Non monetary consideration & service tax basis

This query is : Resolved

vijay (Querist)
Follow

14 February 2013
Company-A is a BPO
Company-B is a Spa, Health care, Surgical massage centre
Relationship between companies is common directors
Company A Entered into lease agreement for 3 blocks individually in one floor, It occupied 2Blocks and 1 is allowed to company-B to run its business inconsideration that Newly recruited employees of Company-A will be sent to get few checkups & Tests for free of cost as part of Hiring process, counseling.

So what how the service tax liability can be determined.
1.Whether rent amount basis or similar type of service consideration in money or its cost?
2. Is your answer would change if only part block is allowed to use.?

Madhukar N Hiregange

Madhukar N Hiregange (Expert)
Follow

15 February 2013 Rent = to value of comparable service.

vijay

vijay (Querist)
Follow

15 February 2013 Dear expert,
You have not answered the 2nd question
Isn't it difficult to determine part of block rent?

don't close d query in hurry

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

03 August 2024 In the scenario where Company-A (a BPO) leases part of its property to Company-B (a spa, healthcare, and surgical massage center) and receives non-monetary consideration in the form of free services, the service tax implications need to be carefully assessed. Here's a detailed explanation addressing both questions:

### **1. **Service Tax Liability Determination**

#### **Non-Monetary Consideration**

When services or goods are provided in exchange for non-monetary consideration, service tax needs to be assessed based on the fair market value of the services received.

**1.1 **Service Tax Based on Non-Monetary Consideration**

- **Fair Market Value**: For non-monetary consideration, such as free services, the service tax liability is typically determined based on the fair market value of the services received.

- **Rental Basis**: In this case, you need to assess the fair market value of the services provided by Company-B (such as free checkups, tests, or counseling) and compare it to the rental value of the property. The value of these free services will be treated as consideration for the lease of the property and will be subject to service tax.

- **Example Calculation**: If Company-B provides services worth ₹1,00,000 as a part of the agreement, and the rent for the leased property is ₹1,00,000, then the service tax will be based on the value of the services received, assuming they are comparable to the rental value.

**1.2 **Determination Method**

- **Lease Value vs. Service Value**: The critical point is to determine if the value of the services provided (free checkups, tests) is equivalent to or exceeds the rental value. If the services are comparable to the rent, then service tax should be calculated on this equivalent value.

### **2. **Impact of Leasing Part of the Block**

**2.1 **Leasing Partial Block**

If Company-A only allows Company-B to use part of the leased block:

- **Proportional Rent Adjustment**: Service tax liability should be based on the proportionate value of the rent attributed to the area used by Company-B. For example, if Company-B uses one-third of the block, the rent and the corresponding value of the free services should be adjusted accordingly.

- **Calculation Example**: If the total rent for the three blocks is ₹3,00,000, and Company-B occupies one block (one-third), then the rent attributable to Company-B is ₹1,00,000. Similarly, the value of the free services provided should be proportionate to the area used.

- **Determining Value**: If Company-B uses only a part of the block, the calculation should reflect the value of services and the rent attributable to the part used. The fair market value of the services provided should be compared to the proportional rent to determine the service tax liability.

### **Summary**

1. **Service Tax Basis**: The service tax liability for non-monetary consideration should be based on the fair market value of the services received. If the value of the services provided by Company-B is comparable to or exceeds the rental value, then the service tax should be based on this value.

2. **Part Block Leasing**: If only part of the block is leased, the rent and service value should be prorated accordingly. The service tax liability should reflect the proportionate rent and the fair market value of the services provided.

In both scenarios, it's crucial to ensure accurate valuation of the services received and to comply with the service tax regulations. Consulting a tax professional for detailed calculations and compliance is advisable to handle such complex transactions effectively.