Subject exemption 2012 syllabus
This query is : Resolved
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
26 August 2014
I am pursuing ICWA. Gave an attempt for june 14 inter group I exams (2012 syllabus). My marks are as follows
Paper 5 - 32 (Financial Accounting)
Paper 6 - 61 (Law)
Paper 7 - 27 (Direct Taxation)
Paper 8 - 24 (costing)
Will I get exemption for paper 6 i.e Law and if i give an attempt for Dec 2014 exams what will my pass criteria.
Can any one please clarify.
Thanks in advance
Paper 5 - 32 (Financial Accounting)
Paper 6 - 61 (Law)
Paper 7 - 27 (Direct Taxation)
Paper 8 - 24 (costing)
Will I get exemption for paper 6 i.e Law and if i give an attempt for Dec 2014 exams what will my pass criteria.
Can any one please clarify.
Thanks in advance
26 August 2014
A candidate who obtains more than 60% of marks in any paper or papers shall be exempted from appearing in that paper in the subsequent examinations. The candidate is required to obtain a minimum of 40% in each paper and an aggregate of 50% in the total of the remaining subjects of the stage in the subsequent examinations.
26 August 2014
Example:
An Attempt
Say a student has obtained the following marks in an examination
I - 65, II - 40, III - 43, IV - 42 Total = 190. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
Since the student has got marks ≥ 60% in Paper I and has also got the minimum required in other papers i.e. ≥ 40% in Papers II, III and IV, he/she will be exempted from appearing in Paper I in the subsequent examinations.
In the next exam the candidate is required to appear only in papers II, III, and IV and get a minimum of 40% and aggregate of 50% (total of 150) in the papers II, III, and IV together.
Next Attempt:
Say the student has obtained the following marks in the subsequent exam
Case 1
The student may obtain marks required to pass the examination.
II - 54, III - 58, IV - 42. Total = 154. Aggregate ≥ 50% ⇒ Pass
Case 2
The student may fail the examination but still obtain an exemption in one more paper.
II - 44, III - 60, IV - 42. Total = 146. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
The student fails the examination. Here there is a scope for exemption in Paper III since the student obtained ≥ 60% and has got a minimum of 40% in the other two papers.
In the next exam the stduent is required to appear only in Papers II and IV and get a minimum of 40% and aggregate of 50% (total of 100) in the papers II and IV together.
Case 3
The student may fail the examination and has got not new exemptions.
II - 38, III - 65, IV - 42. Total = 145. Aggregate ≥ 50% and Failed in Paper II ⇒ Fail
An Attempt
Say a student has obtained the following marks in an examination
I - 65, II - 40, III - 43, IV - 42 Total = 190. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
Since the student has got marks ≥ 60% in Paper I and has also got the minimum required in other papers i.e. ≥ 40% in Papers II, III and IV, he/she will be exempted from appearing in Paper I in the subsequent examinations.
In the next exam the candidate is required to appear only in papers II, III, and IV and get a minimum of 40% and aggregate of 50% (total of 150) in the papers II, III, and IV together.
Next Attempt:
Say the student has obtained the following marks in the subsequent exam
Case 1
The student may obtain marks required to pass the examination.
II - 54, III - 58, IV - 42. Total = 154. Aggregate ≥ 50% ⇒ Pass
Case 2
The student may fail the examination but still obtain an exemption in one more paper.
II - 44, III - 60, IV - 42. Total = 146. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
The student fails the examination. Here there is a scope for exemption in Paper III since the student obtained ≥ 60% and has got a minimum of 40% in the other two papers.
In the next exam the stduent is required to appear only in Papers II and IV and get a minimum of 40% and aggregate of 50% (total of 100) in the papers II and IV together.
Case 3
The student may fail the examination and has got not new exemptions.
II - 38, III - 65, IV - 42. Total = 145. Aggregate ≥ 50% and Failed in Paper II ⇒ Fail
26 August 2014
Carry Forward [Second Method]
The student is exempted from appearing in the paper in which he obtains the high marks. The marks of the student in that paper would be carried forward to the next examinations. The student would be required to obtain the minimum marks and the aggregate in all the papers of the group/stage taking into consideration the same marks obtained in the paper in which he has obtained the high mark.
This method works on the premise that the paper whose marks are allowed to be carried forward has been alloted the same marks in the subsequent examinations also. Therefore it amounts to having appeared in all the papers including the paper whose marks are carried forward. The rule of 40% minimum in each paper and 50% aggregate should be applied accordingly to all the papers by including the carried forward marks.
A candidate who obtains more than 60% of marks in any paper or papers and a minimum of 40% of marks in all the other papers shall be exempted from appearing in that paper in the subsequent examinations and will be eligible for availing the benefit of carry forward of marks.
The candidate is required to obtain a minimum of 40% in each of the remaining papers and an aggregate of 50% in the total of all the subjects of the stage including the ones in which he was exempted by taking into consideration the same mark for the subjects in which he was exempted.
The student is exempted from appearing in the paper in which he obtains the high marks. The marks of the student in that paper would be carried forward to the next examinations. The student would be required to obtain the minimum marks and the aggregate in all the papers of the group/stage taking into consideration the same marks obtained in the paper in which he has obtained the high mark.
This method works on the premise that the paper whose marks are allowed to be carried forward has been alloted the same marks in the subsequent examinations also. Therefore it amounts to having appeared in all the papers including the paper whose marks are carried forward. The rule of 40% minimum in each paper and 50% aggregate should be applied accordingly to all the papers by including the carried forward marks.
A candidate who obtains more than 60% of marks in any paper or papers and a minimum of 40% of marks in all the other papers shall be exempted from appearing in that paper in the subsequent examinations and will be eligible for availing the benefit of carry forward of marks.
The candidate is required to obtain a minimum of 40% in each of the remaining papers and an aggregate of 50% in the total of all the subjects of the stage including the ones in which he was exempted by taking into consideration the same mark for the subjects in which he was exempted.
26 August 2014
Example:
An Attempt
Say a student has obtained the following marks in an examination
I - 65, II - 40, III - 43, IV - 42 Total = 190. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
Since the student has got marks ≥ 60% in Paper I and has also got the minimum required in other papers i.e. ≥ 40% in Papers II, III and IV, he/she will be given the benefit of carry forward of marks obtained in Paper I.
In the next exam the candidate is required to appear only in papers II, III, and IV and get a minimum of 40% and a total of 135 in the papers II, III, and IV together to make the aggregate 50% in all the papers including the paper whose marks were carried forward.
This provision is applied as if you got the same mark in every examination in that paper in which you have obtained the high marks.
Next Attempt:
Say the student has obtained the following marks in the subsequent exam
Case 1
The student may obtain marks required to pass the examination.
II - 55, III - 48, IV - 42. Total = 145.
Aggregate ≥ 50% (210 i.e. 145 + 65) ⇒ Pass
Case 2
The student may fail the examination but still obtain an exemption in another paper.
II - 35, III - 60, IV - 42. Total = 137.
Failed in Paper II ⇒ Fail
The student fails the examination. Here there is a scope for exemption in Paper III since the student obtained ≥ 60%.
In the next exam the stduent is required to appear only in Papers II and IV and get a minimum of 40% and a total of 85 to make an aggregate of 50% (total of 150) in the papers he/she has to appear as well as whose marks are allowed to be carried forward i.e. in the papers II and IV together.
There is no scope for thinking of a case where the student gets carry forward since in such a case he/she would pass the exam [First exam: 60 marks; next exam 40 + 40 + 60 = 140]
Case 3
The student may fail the examination and has got not new exemptions.
II - 38, III - 55, IV - 42. Total = 135.
Failed in a subject ⇒ Fail
An Attempt
Say a student has obtained the following marks in an examination
I - 65, II - 40, III - 43, IV - 42 Total = 190. Aggregate < 50% ⇒ Fail
Since the student has got marks ≥ 60% in Paper I and has also got the minimum required in other papers i.e. ≥ 40% in Papers II, III and IV, he/she will be given the benefit of carry forward of marks obtained in Paper I.
In the next exam the candidate is required to appear only in papers II, III, and IV and get a minimum of 40% and a total of 135 in the papers II, III, and IV together to make the aggregate 50% in all the papers including the paper whose marks were carried forward.
This provision is applied as if you got the same mark in every examination in that paper in which you have obtained the high marks.
Next Attempt:
Say the student has obtained the following marks in the subsequent exam
Case 1
The student may obtain marks required to pass the examination.
II - 55, III - 48, IV - 42. Total = 145.
Aggregate ≥ 50% (210 i.e. 145 + 65) ⇒ Pass
Case 2
The student may fail the examination but still obtain an exemption in another paper.
II - 35, III - 60, IV - 42. Total = 137.
Failed in Paper II ⇒ Fail
The student fails the examination. Here there is a scope for exemption in Paper III since the student obtained ≥ 60%.
In the next exam the stduent is required to appear only in Papers II and IV and get a minimum of 40% and a total of 85 to make an aggregate of 50% (total of 150) in the papers he/she has to appear as well as whose marks are allowed to be carried forward i.e. in the papers II and IV together.
There is no scope for thinking of a case where the student gets carry forward since in such a case he/she would pass the exam [First exam: 60 marks; next exam 40 + 40 + 60 = 140]
Case 3
The student may fail the examination and has got not new exemptions.
II - 38, III - 55, IV - 42. Total = 135.
Failed in a subject ⇒ Fail
26 August 2014
Exempted in all papers except one
Special Case
Where a student who has got exemptions in all the papers of a group and has failed in one of the papers of the group, he will be declared to have passed the group if he obtains a minimum of 40% in the paper in which he failed.
Example:
An attempt:
I - 69, II - 75, III - 65, IV - 30 Total = 239.Aggregate > 50% ⇒ Fail
In the subsequent exams you need to appear only in IV and obtain a minimum of 40% in it to pass in the group.
Special Case
Where a student who has got exemptions in all the papers of a group and has failed in one of the papers of the group, he will be declared to have passed the group if he obtains a minimum of 40% in the paper in which he failed.
Example:
An attempt:
I - 69, II - 75, III - 65, IV - 30 Total = 239.Aggregate > 50% ⇒ Fail
In the subsequent exams you need to appear only in IV and obtain a minimum of 40% in it to pass in the group.
26 August 2014
Before taking any decision.....u must check urself too...... Below is the link of ICMAI Website...... U must also see this:
http://icmai.in/studentswebsite/exemption_Syll2012.php
http://icmai.in/studentswebsite/exemption_Syll2012.php
Querist : Anonymous
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist)
08 September 2014
You will claim exemption for LAW for 3 attempts only.
Confirmed from chapters exam branch
Confirmed from chapters exam branch
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Tax on capital gains revoked us 54f
- Should I include march foreign salary received in April in my income for FY 2023-24?
- Inventory of finished goods
- Filing of Form 10BB instead of Filing Form 10B
- Sale of property furniture sale
- Confusion around Form 26QB fields
- Quiery in relation to GST liability in case of an advocate who has obtained GST registration.
- Refund of AY 22-23
- Disallowance of Section 43B(h) to sez units
- Applicability of Ind As to associate of associate
- Last year input claim shown in gstr9
- GST Registration Cancellation books of accounts asked by officer
- TDS Deduction Online Learing Platform
- Point (III) 9 of GSTR-9C
- As per our records, find the below outstanding demand(s)* and interest payable u/s 220(2):
- Regarding transaction th. credit card
- HSN Details in IFF/GSTR-1 & in GSTR 9
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
