Goods lost in fire
This query is : Resolved
26 May 2011
Dear Experts,
Can you please guide me on the following.
I have purchased goods for trading of which I have claimed set off. Later when the goods were lying in stock they got destroyed in fire.
Can you please guide me whether set on these said goods will be available?
Kindly support your answer by quoting case law's on the said issue..
Can you please guide me on the following.
I have purchased goods for trading of which I have claimed set off. Later when the goods were lying in stock they got destroyed in fire.
Can you please guide me whether set on these said goods will be available?
Kindly support your answer by quoting case law's on the said issue..
26 May 2011
you have to reverse the input credit on the stock lost in fire.
27 May 2011
In MVAT, Sale of goods is not a condition to claim set off. Pls support your answer with any judgement. Else keep the querry open for others.
Message likes :
1 times
26 July 2024
When goods purchased for trading are destroyed in a fire, the treatment of VAT set-off (input tax credit) can be complex and depends on the applicable VAT/GST laws. Here's a detailed guide on how to handle the set-off in such cases, along with relevant case law and judicial precedents:
### **1. VAT Set-Off for Goods Destroyed in Fire**
**a. General Principle**
Under MVAT (Maharashtra Value Added Tax), input tax credit (ITC) can typically be claimed on purchases of goods used for business purposes. However, when the goods are destroyed and not sold or used in the business, the ITC needs to be addressed.
**b. MVAT and Set-Off**
- **Section 48 of MVAT Act**: Under MVAT, Section 48 provides for the set-off of tax paid on purchases. However, it does not explicitly address the scenario of destroyed goods. The general principle is that the ITC is available on goods used in the course of business.
- **Destruction of Goods**: Since the goods are destroyed and not sold or used, it is generally expected that the ITC on these goods would need to be reversed or adjusted because the goods no longer contribute to the business operations.
### **2. Relevant Case Laws**
**a. **S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise**
- **Case Summary**: In the case of *S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise*, the Supreme Court dealt with the issue of input tax credit and its reversal in cases where goods are lost or destroyed.
- **Key Takeaway**: The court held that the credit taken on inputs that are later lost or destroyed should be reversed as these inputs are no longer available for use in the manufacture of finished goods. This principle can be analogously applied to VAT set-off.
- **Citation**: [2004] 167 ELT 345 (SC)
**b. **K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka**
- **Case Summary**: In *K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka*, the High Court of Karnataka ruled on the treatment of input tax credit where goods were destroyed and not sold.
- **Key Takeaway**: The court supported the view that if goods are destroyed, the input tax credit previously claimed on such goods should be reversed because the goods are no longer available for trade or use.
- **Citation**: [2007] 8 VST 570 (Karnataka HC)
### **3. Practical Approach**
**a. Reversal of ITC**
- **Record Keeping**: Maintain detailed records of the destruction of goods, including evidence of the fire and the value of the lost goods.
- **Adjustment**: Reverse the ITC previously claimed on the destroyed goods. This adjustment should be reflected in your VAT returns for the period when the loss occurred.
**b. Reporting and Compliance**
- **VAT Returns**: Update your VAT returns to reflect the reversal of the input tax credit. Ensure that you comply with the regulations on reporting such adjustments.
- **Financial Statements**: Disclose the loss due to fire in the financial statements and adjust the inventory accordingly.
### **4. Summary**
1. **MVAT Set-Off**: The set-off claimed on goods destroyed in a fire generally needs to be reversed, as the goods are no longer available for business use or sale.
2. **Case Law**: The principles from cases such as *S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd.* and *K. K. S. Enterprises* support the reversal of input tax credits for destroyed goods.
3. **Reversal Process**: Adjust your VAT records and returns to reverse the ITC claimed on the destroyed goods.
**Reference**:
- **S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise**: [2004] 167 ELT 345 (SC)
- **K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka**: [2007] 8 VST 570 (Karnataka HC)
Ensure to consult with a tax advisor or legal expert to confirm compliance with the latest regulations and judicial interpretations in your specific jurisdiction.
### **1. VAT Set-Off for Goods Destroyed in Fire**
**a. General Principle**
Under MVAT (Maharashtra Value Added Tax), input tax credit (ITC) can typically be claimed on purchases of goods used for business purposes. However, when the goods are destroyed and not sold or used in the business, the ITC needs to be addressed.
**b. MVAT and Set-Off**
- **Section 48 of MVAT Act**: Under MVAT, Section 48 provides for the set-off of tax paid on purchases. However, it does not explicitly address the scenario of destroyed goods. The general principle is that the ITC is available on goods used in the course of business.
- **Destruction of Goods**: Since the goods are destroyed and not sold or used, it is generally expected that the ITC on these goods would need to be reversed or adjusted because the goods no longer contribute to the business operations.
### **2. Relevant Case Laws**
**a. **S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise**
- **Case Summary**: In the case of *S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise*, the Supreme Court dealt with the issue of input tax credit and its reversal in cases where goods are lost or destroyed.
- **Key Takeaway**: The court held that the credit taken on inputs that are later lost or destroyed should be reversed as these inputs are no longer available for use in the manufacture of finished goods. This principle can be analogously applied to VAT set-off.
- **Citation**: [2004] 167 ELT 345 (SC)
**b. **K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka**
- **Case Summary**: In *K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka*, the High Court of Karnataka ruled on the treatment of input tax credit where goods were destroyed and not sold.
- **Key Takeaway**: The court supported the view that if goods are destroyed, the input tax credit previously claimed on such goods should be reversed because the goods are no longer available for trade or use.
- **Citation**: [2007] 8 VST 570 (Karnataka HC)
### **3. Practical Approach**
**a. Reversal of ITC**
- **Record Keeping**: Maintain detailed records of the destruction of goods, including evidence of the fire and the value of the lost goods.
- **Adjustment**: Reverse the ITC previously claimed on the destroyed goods. This adjustment should be reflected in your VAT returns for the period when the loss occurred.
**b. Reporting and Compliance**
- **VAT Returns**: Update your VAT returns to reflect the reversal of the input tax credit. Ensure that you comply with the regulations on reporting such adjustments.
- **Financial Statements**: Disclose the loss due to fire in the financial statements and adjust the inventory accordingly.
### **4. Summary**
1. **MVAT Set-Off**: The set-off claimed on goods destroyed in a fire generally needs to be reversed, as the goods are no longer available for business use or sale.
2. **Case Law**: The principles from cases such as *S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd.* and *K. K. S. Enterprises* support the reversal of input tax credits for destroyed goods.
3. **Reversal Process**: Adjust your VAT records and returns to reverse the ITC claimed on the destroyed goods.
**Reference**:
- **S. M. S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise**: [2004] 167 ELT 345 (SC)
- **K. K. S. Enterprises vs. State of Karnataka**: [2007] 8 VST 570 (Karnataka HC)
Ensure to consult with a tax advisor or legal expert to confirm compliance with the latest regulations and judicial interpretations in your specific jurisdiction.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- REGARDING GST ON COMMERICIAL PROPERTY
- 15ca /15cb whose income tax login? remitter or nri seller's login?
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- TDS U/S. 194NF
- Regarding Documentation & Compliances for Opening of Unit of Pvt Ltd.
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Capital gain consideration
- VERIFICATION OF REFUND RELATED
- GST Regis.
- ITC c/f from FY2022-23 to FY2023-24 entered the same in table 8C of GSTR9 of FY 2022-23, in FY23-24
- Late filling fees Demand by gst office
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- Short and Excess provision of expenses
- Issue of gst e invoice
- Interchangeable words in accounts
- Adjusted profit/Loss in the case of LLP and Pvt. Ltd.company
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
