22 August 2023
A US-based company, referred to as Company X, is in the process of being acquired by Company Y. This acquisition is structured as a 50-50 deal, with a combination of cash and stock. Specifically, for each share of Company X, shareholders will receive a combination of cash and Company Y's stock. The cash portion is equal to 50% of the current value of Company X's stock, and the number of Company Y's shares received is determined by dividing 50% of the current value of Company X's stock by the current value of Company Y's stock.
Now, when it comes to the cash portion received by shareholders of Company X, this is being treated as a dividend. The US government imposes a 30% tax on this dividend amount. My concern is whether it's possible to recover or reclaim this deducted tax money. It appears incorrect to me to pay a 30% tax on what is essentially not a traditional dividend. Adjusting it with stock P&L will not yield any benefits.
Is there a way to potentially recover or mitigate this 30% tax without affecting your profits?
06 July 2024
In the context of the acquisition deal between Company X and Company Y, where shareholders of Company X receive a cash portion as part of the acquisition consideration, which is treated as a dividend subject to a 30% tax withholding by the US government, here are some considerations regarding potential recovery or mitigation of this tax:
### Understanding the Tax Treatment:
1. **Dividend Treatment:** - The cash portion received by shareholders of Company X is treated as a dividend under US tax laws. This is because, in an acquisition scenario, when shareholders receive cash in exchange for their shares, it's often treated as a distribution of profits (similar to a dividend) rather than a capital gain.
2. **Tax Withholding:** - The US government imposes a 30% tax withholding on dividends paid to non-resident shareholders, unless reduced by an applicable tax treaty. This withholding is designed to ensure that taxes are collected upfront on income distributed to foreign shareholders.
### Potential Recovery or Mitigation Strategies:
1. **Tax Treaty Benefits:** - Determine if there is a tax treaty between the US and the country where the shareholders of Company X reside. Tax treaties often provide reduced withholding rates on dividends. For example, some treaties reduce the withholding rate to 15% or even lower for qualifying shareholders.
2. **Claiming Foreign Tax Credit:** - Shareholders may be able to claim a foreign tax credit in their home country for the US taxes withheld on dividends. This depends on the tax laws of the shareholder's country of residence. The credit generally offsets the tax liability in the shareholder's home country, reducing the overall tax burden.
3. **Tax Planning and Structuring:** - Consult with tax advisors to explore potential tax planning strategies that could mitigate the impact of the withholding tax. This may involve structuring the transaction in a way that optimizes tax efficiency or leveraging specific provisions under tax laws.
4. **Negotiation in Acquisition Terms:** - During negotiations between Company X and Company Y, consider whether there's room to adjust the terms of the acquisition to mitigate the tax impact on shareholders. For instance, restructuring the deal to include more stock consideration (which may not trigger immediate tax consequences) could be explored.
5. **Seeking Expert Advice:** - Given the complexities of international tax laws and the specifics of the acquisition deal, it's crucial to seek advice from tax professionals who specialize in cross-border transactions and tax planning. They can provide tailored advice based on the shareholder's individual circumstances and objectives.
### Conclusion:
While the 30% tax withholding on dividends may seem significant, exploring tax treaty benefits and foreign tax credit options can potentially mitigate this tax burden for shareholders of Company X. Strategic tax planning and advice from experts will be instrumental in navigating these complexities and optimizing the tax outcome in the context of the acquisition deal.
CAclubindia
