Investing in a private limited company

This query is : Resolved

Jasdeep Singh (Querist)
Follow

04 December 2012 Hi friends I am new here so please bear with me, here is situation, I am going to invest in a pvt. ltd. company of my friend which was formed in 2010 but not doing any major business activity till date. It has 2 founding shareholders as directors. They are also going to do a fresh investment into it. We deciced to investment equal amount of money and My wife will be appointed as one of the 2 director of the company. (one present director will resign), Now my questions is: What is the more secure and better way for me to invest in it, as our accountant had suggested 2 options, one is buying the shares equal to the amount invested after calculating the per share value and second is that I can invest in it by giving a loan to director (my wife) at agreed rate of intrest and period thus without having any share in the company. I want to know which is the better and secure option for me, giving loan or buying equity, what the legalities involved. Do I need to look into MOA & AOA of the company for this. One thing more, me and my firend both are going to work together for the growth of company and also will exanpd in coming years.

Rasesh

Rasesh (Expert)
Follow

04 December 2012 If you are serious about the business, the option of investing in equity is better.

You are on high risk but the rewards are also in your favour.

Rasesh

Rasesh (Expert)
Follow

04 December 2012 If you are serious about the business, the option of investing in equity is better.

You are on high risk but the rewards are also in your favour.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Jasdeep Singh

Jasdeep Singh (Querist)
Follow

05 December 2012 Thanks for the reply,
What documents need to be prepared I mean do we need any change in MOA, AOA or any other agreement. Also how share will be allotted, by creating a fresh equity or transfer from other shareholders.

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

01 August 2024 Investing in a private limited company involves several considerations, especially when it comes to choosing between buying shares and providing a loan. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you understand the options and legalities involved:

### **1. **Options for Investment:**

**A. Buying Shares:**

**Pros:**
- **Ownership and Control:** You will own a part of the company and have a say in its decisions, depending on the percentage of shares you hold.
- **Potential for Growth:** As a shareholder, you may benefit from the company's growth through dividends and capital appreciation.

**Cons:**
- **Risk:** Your investment is at risk, and the value of shares may fluctuate based on the company's performance.
- **Dilution:** If the company issues more shares in the future, your ownership percentage may be diluted.

**Process:**
- **Valuation:** Determine the per-share value based on the company’s valuation.
- **Share Allotment:** Shares can be allotted either by issuing new shares or by transferring existing shares from current shareholders.
- **Documentation:** Amendments to the Memorandum of Association (MOA) and Articles of Association (AOA) may be required. Prepare a Shareholders' Agreement to outline the rights and obligations of shareholders.

**B. Providing a Loan:**

**Pros:**
- **Fixed Return:** You receive interest payments as per the agreed terms, which may provide a predictable return.
- **Priority in Repayment:** In the event of liquidation, loans are typically repaid before equity holders.

**Cons:**
- **No Ownership:** You won’t have ownership or voting rights in the company.
- **Repayment Risk:** The company must repay the loan as per the agreed terms, which may be a risk if the company faces financial difficulties.

**Process:**
- **Loan Agreement:** Draft a detailed loan agreement specifying the interest rate, repayment schedule, and any security interests.
- **Documentation:** Ensure that the loan terms are documented and legally binding.

### **2. **Legalities and Documentation:**

**A. **Amending MOA and AOA:**

- **MOA (Memorandum of Association):** May need to be amended if new objects or changes in the company’s business activities are required.
- **AOA (Articles of Association):** May need to be amended to reflect changes in share capital, appointment of new directors, and rights of new shareholders.

**B. **Shareholder’s Agreement:**

- **Purpose:** Outlines the rights, responsibilities, and obligations of shareholders. It may include clauses on voting rights, dividend distribution, and exit strategies.

**C. **Director’s Appointment:**

- **Resolution:** Pass a board resolution for the appointment of your wife as a director and the resignation of the current director.
- **Filing:** File necessary forms with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) to update the board of directors.

**D. **Share Allotment:**

- **New Shares vs. Transfer:**
- **New Shares:** Issue new shares to you and your friend as per the agreed investment amount. This may require increasing the authorized share capital.
- **Transfer of Existing Shares:** Existing shareholders may transfer their shares to you. This involves a share transfer agreement and updating the company’s register of shareholders.

**E. **Investment Documentation:**

- **Investment Agreement:** Document the terms of your investment, including the amount, form (equity or loan), and conditions.
- **Loan Agreement (if applicable):** Detail the terms of the loan, including interest rate, repayment schedule, and any security.

### **3. **Key Considerations:**

- **Consult Legal and Financial Experts:** Engage with legal and financial professionals to ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations.
- **Due Diligence:** Perform thorough due diligence on the company’s financials, legal standing, and business prospects.
- **Future Planning:** Consider the company’s future funding needs and how your investment aligns with its growth strategy.

### **Summary:**

- **Buying Shares:** Offers ownership and potential benefits but involves risks. Requires amending MOA, AOA, and preparing a Shareholders' Agreement.
- **Providing a Loan:** Offers a fixed return with lower risk but no ownership rights. Requires a detailed Loan Agreement.

Your decision should be based on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and involvement in the company's operations. Ensure all legal and financial documents are correctly prepared and filed to protect your interests.