Is tax audit applicable in case of F&O transaction
This query is : Resolved
29 August 2021
would like to know the tax audit applicability of a resident individual having the following source of income for the AY 21-22
Business income
Non speculative loss- 1,00,000
Speculative profit- 20,000
Income from other sources- Interest from FD- 90,000
I would like to know whether i need to get my account audited u/s 44AB to carry forward the business loss.
Please note that i have not claimed any benefit under section 44AD in any of the preceding previous years even though i was eligible assessee and nor am i planning to opt for section 44AD during this PY as well. Kindly advice
Business income
Non speculative loss- 1,00,000
Speculative profit- 20,000
Income from other sources- Interest from FD- 90,000
I would like to know whether i need to get my account audited u/s 44AB to carry forward the business loss.
Please note that i have not claimed any benefit under section 44AD in any of the preceding previous years even though i was eligible assessee and nor am i planning to opt for section 44AD during this PY as well. Kindly advice
29 August 2021
As your total taxable income is below the limit, i.e. maximum amount not chargeable to tax, tax audit not applicable
Message likes :
1 times
29 August 2021
@dhirajlal rambhia
sir what if my total income comes to say Rs, 6,00,000 after considering the loss from futures and option. Still i would be not applicable for tax audit right as the limit u/s 44AB is 1 crore right?
The provisions of 44AB, what it says is that for persons whome 44AD(4) are applicable and the income exceeds the basic amount chargeable to tax then tax audit is required.
whereas 44AD(4) provides for any person who has opted to pay tax in any PY u/s 44AD(1) has shown a total income less than 8% of turnover, then such person shall be liable to audit if the sum exceeds the basic taxable amount.
However in my case since i have not opted for 44AD(1) in any of the PY hence 44AD(4) would be applicable right and only 44AB(1) will be applicable for computing whether tax audit is required or not. Which is the limit of 1 crore?
Is my view correct?
sir what if my total income comes to say Rs, 6,00,000 after considering the loss from futures and option. Still i would be not applicable for tax audit right as the limit u/s 44AB is 1 crore right?
The provisions of 44AB, what it says is that for persons whome 44AD(4) are applicable and the income exceeds the basic amount chargeable to tax then tax audit is required.
whereas 44AD(4) provides for any person who has opted to pay tax in any PY u/s 44AD(1) has shown a total income less than 8% of turnover, then such person shall be liable to audit if the sum exceeds the basic taxable amount.
However in my case since i have not opted for 44AD(1) in any of the PY hence 44AD(4) would be applicable right and only 44AB(1) will be applicable for computing whether tax audit is required or not. Which is the limit of 1 crore?
Is my view correct?
29 August 2021
There are many professionals who have same opinion. Even ICAI has asked for clarification on the issue. But main issue is that the software is developed based on 'Deemed income' as mentioned in sec. 44AD; hence the such ITRs are not accepted without Tax Audit report. You may wait for any clarification/rectification from department.
29 August 2021
Thank you @ dhirajlal
22 September 2021
My Pleasure ...
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- TDS-194M Contract
- TDS applicability for partnership firm
- Treatment of Car allowance
- Dried Vegetable Sale from Rajasthan to MP, E-way Bill compulsory or not?
- TDS on Property
- After retirement
- 44AD PRESUMPTIVE RATE ON CREDIT SALES
- Section 44AE
- Input tax credit on modular office kitchen
- Assessment Completed u/s 147 of the IT Act
- Advt Expenses
- ITC of Insurance on Capital Electronic Goods
- Discontinuance of Interest and Salary to working partners
- SERVICE PROVIDER GST
- TIME LIMIT FOR AVAILMENT OF ITC LAYING IN ITC REVRSAL LEDGER
- Tally entry - Debit note
- Debit Note of GST amount
- Reposting my query kindly reply.
- Regarding ITC taken or not
- Gst registration in the state of maharashtra
Trending Online Classes
-
GST LIVE Certification Course - 42nd Weekend Batch(With Govt Certificate)
Industry Expert17 May 2025
CAclubindia
