Mutuality of interest
This query is : Resolved
17 May 2013
We have formed a cooperative society for employees of a particular company. The society is formed for sale of consumables to members only in township campus and for loan to its members. No outsider are allowed to purchase anything from society. Wheather the income of seciety will be taxable or concept of mutual concern apply in this case.
Regards,
CA Sandeep Aggarwal
Regards,
CA Sandeep Aggarwal
11 June 2013
Dear Experts
kindly suggest me on the issue.
Regards,
CA Sandeep aggarwal
kindly suggest me on the issue.
Regards,
CA Sandeep aggarwal
03 August 2024
In the case of a cooperative society formed for employees of a particular company and operated within a specific township, the concept of mutuality is highly relevant. Here’s a breakdown of how mutuality of interest impacts the taxability of such a society:
### **1. Concept of Mutuality**
- **Definition:** The principle of mutuality holds that if an organization’s income is derived from transactions with its members and is used for the benefit of its members, such income may not be taxable. This is based on the idea that the members of the organization are both contributors and recipients of the benefits.
### **2. Applicability to Cooperative Societies**
- **Members-Only Transactions:** If a cooperative society is formed exclusively for the benefit of its members (e.g., employees of a specific company) and the transactions are only with and for the benefit of its members, the principle of mutuality may apply.
- **Example:** Selling consumables only to members and providing loans exclusively to members.
- **Taxability Criteria:**
- **Income from Members:** Income derived from transactions with members is generally considered not taxable, provided it is distributed among the members and used for their benefit.
- **Income from Non-Members:** If the cooperative society earns income from non-members or engages in transactions outside its mutual membership, that income may be subject to tax.
- **Surplus Utilization:** The surplus generated should be used for the benefit of the members, and not distributed as profit. This helps in maintaining the principle of mutuality.
### **3. Tax Implications**
- **Income Not Taxable Under Mutuality:**
- If the cooperative society’s income is derived solely from its members and is used for their benefit, it is generally not subject to income tax under the principle of mutuality.
- The cooperative society must ensure that all activities and income are within the scope of mutuality to claim this exemption.
- **Taxable Income:**
- Any income generated from sources outside the membership or from non-members is taxable.
- If the society engages in activities that do not strictly adhere to the mutuality principle (e.g., business transactions with outsiders), such income will be taxable.
### **4. Compliance and Documentation**
- **Documentation:** The cooperative society should maintain clear records of transactions, showing that all activities are conducted with and for the benefit of its members.
- **Income Tax Filing:** Ensure proper documentation and reporting of income and expenses in the society’s income tax return, adhering to the guidelines for mutual organizations.
### **5. Example Scenario:**
- **Cooperative Society Setup:** A cooperative society is formed exclusively for employees of a company. It sells consumables and provides loans only to its members.
- **Income from Consumables and Loans:** Since the income is derived from transactions with members and is used for their benefit, it generally falls under the mutuality principle and is not taxable.
- **Verification:** It is crucial to verify that all transactions and benefits are in compliance with the mutuality principle.
### **6. Conclusion**
- **Mutual Concern Principle:** If the cooperative society’s operations and income are strictly within the bounds of mutuality, where all transactions are with members and benefits are for their advantage, the income is generally not taxable.
- **Professional Advice:** For specific guidance, especially in complex cases or if there are doubts about compliance, consult a tax professional or legal advisor.
This ensures that the cooperative society adheres to the mutuality principle and correctly applies tax rules.
### **1. Concept of Mutuality**
- **Definition:** The principle of mutuality holds that if an organization’s income is derived from transactions with its members and is used for the benefit of its members, such income may not be taxable. This is based on the idea that the members of the organization are both contributors and recipients of the benefits.
### **2. Applicability to Cooperative Societies**
- **Members-Only Transactions:** If a cooperative society is formed exclusively for the benefit of its members (e.g., employees of a specific company) and the transactions are only with and for the benefit of its members, the principle of mutuality may apply.
- **Example:** Selling consumables only to members and providing loans exclusively to members.
- **Taxability Criteria:**
- **Income from Members:** Income derived from transactions with members is generally considered not taxable, provided it is distributed among the members and used for their benefit.
- **Income from Non-Members:** If the cooperative society earns income from non-members or engages in transactions outside its mutual membership, that income may be subject to tax.
- **Surplus Utilization:** The surplus generated should be used for the benefit of the members, and not distributed as profit. This helps in maintaining the principle of mutuality.
### **3. Tax Implications**
- **Income Not Taxable Under Mutuality:**
- If the cooperative society’s income is derived solely from its members and is used for their benefit, it is generally not subject to income tax under the principle of mutuality.
- The cooperative society must ensure that all activities and income are within the scope of mutuality to claim this exemption.
- **Taxable Income:**
- Any income generated from sources outside the membership or from non-members is taxable.
- If the society engages in activities that do not strictly adhere to the mutuality principle (e.g., business transactions with outsiders), such income will be taxable.
### **4. Compliance and Documentation**
- **Documentation:** The cooperative society should maintain clear records of transactions, showing that all activities are conducted with and for the benefit of its members.
- **Income Tax Filing:** Ensure proper documentation and reporting of income and expenses in the society’s income tax return, adhering to the guidelines for mutual organizations.
### **5. Example Scenario:**
- **Cooperative Society Setup:** A cooperative society is formed exclusively for employees of a company. It sells consumables and provides loans only to its members.
- **Income from Consumables and Loans:** Since the income is derived from transactions with members and is used for their benefit, it generally falls under the mutuality principle and is not taxable.
- **Verification:** It is crucial to verify that all transactions and benefits are in compliance with the mutuality principle.
### **6. Conclusion**
- **Mutual Concern Principle:** If the cooperative society’s operations and income are strictly within the bounds of mutuality, where all transactions are with members and benefits are for their advantage, the income is generally not taxable.
- **Professional Advice:** For specific guidance, especially in complex cases or if there are doubts about compliance, consult a tax professional or legal advisor.
This ensures that the cooperative society adheres to the mutuality principle and correctly applies tax rules.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Inventory of finished goods
- GST ON EXPORT COMMISSION
- RCM INVOICING FROM NOV-2024
- REGARDING 25 AS DATE OF PAYMENT AND DATE OF BOOKING
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- ITC EXCESS CLAIM + RCM NOT PAID...BOTH FOR FY 2020-21......PAID IN FY 2024-25....EFFECT
- LAST YEAR 2022-23 ITC IN NEXT YEAR 2023-24 REPORITNG IN GSTR-9
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- Issue of gst e invoice
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
- 133(6) DIN INVALID format error - ->WHERE TO REPLY 133(6) notice?
- Query for dubts
- Regarding einvoice taken on nil rated sales
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
