20 April 2021
the clarification issued by the commissioner of commercial tax deportment under section 59(4) of KVAT act 2003 will become vat act without any notification by the govt. Shell we challenge the clarification /advance ruling in the High court of the state. Kindly give your valuable feedback. Thanks in advance.
06 July 2024
Challenging a clarification or advance ruling issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Tax Department under the KVAT Act 2003 in the High Court typically involves legal considerations and procedural steps. Here are some key points to consider:
1. **Legal Basis for Challenge**: Before deciding to challenge the clarification or advance ruling, it's crucial to assess the legal basis of the ruling and the grounds on which you believe it to be incorrect or unfair. This involves a thorough review of the KVAT Act 2003 and any relevant provisions regarding advance rulings or clarifications.
2. **Grounds for Challenge**: Common grounds for challenging such rulings include: - Violation of statutory provisions or procedural rules. - Incorrect interpretation or application of the law. - Failure to consider relevant facts or legal precedents.
3. **Procedure for Challenging**: In India, challenging a government ruling typically involves filing a writ petition in the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, which empowers the High Court to issue writs for enforcement of fundamental rights and for any other purpose.
4. **Documentation and Evidence**: Prepare a strong case supported by documentation, including copies of the clarification or advance ruling, relevant sections of the KVAT Act, any communications with the tax department, and legal arguments supporting your position.
5. **Legal Representation**: It's advisable to engage a competent tax lawyer who specializes in indirect taxation and has experience with High Court litigation. They can provide guidance on the specific requirements, procedures, and potential outcomes of challenging such rulings.
Before proceeding with any legal action, it's essential to weigh these factors carefully and seek professional legal advice to determine the best course of action based on your specific circumstances and objectives.
CAclubindia
