01 December 2008
Hi every one, I was undergoing articles where in, i was encountered with the following problem
Facts of the case: a)x & y - Both of them are hubsand and wife, b)Mrs.x, owns a property c)It was given on rent to his husband, Y d)The house property is being used by both of them for self occupance purpose but not for any other purpose e)y is paying monthly rental payments to Mrs.x
1)My question is whether it can be treated as source in the hands of Mrs.x 2)If the above, is correct whether it is chargeable under the head "House Property" in the hands of Mrs.x 3)What will be the situation if "Y" is in reciept of HRA & what if not?
Please help me out from this problem I look out for our response much earlier as possible With regards, K.Vinod.
28 July 2024
Let's break down the taxation issue with the given facts and answer each question in detail:
### Facts: - Mrs. X owns the property. - The property is rented to her husband, Mr. Y. - The property is used for self-occupancy by both Mrs. X and Mr. Y. - Mr. Y is paying rent to Mrs. X.
### Questions and Answers:
#### 1. **Can Rental Income be Treated as Income in the Hands of Mrs. X?**
Yes, the rental income must be treated as income in the hands of Mrs. X. Since Mrs. X is the owner of the property and Mr. Y is paying rent, this rental income belongs to Mrs. X.
#### 2. **Is the Rental Income Chargeable Under the Head "House Property" in the Hands of Mrs. X?**
Yes, the rental income received by Mrs. X is chargeable under the head "Income from House Property." According to the Income Tax Act, rental income from a property is generally taxed under the head "Income from House Property" in the hands of the property owner.
However, since the property is used for self-occupation by both Mrs. X and Mr. Y, you need to consider the following:
- **Self-Occupied Property**: Normally, if the property is self-occupied, the income from it is not taxable. However, in this case, because Mrs. X is receiving rent from Mr. Y, the property is not entirely treated as self-occupied.
- **Deemed Let-Out**: Since Mrs. X is receiving rent, the property may be treated as "deemed to be let out," and the rental income is taxable under the head "Income from House Property."
- **Deductions**: Mrs. X can claim deductions for municipal taxes and interest on a housing loan under Section 24(b) of the Income Tax Act. If the property is used partly for self-occupation and partly for rental purposes, deductions need to be calculated accordingly.
#### 3. **What if Mr. Y is in Receipt of HRA (House Rent Allowance)?**
- **If Mr. Y Receives HRA**: If Mr. Y receives HRA from his employer, he can claim HRA exemption under Section 10(13A) of the Income Tax Act. To claim HRA exemption, Mr. Y would need to provide proof of rent payments to Mrs. X and have a rent agreement in place. This allows him to claim HRA exemption if all other conditions are met.
- **If Mr. Y Does Not Receive HRA**: If Mr. Y is not receiving HRA, there is no impact on the HRA exemption claim, and the rental income will still be taxable in Mrs. X’s hands.
### Summary
1. **Income in the Hands of Mrs. X**: The rental income received by Mrs. X is treated as her income. 2. **Chargeable Under "House Property"**: Yes, it is taxable under "Income from House Property" in Mrs. X’s hands. 3. **Mr. Y’s HRA**: - **With HRA**: Mr. Y can claim HRA exemption if he fulfills all conditions and provides proof of rent payments. - **Without HRA**: The situation remains the same for Mrs. X’s rental income taxability.
### Practical Steps
1. **Ensure Proper Documentation**: Both parties should maintain proper documentation, including lease agreements and rent receipts. 2. **Calculate Deductions Carefully**: Mrs. X should accurately calculate deductions and taxable income. 3. **HRA Exemption for Mr. Y**: Ensure Mr. Y has valid proof and documents to claim HRA exemption, if applicable.
Consulting a tax professional for specific advice tailored to your situation can provide further clarity and ensure compliance with tax regulations.
CAclubindia
