cinema hall is chargeable U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources" or do we need to go through the tenancy agreement to find out whether it is inseperable or not.
I am asking this query only out of academic interest.
Thank you all.
Message likes :
1 times
05 August 2011
Academically the answer has been given by the expert CMA Ramesh.
However,practically if you desire to separate the rent of building -as say Rs 1.00 lac per month and rent of furniture
and facilities is say Rs .50 lac, then
you can take the rent of building U/H IFHP
and further rent of Furniture,
Projector etc can be taken under income from other sources or IFBP.
.
Two separate agreements can be entered into.
.
As such We need to go through the tenancy agreement to find out whether it is inseperable or not.
However,practically if you desire to separate the rent of building -as say Rs 1.00 lac per month and rent of furniture
and facilities is say Rs .50 lac, then
you can take the rent of building U/H IFHP
and further rent of Furniture,
Projector etc can be taken under income from other sources or IFBP.
.
Two separate agreements can be entered into.
.
As such We need to go through the tenancy agreement to find out whether it is inseperable or not.
Message likes :
2 times
05 August 2011
Dear Sir,
Composite rent being inseparable means letting out of one asset cannot be done without letting out the other asset. In such cases the entire income is taxable U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources".
Obviously letting out of building is inseparable to letting out of furniture in the cinema hall.
But as you said, practically, we can make the agreement separable by entering into two separate agreements and charge rent from building U/H "Income from House property" and rent on furniture U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources".
Thank you all.
Composite rent being inseparable means letting out of one asset cannot be done without letting out the other asset. In such cases the entire income is taxable U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources".
Obviously letting out of building is inseparable to letting out of furniture in the cinema hall.
But as you said, practically, we can make the agreement separable by entering into two separate agreements and charge rent from building U/H "Income from House property" and rent on furniture U/H "Income from Business or Profession" or "Income from other Sources".
Thank you all.
Message likes :
1 times
06 March 2013
can we go foe presumptive taxation u/s 44ad??? if rent is inseprable and taxable u/h pgbp.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- REGARDING GST ON COMMERICIAL PROPERTY
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- 15ca /15cb whose income tax login? remitter or nri seller's login?
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- TDS U/S. 194NF
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- Regarding Documentation & Compliances for Opening of Unit of Pvt Ltd.
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- VERIFICATION OF REFUND RELATED
- GST Regis.
- ITC c/f from FY2022-23 to FY2023-24 entered the same in table 8C of GSTR9 of FY 2022-23, in FY23-24
- Late filling fees Demand by gst office
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- Short and Excess provision of expenses
- Issue of gst e invoice
- Interchangeable words in accounts
- Adjusted profit/Loss in the case of LLP and Pvt. Ltd.company
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
