Interstate purchase
This query is : Resolved
13 September 2015
I had purchased interstate and I paid excise duty 12.5 + CST 2% now my question is do I need to pay local vat14.5 % in karnataka or not if yes why if not why ? pls clarify my doubt
15 September 2015
No you not need to pay it again as you already paid it once
21 February 2016
y I need not pay local tax sir pls explain me ?
21 February 2016
why I need not to pay local tax sir pls explain me ?
01 August 2024
In the context of the pre-GST tax regime in India, here’s a clear explanation of why you did not need to pay local VAT after making an interstate purchase:
### **Understanding Pre-GST Tax Regime:**
1. **Central Sales Tax (CST):** CST was levied on interstate sales and was intended to cover the tax liability for transactions occurring between states. This tax was collected by the seller from the buyer in the state of origin and paid to the central government.
2. **Excise Duty:** This was applicable on the manufacture of goods and was paid by the manufacturer to the central government. For goods sold interstate, the excise duty was included in the price of the goods.
3. **Local VAT:** Local VAT or State Sales Tax was applicable on transactions occurring within a state. It was collected by the seller on sales made within the state and was paid to the respective state government.
### **Why Local VAT is Not Required on Interstate Purchases:**
When you make an interstate purchase, the following points clarify why local VAT is not applicable:
1. **CST Covers Interstate Transactions:** CST was specifically designed to tax interstate sales. By paying CST on your interstate purchase, you have already covered the tax obligation related to the movement of goods across state boundaries. The CST collected by the seller was meant to be a substitute for the local VAT, which would otherwise apply if the purchase was made within the same state.
2. **No Duplicate Taxation:** Allowing both CST and local VAT on the same transaction would result in double taxation. To avoid this, the tax system provided that interstate transactions, upon which CST is paid, would not be subject to additional local VAT.
3. **Excise Duty:** For interstate sales, excise duty was included in the price of the goods. This duty was intended to be part of the overall tax structure and was not a substitute for VAT but rather an additional tax on manufacture.
### **Illustrative Example:**
- Suppose you purchased goods worth ₹100,000 from another state. The seller charged you CST (2%) of ₹2,000 and included excise duty (12.5%) in the price.
- In this scenario, the CST of ₹2,000 was the tax applicable for the interstate movement of goods.
- You would not be liable to pay local VAT (14.5%) in Karnataka because the CST you paid already addressed the tax liability for that interstate purchase. Local VAT would apply only to intra-state transactions where goods are sold within the same state.
### **Key Points:**
- **Pre-GST System:** CST was used for interstate transactions, and you paid CST instead of local VAT. Hence, local VAT was not applicable.
- **Avoiding Double Taxation:** The system was designed to ensure that you did not pay both CST and local VAT on the same transaction.
### **Post-GST Transition:**
If you are referring to a situation post-GST (after July 1, 2017), the tax structure has changed:
- **IGST (Integrated GST):** For interstate sales under GST, IGST is applicable instead of CST. IGST covers both central and state tax components.
- **Input Tax Credit (ITC):** Under GST, you can claim input tax credit for the IGST paid, which avoids the need for local VAT.
In conclusion, under the pre-GST regime, the payment of CST for interstate purchases meant that you did not need to pay additional local VAT. The tax structure was designed to avoid double taxation and ensure that interstate transactions were taxed appropriately.
### **Understanding Pre-GST Tax Regime:**
1. **Central Sales Tax (CST):** CST was levied on interstate sales and was intended to cover the tax liability for transactions occurring between states. This tax was collected by the seller from the buyer in the state of origin and paid to the central government.
2. **Excise Duty:** This was applicable on the manufacture of goods and was paid by the manufacturer to the central government. For goods sold interstate, the excise duty was included in the price of the goods.
3. **Local VAT:** Local VAT or State Sales Tax was applicable on transactions occurring within a state. It was collected by the seller on sales made within the state and was paid to the respective state government.
### **Why Local VAT is Not Required on Interstate Purchases:**
When you make an interstate purchase, the following points clarify why local VAT is not applicable:
1. **CST Covers Interstate Transactions:** CST was specifically designed to tax interstate sales. By paying CST on your interstate purchase, you have already covered the tax obligation related to the movement of goods across state boundaries. The CST collected by the seller was meant to be a substitute for the local VAT, which would otherwise apply if the purchase was made within the same state.
2. **No Duplicate Taxation:** Allowing both CST and local VAT on the same transaction would result in double taxation. To avoid this, the tax system provided that interstate transactions, upon which CST is paid, would not be subject to additional local VAT.
3. **Excise Duty:** For interstate sales, excise duty was included in the price of the goods. This duty was intended to be part of the overall tax structure and was not a substitute for VAT but rather an additional tax on manufacture.
### **Illustrative Example:**
- Suppose you purchased goods worth ₹100,000 from another state. The seller charged you CST (2%) of ₹2,000 and included excise duty (12.5%) in the price.
- In this scenario, the CST of ₹2,000 was the tax applicable for the interstate movement of goods.
- You would not be liable to pay local VAT (14.5%) in Karnataka because the CST you paid already addressed the tax liability for that interstate purchase. Local VAT would apply only to intra-state transactions where goods are sold within the same state.
### **Key Points:**
- **Pre-GST System:** CST was used for interstate transactions, and you paid CST instead of local VAT. Hence, local VAT was not applicable.
- **Avoiding Double Taxation:** The system was designed to ensure that you did not pay both CST and local VAT on the same transaction.
### **Post-GST Transition:**
If you are referring to a situation post-GST (after July 1, 2017), the tax structure has changed:
- **IGST (Integrated GST):** For interstate sales under GST, IGST is applicable instead of CST. IGST covers both central and state tax components.
- **Input Tax Credit (ITC):** Under GST, you can claim input tax credit for the IGST paid, which avoids the need for local VAT.
In conclusion, under the pre-GST regime, the payment of CST for interstate purchases meant that you did not need to pay additional local VAT. The tax structure was designed to avoid double taxation and ensure that interstate transactions were taxed appropriately.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- REGARDING GST ON COMMERICIAL PROPERTY
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- 15ca /15cb whose income tax login? remitter or nri seller's login?
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- TDS U/S. 194NF
- Regarding Documentation & Compliances for Opening of Unit of Pvt Ltd.
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- REGARDING 25 AS DATE OF PAYMENT AND DATE OF BOOKING
- Short and Excess provision of expenses
- Issue of gst e invoice
- Interchangeable words in accounts
- Adjusted profit/Loss in the case of LLP and Pvt. Ltd.company
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
- 133(6) DIN INVALID format error - ->WHERE TO REPLY 133(6) notice?
- Query for dubts
- Regarding Resignation by Auditor from Pvt. Ltd.
- Regarding einvoice taken on nil rated sales
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
