Goodwill accounting - Please help
This query is : Resolved
11 September 2010
ABC is a partnership firm. The capital account balance of A as on 31/03/2010 is 10 lakhs.
On 1st April 2010, A retires from partnership.The firm pays Rs. 15 lakhs to A on his retirement and the accounts the balance 5 lakhs as goodwill in its books.
Is this 5 lakhs taxable in the hands of A?
There are so many case laws.some of them say it is taxable and others say it is not taxable. I am confused.Pleae help.
On 1st April 2010, A retires from partnership.The firm pays Rs. 15 lakhs to A on his retirement and the accounts the balance 5 lakhs as goodwill in its books.
Is this 5 lakhs taxable in the hands of A?
There are so many case laws.some of them say it is taxable and others say it is not taxable. I am confused.Pleae help.
12 September 2010
Excess amount received by Mr. A will not be taxable in their hands as per law declared by SC in case of R Lingmallu Raghukumar (247 ITR 801).
26 July 2024
The tax treatment of goodwill received by a retiring partner can indeed be complex and has been subject to varying interpretations and case laws. Let’s break down the situation and clarify the tax implications based on the current understanding.
### **Understanding the Scenario**
1. **Capital Account Balance**:
- **: ₹10 lakhs (A’s share of capital in the firm)
2. **On 1st April 2010**:
- **Payment to A**: ₹15 lakhs
- **Balance amount accounted as Goodwill**: ₹5 lakhs
### **Tax Implications**
**1. **Taxability of Goodwill Received by Retiring Partner**
The key issue is whether the amount received by the retiring partner, which includes the portion allocated as goodwill, is taxable in the hands of the partner. The Income Tax Act does not explicitly address this scenario, but several principles and case laws provide guidance.
**2. **Tax Treatment Based on Case Laws and Judgments**
**a. **Taxability of Amount Received**:
- **Generally**: The amount received by a partner on retirement that exceeds their capital account balance can be considered as a capital gain. The portion that exceeds the capital balance could be subject to tax as capital gains under Section 45 of the Income Tax Act.
- **Goodwill**: If the amount received includes a component attributed to goodwill, it is typically seen as a realization of goodwill and is potentially taxable. The calculation and taxability can depend on the nature of the payment and the specific circumstances.
**b. **Case Laws and Interpretations**:
- **Supreme Court Ruling**: In the case of **K.C. Kothiyal vs. CIT**, the Supreme Court held that a retiring partner is not taxed on the goodwill amount received if it represents a part of the firm’s asset distribution, which is a capital transaction rather than a revenue transaction.
- **Other Jurisprudence**: Some case laws have held that the retiring partner’s share of goodwill, being part of the firm’s assets, is not directly taxable as income. Instead, it is treated as part of the capital gains in the distribution of assets.
### **Accounting and Tax Treatment**
**1. **Goodwill as Part of the Capital Account**:
- **Capital Balance**: A's capital account balance is ₹10 lakhs.
- **Payment on Retirement**: ₹15 lakhs is paid to A, which includes the goodwill component.
**2. **Taxable Amount Calculation**:
- **Capital Account Balance**: ₹10 lakhs
- **Excess Payment**: ₹15 lakhs - ₹10 lakhs = ₹5 lakhs (this is the amount in excess of the capital account balance)
**3. **Goodwill Amount**:
- **Goodwill**: ₹5 lakhs (which is part of the total payment made)
**4. **Tax Filing Considerations**:
- **Capital Gains**: The ₹5 lakhs could be treated as a capital gain if it is deemed as realization of goodwill.
### **Steps for Tax Filing**
1. **Determine the Capital Gain**:
- Include the ₹5 lakhs in the calculation of capital gains if it represents the realization of goodwill.
2. **Report the Income**:
- Report the ₹5 lakhs as capital gains in the income tax return, considering the provisions for capital gains taxation.
3. **Seek Professional Advice**:
- Consult with a tax professional or advisor to ensure compliance with current tax laws and case law interpretations.
### **Summary**
- The ₹5 lakhs received as goodwill by A on retirement is generally subject to tax as capital gains, as it represents an excess amount received over the capital account balance.
- Case laws suggest that while goodwill itself may not be directly taxable as ordinary income, the excess payment could be subject to capital gains tax.
- Ensure proper documentation and seek advice from a tax professional to accurately handle the tax implications in compliance with current laws and interpretations.
### **Understanding the Scenario**
1. **Capital Account Balance**:
- **: ₹10 lakhs (A’s share of capital in the firm)
2. **On 1st April 2010**:
- **Payment to A**: ₹15 lakhs
- **Balance amount accounted as Goodwill**: ₹5 lakhs
### **Tax Implications**
**1. **Taxability of Goodwill Received by Retiring Partner**
The key issue is whether the amount received by the retiring partner, which includes the portion allocated as goodwill, is taxable in the hands of the partner. The Income Tax Act does not explicitly address this scenario, but several principles and case laws provide guidance.
**2. **Tax Treatment Based on Case Laws and Judgments**
**a. **Taxability of Amount Received**:
- **Generally**: The amount received by a partner on retirement that exceeds their capital account balance can be considered as a capital gain. The portion that exceeds the capital balance could be subject to tax as capital gains under Section 45 of the Income Tax Act.
- **Goodwill**: If the amount received includes a component attributed to goodwill, it is typically seen as a realization of goodwill and is potentially taxable. The calculation and taxability can depend on the nature of the payment and the specific circumstances.
**b. **Case Laws and Interpretations**:
- **Supreme Court Ruling**: In the case of **K.C. Kothiyal vs. CIT**, the Supreme Court held that a retiring partner is not taxed on the goodwill amount received if it represents a part of the firm’s asset distribution, which is a capital transaction rather than a revenue transaction.
- **Other Jurisprudence**: Some case laws have held that the retiring partner’s share of goodwill, being part of the firm’s assets, is not directly taxable as income. Instead, it is treated as part of the capital gains in the distribution of assets.
### **Accounting and Tax Treatment**
**1. **Goodwill as Part of the Capital Account**:
- **Capital Balance**: A's capital account balance is ₹10 lakhs.
- **Payment on Retirement**: ₹15 lakhs is paid to A, which includes the goodwill component.
**2. **Taxable Amount Calculation**:
- **Capital Account Balance**: ₹10 lakhs
- **Excess Payment**: ₹15 lakhs - ₹10 lakhs = ₹5 lakhs (this is the amount in excess of the capital account balance)
**3. **Goodwill Amount**:
- **Goodwill**: ₹5 lakhs (which is part of the total payment made)
**4. **Tax Filing Considerations**:
- **Capital Gains**: The ₹5 lakhs could be treated as a capital gain if it is deemed as realization of goodwill.
### **Steps for Tax Filing**
1. **Determine the Capital Gain**:
- Include the ₹5 lakhs in the calculation of capital gains if it represents the realization of goodwill.
2. **Report the Income**:
- Report the ₹5 lakhs as capital gains in the income tax return, considering the provisions for capital gains taxation.
3. **Seek Professional Advice**:
- Consult with a tax professional or advisor to ensure compliance with current tax laws and case law interpretations.
### **Summary**
- The ₹5 lakhs received as goodwill by A on retirement is generally subject to tax as capital gains, as it represents an excess amount received over the capital account balance.
- Case laws suggest that while goodwill itself may not be directly taxable as ordinary income, the excess payment could be subject to capital gains tax.
- Ensure proper documentation and seek advice from a tax professional to accurately handle the tax implications in compliance with current laws and interpretations.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- Inventory of finished goods
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- RCM INVOICING FROM NOV-2024
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- REGARDING 25 AS DATE OF PAYMENT AND DATE OF BOOKING
- Should I report my US salary for January, February, March in Schedule FA?
- Sale of property furniture sale
- Confusion around Form 26QB fields
- Adjustment entry in the case of Individual and HUF on 31st March
- LAST YEAR 2022-23 ITC IN NEXT YEAR 2023-24 REPORITNG IN GSTR-9
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- Issue of gst e invoice
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
- 133(6) DIN INVALID format error - ->WHERE TO REPLY 133(6) notice?
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
