26 November 2022
the officer issued an SCN jul 2017 to mar-2018 regarding RCM on Mining Royalty but Drop the processing of that SCN saying that the SCN was wrongly issued after this, a new SCN is issued for the same period or same matter in which tax has been issued for more tax than the earlier SCN. can SCN of same duration be issued on same issue with more demand please guide me.
10 July 2024
In your situation, it appears that the tax officer initially issued a Show Cause Notice (SCN) related to Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) on Mining Royalty for the period July 2017 to March 2018. However, the processing of this SCN was dropped because it was deemed to be incorrectly issued. Subsequently, a new SCN was issued for the same period or matter, but this time with a higher tax demand than the earlier SCN.
### Understanding the Issuance of SCN:
1. **Validity of SCN on the Same Issue:** - Under GST laws, a tax authority can issue multiple SCNs for the same period or matter if there are valid reasons to do so. The fact that a previous SCN was dropped does not preclude the tax authority from issuing a fresh SCN if they believe there are grounds to reassess or re-examine the tax liability.
2. **Increase in Tax Demand:** - The new SCN with a higher tax demand indicates that the tax authority has either found additional grounds for taxing certain transactions or has revised their assessment of the tax liability based on new information or interpretations of the law.
3. **Legal Considerations:** - While there is no specific prohibition against issuing a new SCN with a higher tax demand for the same period or matter, the tax authority must justify any increase in the tax demand based on solid grounds such as new evidence, legal interpretations, or corrections to previous assessments.
4. **Defending Against the SCN:** - As a recipient of the SCN, you have the right to respond with relevant documentation, explanations, and legal arguments to contest the tax demand. This includes demonstrating compliance with GST laws, providing evidence of correct tax treatment, and addressing any factual or procedural inaccuracies.
5. **Consultation with Tax Experts:** - Given the complexities involved in responding to an SCN, especially when it involves multiple issuances or revised tax demands, it is advisable to seek advice from tax experts or legal professionals who specialize in GST matters. They can help review the SCN, assess the grounds for the tax demand, and prepare a robust response on your behalf.
### Conclusion: While a new SCN with a higher tax demand for the same period or matter can be issued by the tax authority, it must be supported by valid reasons and comply with legal requirements. As the recipient of the SCN, it is crucial to understand the basis of the tax demand, gather relevant evidence, and respond comprehensively to protect your interests and rights under GST regulations.
CAclubindia
