04 July 2024
Individual A is a majority shareholder in Company C, which is a privately held company. In Aug 2023, C issues fresh shares to another company X. At the same time, C also issues Convertible Debentures to X where the conversion ratio is fixed at 1:1. The shares as well as the debentures are of face value Rs 10 but issued at Rs 300 (i.e. premium of Rs 290). X now holds 60% equity in C on a fully-diluted basis. Both C and X are Indian companies and A is also an Indian national.
In May 2024, C converts the debentures into shares. Immediately after conversion, A buys 45% of the holding from X at face value i.e. Rs 10 as X fails to meet some of the covenants agreed upon at the time of the issuance.
Considering that the shares which were originally valued at Rs 300 have now changed hands at Rs 10, is there any tax implication of the transfer either on A, C or X?
11 July 2024
Yes, there are potential tax implications arising from the transfer of shares between A and X, especially considering the difference between the original issuance price (Rs 300) and the subsequent transfer price (Rs 10).
Here's a breakdown of the tax implications for each party involved:
### 1. Company C (Issuer)
- **Tax Implications**: When Company C issued shares and debentures to X originally, it involved a premium of Rs 290 per share over the face value of Rs 10. This premium is typically treated as share premium and forms part of the reserves of the company. - **Tax Treatment**: The premium received on issuance of shares (Rs 290 per share) is not taxable as income under the Income Tax Act, as it is considered to be capital receipt. Therefore, there is no immediate tax implication for Company C when issuing the shares and debentures.
### 2. Company X (Investor)
- **Tax Implications**: Company X acquired shares and debentures from Company C at Rs 300 per share (including Rs 290 premium). - **Capital Gains Tax**: When Company X sells 45% of its holding to A at Rs 10 per share, there is a substantial reduction in the value from the original acquisition cost (Rs 300 per share). - **Capital Loss**: The difference between the sale price (Rs 10) and the acquisition cost (Rs 300) results in a capital loss for Company X. - **Tax Treatment**: Capital losses can generally be set off against capital gains in the same year or carried forward for future years to offset capital gains. Company X can utilize this capital loss for tax purposes.
### 3. Individual A
- **Tax Implications**: A purchases shares from X at Rs 10 per share. - **Capital Gains for A**: Although A is acquiring shares at a significantly lower price (Rs 10 per share), the tax implications for A arise from the perspective of the seller (Company X). - **Cost of Acquisition**: A's cost of acquisition is Rs 10 per share. - **Potential Tax on Capital Gains for X**: If X had any capital gains on the original acquisition of shares and now realizes a capital loss, X may face implications accordingly.
### Summary
- **Company C**: No immediate tax implication on issuance of shares and debentures. - **Company X**: Capital loss can be utilized for tax purposes. - **Individual A**: The purchase at a lower value (Rs 10 per share) may result in implications for the seller (X) depending on X's original acquisition cost.
It's important for Company X to accurately account for the capital loss and report it correctly in their tax filings to benefit from tax relief. As always, tax implications can vary based on specific circumstances and should be reviewed with a tax advisor to ensure compliance with tax laws and optimization of tax benefits.
CAclubindia
