Delhi-vat on sale of capital asset

This query is : Resolved

Yogendra (Querist)
Follow

12 July 2014 I am registered as a Works Contractor under Composition Scheme of Delhi Value Added Tax with 3% tax liability.

I want to exchange my old car with a new car which has been used for personal as well as business use.

Depreciation benefit is being claimed on the car.

I want to know will there be any D-VAT liability on exchange of the old car? What would be the rate of tax?

Will I have to pay income tax also on exchange of old car?

On what amount would I be liable to pay VAT & Income Tax on? On the whole exchange consideration OR only on profit ( i.e. sale amount - value of car in books)?

What if I incur loss on exchange as per books? Will I still be liable to pay VAT/Income Tax?

Yogendra

Yogendra (Querist)
Follow

28 July 2014 Can anyone help me please?

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

20 July 2024 In Delhi, VAT (Value Added Tax) on the sale of capital assets, such as a car used for both personal and business purposes, depends on several factors:

1. **D-VAT Liability on Exchange of Old Car:**
- Under the Delhi VAT regime, the sale of a used car would typically be subject to VAT if you are registered under the Composition Scheme. The Composition Scheme usually prescribes a flat rate of tax (e.g., 3% in your case) on the total turnover or value of goods sold.
- When exchanging an old car for a new one, VAT would be applicable on the value of the old car. If you are selling the old car, the VAT would be levied on the consideration received or deemed received for the old car, subject to any adjustments for depreciation or market value.

2. **Rate of VAT:**
- The rate of VAT applicable in Delhi varies based on the nature of the goods and the scheme under which you are registered. For works contractors under the Composition Scheme, it's typically a fixed percentage (3% in your case).

3. **Income Tax on Exchange of Old Car:**
- For income tax purposes, the exchange of an old car for a new one can trigger tax implications depending on whether there is a capital gain or loss.
- If the exchange results in a profit (consideration received exceeds the book value of the old car), the profit would generally be subject to income tax under the head "Capital Gains."
- If there is a loss (book value exceeds consideration received), it can be adjusted against other capital gains or carried forward for set-off in subsequent years.

4. **Amount Subject to VAT and Income Tax:**
- VAT: Typically, VAT is applicable on the consideration received for the old car. If the old car is exchanged for a new one and there is a difference in value or consideration, VAT would be calculated on the net taxable value (consideration received or deemed received minus any adjustments).
- Income Tax: For income tax purposes, the tax liability arises on the capital gain, which is computed as the difference between the consideration received for the old car and its adjusted cost (usually the purchase price minus depreciation claimed).

5. **Loss on Exchange:**
- If you incur a loss on the exchange (consideration received is less than the adjusted cost), there would generally be no immediate VAT liability on the transaction because VAT is usually on the sales proceeds.
- For income tax, a loss on exchange can potentially reduce your taxable income in the year of the exchange or can be carried forward for set-off against future capital gains.

Given these considerations, it's advisable to consult with a tax advisor or accountant who can assess your specific situation, calculate the tax implications accurately, and guide you through the VAT and income tax requirements in Delhi based on the exchange of your old car for a new one. They can also help ensure compliance with both VAT and income tax laws, especially regarding the treatment of capital assets and any potential liabilities arising from their exchange.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!