Expenditure incurred for transfer of asset

This query is : Resolved

shubham (Querist)
Follow

20 May 2017 When sale of asset from the block of asset. Why we deduct the sales expenses from the sale value? Please tell me which example or logic.

CA CMA CS Ram Pavan Kumar Melam

CA CMA CS Ram Pavan Kumar Melam (Expert)
Follow

21 May 2017 Please refer section 50 of Income Tax Act, 1961

Message likes : 1 times

shubham

shubham (Querist)
Follow

21 May 2017 Dear sir, I read sec 50 but sir why act allowed for the deduction transfer expenditure from sale value..any logic behind that ?

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

24 July 2024 When calculating the taxable income or capital gains from the sale of an asset, it's important to deduct the expenses directly related to the transfer of that asset. Here’s why sales expenses are deducted from the sale value:

### Purpose of Deducting Sales Expenses:

1. **Cost of Acquisition Calculation**: The sales expenses incurred directly in relation to the transfer of an asset are treated as part of the cost of acquisition of that asset. This is crucial for accurately determining the capital gains or losses on the sale of the asset.

2. **Taxable Income Calculation**: Under tax laws, particularly in the context of capital gains tax, the taxable gain is computed as the difference between the sale proceeds (sale value) and the cost of acquisition (adjusted basis). Sales expenses reduce the sale proceeds, thereby reducing the taxable gain.

### Example and Logic:

Let’s consider a simplified example:

- **Asset Purchase**: You purchased machinery for ₹10L
- **Sales Process**: When you sell this machinery, you incur expenses such as brokerage fees (₹20,000), legal fees (₹10,000), and transportation charges (₹5,000) directly related to the sale.
- **Sale Price**: You sell the machinery for ₹12L

### Calculation without Deducting Sales Expenses:

- Sale Price: ₹12L
- Cost of Acquisition (without deducting expenses): ₹10L

Capital Gain = Sale Price - Cost of Acquisition
Capital Gain = ₹12L - ₹10L = ₹2L

### Calculation with Deducting Sales Expenses:

- Sale Price: ₹12L
- Cost of Acquisition (including deducted expenses): ₹10L + ₹20K + ₹10K + ₹5K = ₹10.35L

Capital Gain = Sale Price - Cost of Acquisition
Capital Gain = ₹12L - ₹10.35L = ₹1.65L

### Conclusion:

By deducting sales expenses (₹20K + ₹10K + ₹5K = ₹35K) from the sale value, you effectively adjust the cost basis of the asset. This adjustment accurately reflects the actual cost incurred in acquiring and transferring the asset, thereby reducing the taxable gain and ensuring that the tax liability is calculated correctly based on the net gain realized from the sale.

This approach aligns with tax principles that seek to tax the actual economic gain or profit realized from the sale of assets, after accounting for all direct costs associated with the transaction. It also ensures fairness in taxation by preventing overstatement of capital gains due to expenses directly attributable to the sale.