Dear Sir / Madam,

I am writing in reference to the subject matter that whether we should charge GST to ESIC Hospital in Kolkata? This is a Government tender and we have got this tender for next 3 (three) years after signing a mutual agreed contract. Section 12/2017 CGST Act. (Rate) mentioned that "Pure services (excluding works contract service or other composite supplies involving supply of any goods) provided
to the Central Government, State Government or Union territory or local authority or a Governmental authority" shall comes under the exempted service.

ESIC authority claiming exemption on the said service & as per notification this is a works contract service too, then what we have to do in such case.

Please clarify with your point

Sec 194J - when it is applicable and also threshold limit exceeds Rs.30,000/- during the year or Single Payment? . Kindly clarify the doubt

Dear GST Expert,

I have a query, Suppose We have Credit bal on GST portal since April'20 Say Rs. 25Lakhs...& Unpaid GST filing of Rs. 15 Lakhs in Aug'20 & 9.8 Lakhs in Sept'20.. I'm supposed to get interest on credit bal or will it be charged interest from Aug' & Sept; for unpaid Inv.

Plz justify & guide asap..

Thanks & Regards,
Bharti Sharma

Dear sir/ Madam,
We are supplied our product to Other country. My doubt is, in which head i have to fillup this sales in GSTR 1. Please suggest and clear my doubt

Respected Sir / Madam

Please let me know , what is investment in NPS,?

Where can we get deduction (under which section) for invetment in NPS?

Dear Sir,

Let me know the useful life of scaffolding system using for construction of buildings.

Regards
shanta Kumar

Bank have imposed cancellation charges on forward contract to us. what is the accounting treatment of it. Our forward contract comes under cash flow hedge.

Sir
I m a private medical professional. My wife also a doctor and retired few months back from govt job. Can I pay her salary from my clinic as an employee or for her services? Kindly advise me from IT point of view.

I had transferred 10 Lakh to my wife. She invested part of it in Shares and MF and she is doing business of share trading with the remaining amount.
My question are about clubbing of income:
1. I assume income (capital gain) if any received from share/MF investment will be clubbed with my income. am I right ?
2. What about her trading income. Will it be treated as her income or this also clubbed with my income?

Thanks in advance,
SD

Dear all,

Suppose "A" company is selling milk pouches to another "B" company. The milk pouches are sold in "returnable milk crates" which are returned by "B" to "A" on regular basis.

On one occasion, "B" fails to return 50 milk crates to "A".

"A", therefore, raises a debit note (@ Rs.200 per crate) on "B" for recovery of amount of lost crates.

Now, please answer whether GST is applicable to this debit notes in lights of the following points:
1) GST is not applicable on pouch milk sale
2) GST is applicable on "sale" of crates
3) The rate of Rs.200/- per crate is the cost to "A" (In other words, "A" is not making any profit on this transaction, it is just recovering the cost amount)
Thanks.