Deferred tax assets

This query is : Resolved

Report Abuse Follow Query Ask a Query

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

02 July 2012 Can any one tell me Profit/Loss on sale of fixed Assets is a Timing Difference or Permanent Difference?

CA CS Amit S. Kedia

CA CS Amit S. Kedia (Expert)
Follow

02 July 2012 Profit on sale of Fixed assets is permanent difference since in income tax there is block of assets system.
So, there may not be any capital gain on transfer of assets as per IT.

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

04 July 2012 If there is Shrot Term Capital Gain on sale of Assets as per I.T Act and Profit on Sale of Fixed Assets as per Companies Act, 1956 so this will be Timing Difference for computing Deferred Tax Assets/ Deferred Tax liabilities?

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

20 July 2024 Profit or loss on the sale of fixed assets can be categorized as either a timing difference or a permanent difference, depending on the circumstances. Here’s an explanation:

### Timing Difference vs. Permanent Difference

1. **Timing Difference:**
- Timing differences arise when the recognition of items in the financial statements differs from their recognition in tax computations, but the amounts will reverse in future periods.
- For example, depreciation methods might differ between accounting standards (Companies Act) and tax laws (Income Tax Act). This difference results in timing differences because the depreciation expense recognized in the financial statements may be different from the depreciation expense allowed for tax purposes. When the asset is sold, any resulting profit or loss might also be different for accounting and tax purposes.

2. **Permanent Difference:**
- Permanent differences occur when items are recognized in the financial statements but are never recognized in the tax computations, or vice versa, and these differences do not reverse in future periods.
- For example, expenses that are not deductible for tax purposes but are recognized in the financial statements (e.g., fines and penalties) create permanent differences.

### Profit/Loss on Sale of Fixed Assets

- **Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG) vs. Profit on Sale:**
- If there is a Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG) as per the Income Tax Act and a profit on sale of fixed assets as per the Companies Act, this situation typically represents a timing difference.
- The timing difference arises because the profit or gain on sale is recognized in the financial statements as per the Companies Act, while the taxable income (or gain) is calculated differently under the Income Tax Act, considering factors such as indexation, cost of acquisition, and holding period for determining STCG.
- The difference in treatment between accounting standards and tax laws creates timing differences that lead to deferred tax assets or liabilities.

### Deferred Tax Assets/Liabilities

- **Deferred Tax Assets (DTAs):**
- DTAs arise when taxable income is expected to be higher in future periods due to timing differences that will result in tax deductions or credits in those periods.
- For example, if the accounting profit on the sale of fixed assets is higher than the taxable profit (due to different recognition or valuation rules), this creates a temporary difference leading to a deferred tax asset.

- **Deferred Tax Liabilities (DTLs):**
- DTLs arise when taxable income is expected to be lower in future periods due to timing differences that will result in taxable amounts in those periods.
- For example, if the accounting profit on the sale of fixed assets is lower than the taxable profit (again, due to different rules), this creates a temporary difference leading to a deferred tax liability.

### Conclusion

In the scenario where there is a Short-Term Capital Gain (STCG) as per the Income Tax Act and a profit on sale of fixed assets as per the Companies Act, this creates a timing difference for the computation of deferred tax assets (DTAs) or deferred tax liabilities (DTLs). The treatment of such gains and profits will influence how DTAs and DTLs are calculated and reported in the financial statements, ensuring compliance with accounting standards (such as Ind AS 12 or AS 22) that govern the recognition and measurement of deferred tax.