lingam
18 February 2026 at 12:03

SHORT AMOUNT GST PAID

Dear Sir/Madam,

We are into transportation services (GTA) we have supplied some taxable services to the customer but while filing we have shown as 5% RCM which was later amended as taxable services but again done mistake with 5% GST shown instead of 18% GST and now the bill is not amendable.

So if we cancel the bill and pass credit note and issue fresh bill is it acceptable or is there any other solutions.

Thanks & regards

Answer now

sakthees
18 February 2026 at 12:02

CREDIT NOTE ISSUES IN GST

We have issued credit note to our B2B customers from Tally. But in that docuement title showing 'Tax invoice' and other columns captured like document type showing Credit Note. Is there any misconfication to issues in this document to the customer ?.please clarify for Invoice, Credit Note, Debit Note and Bill of supply in GST.I think and assure the document type only classify above the same.
please clarify the follows:
1. If it is a normal sale with GST, document title should be “Tax Invoice”.
2. In GST, the document title and document type both matter, but what is legally important is the content and correct classification as per GST rules, not just the heading printed at the top.
3. Even if Tally header shows “Tax Invoice”, but voucher type is Credit Note and GST return is correctly adjusted, legally it works — however, best practice is to change the print title to “Credit Note” to avoid confusion for customer and auditor.

Answer now

Sunil Patnaik

Dear Sir/Madam,

I am seeking your expert opinion regarding the correct GST applicability, rate, and HSN classification for one of our products.
We are dealing with a product named “Millet-Based Probiotic Drink”, which is a packaged, non-alcoholic, fermented beverage made from millets, containing live probiotics. It is marketed as a spicy digestive/probiotic health drink, with zero sugar and zero preservatives.
There is confusion regarding whether this product should be classified as:
• a non-alcoholic beverage under Chapter 22, or
• a functional / probiotic / nutraceutical product under any other appropriate heading,
and accordingly, whether the applicable GST rate should be 5%, 12%, 18% or any other rate.

We request your guidance on:
1. The most appropriate HSN code for this product,
2. The correct GST rate applicable, and
3. Any relevant notifications, circulars, or case laws supporting the classification.
Your professional clarification will help us ensure correct compliance and avoid future disputes.
Looking forward to your valuable advice.

Answer now

Chirag H. Thakkar
05 January 2026 at 16:08

GST on Tobacco - as per new notification

I am a wholesaler of Raw Tobacco. What is the implication of the new notification no. 19/2025 dated 31/12/2025.
how to raise an invoice and how to show the excise?? Weather I have to apply for excise registration?

Answer now

ARCHANA

Sir/Mam,

Composition Dealer GST Annual Return Filing Due dates, what is penalty and is it mandatory

plz explain

Thanking you,

Answer now

Mahabir Prasad Agarwal

One of my GST client had expired during Feb.2025. Can his assistants/relatives file his pending GST returns ? Because many pending transactions (Sales) are to be executed at all cost.

Answer now

Suresh S. Tejwani
19 February 2025 at 13:48

Registered Required in GST Act

If Person is Unregistered in GST Act & Providing DSA Service & Earning 60 lakh Commission from NBFC.
Weather it is required to get registered under GST Act or RCM Provision is apply on NBFC.
if person take GST Number then on such commission income tax liability is on NBFC or Registered Person?

Answer now

komal ameta
17 February 2025 at 12:59

Switch over to Composition Scheme

Dear Experts,

If we switch to composition sceme from a regular tax payer scheme, what will be the steps we need to follow in case we have exempted outward supplies. We have reversed all our ITC till date.

Kindly reply for the steps we need to take and and the things we need to specifically take care in the procedure.

Thank you in advance, it is a great platform for seeking valuable advice.

Answer now

rishabh bhatia
17 February 2025 at 00:54

Gstr 9 and itc

Sir for FY 2020-21 I claimed itc related to fy 2019-20. There is difference arise in itc for FY 2020-21 for rs 4000
I not field annual return for FY 2019-20 and FY 2020-21 because it is optional for us
Now issue is AO is not satisfied with our claim to carry forward ITC and AO issued demand order against us claiming 4000 tax and 20000 penalty and 3000 int total 27000.
1)My concern is kya itc ek year ka next yr mai nhi le sakte yadi annual return nhi file ki hai
2)AO k 27000 k demand mai kya full payment krna padega

Answer now

Neha
15 February 2025 at 11:22

Clarification regarding IMS

Dear Sir/Madam
Plz guide
If my GSTR 2A is Showing record of an invoice of inward supply to me BUT I DO NOT DESIRE TO CLAIM ITS ITC of this Invoice in GSTR 3B. I will take full invoice value as an expense in accounts.
Do I need to REJECT this invoice in IMS ?
or let it remain in IMS. and not claim in GSTR 3B

Answer now





CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members

Follow us



Answer Query