28 July 2014
Dear Experts, Mr. X has sold some unlisted shares purchased in 2010-11. In the process he has made a profit. How will the same be taxed. Whether indexation can be applied to unlisted shares? Whether tax rate will be 10% or 20%? Thanks
18 July 2024
When it comes to taxation of capital gains from the sale of unlisted shares in India, here’s how it generally works:
### Taxation of Capital Gains on Unlisted Shares:
1. **Classification of Gains**: - **Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)**: If the unlisted shares are held for 3 years or less before selling, any gains from their sale will be treated as short-term capital gains. These are taxed at the applicable slab rates based on the total income of the individual.
- **Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)**: If the unlisted shares are held for more than 3 years before selling, the gains are classified as long-term capital gains. As per current tax laws, LTCG on unlisted shares is taxed at a special rate of 20%, with indexation benefit not available.
2. **Indexation Benefit**: - Indexation benefit allows adjusting the cost of acquisition (purchase price) of an asset against inflation using the Cost Inflation Index (CII) published by the Income Tax Department. This adjustment helps in reducing the taxable capital gains by accounting for inflation during the holding period. - However, indexation benefit is available only for certain assets like immovable properties and specified bonds, but not for unlisted shares.
3. **Tax Rates**: - **Short-Term Capital Gains**: Taxed at the applicable slab rates based on the total income of the individual. For example, if Mr. X falls under the 30% tax slab, his STCG from unlisted shares will be taxed at 30%.
- **Long-Term Capital Gains**: Taxed at a special rate of 20% (plus applicable surcharge and cess), without the benefit of indexation. This is a flat rate specifically applicable to long-term gains from the sale of unlisted shares.
### Logic of Denying Indexation Benefit for Unlisted Shares:
The rationale behind denying indexation benefit for unlisted shares primarily revolves around the nature of these investments:
- **Valuation Complexity**: Unlisted shares do not have a readily available market price like listed shares. Valuing them involves more subjective assessment and may not always reflect inflation-adjusted costs in a transparent manner.
- **Simplicity in Taxation**: Applying a flat rate of 20% for LTCG without indexation simplifies the tax computation process for unlisted shares. It eliminates the need for taxpayers and tax authorities to calculate and verify inflation-adjusted costs, which can be complex and prone to disputes.
- **Policy Considerations**: The tax treatment aims to balance revenue generation for the government while providing a predictable tax regime for investors in unlisted securities. The 20% tax rate ensures a stable and known tax liability for investors over the long-term holding period.
### Conclusion:
In summary, while gains from listed shares enjoy indexation benefits for LTCG calculations, unlisted shares are taxed at a flat rate of 20% for long-term gains without the benefit of indexation. This tax treatment aims to simplify taxation and ensure fairness in the treatment of different asset classes under the Income Tax Act. It’s important for taxpayers like Mr. X to consult with a tax advisor or chartered accountant to accurately compute and report their capital gains from unlisted shares based on their specific circumstances.
CAclubindia
