Save Rs 499. Go Ad-Free with CAclubindia Pro for 2 Full Years. Subscribe Now!

Think about the ignorance of CA and Followers

2369 views 26 replies

qarni

student

1220 Points Posted on 22 October 2007

making a 10+ student and a graduate and PG students same and treating both of them on same footing show the knowledge and wisdom of ca members and sitting by seeing shows there ignorance.

Take steps to control this by obolishing the newsheme and introducing old scheme that is pe-1, pe.2 and final.its better to some extent not much but changing little is better and best method in old scheme only.

Replies (26)

sonia

c.a

446 Points Posted on 22 October 2007

i agree

Shashwat Shekhar

Assistant Manager

3528 Points Posted on 22 October 2007

I fully endorse your view mr. qarni

Nilanjan Chowdhury

114 Points Posted on 22 October 2007

i agree with your views and ICAI should immediately abolish this CPT scheme. u cannot enrol 10+ student in the name of catch them young. i think 10+ is merely a 15 or 16 year teen who has just passed out of their school and ICAI should not blindly follow the model of IIT or Medical as an example. they must get back to old scheme and preferable way is to take graduates taking CPT exam.

Prakash Popat

3134 Points Posted on 23 October 2007

I am of contary opinion,ICAI is right,10+ student Competing and passing at early stage should not be questioned,They have greater balancing life to serve the nation in different ways.

Prakash Popat

3134 Points Posted on 23 October 2007

We need lot of talents for development,as We R unable to scrap irrelevant acts and rules.

CA. Dashrath Maheshwari

TaXpert

15126 Points Posted on 23 October 2007

I also agree with popat, y u don't think abt the future of 10+2 student.

pathan

student

94 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

HOw can we agree with pompat,As a person with 10+ and graduate are treated in same way. they dont have the knowledge and cant bear the stress for that icai will have to search anaother way of pulling them out.

pathan

student

94 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

What a strange course !!!!!!!!!!! NO standard only stress by keeping min passing marks and average to 50%. and giving result to the limited %.

CA. Dashrath Maheshwari

TaXpert

15126 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

there is nothing strange in the CA course. Its a valued course due to that stress only which you are thinking of.

Prakash Popat

3134 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

Dear Mr. Pathan, Time Requiered Change and We have to follow the same,tommorrow your kids having Talents to clear Professional Examinations @ 10+ do you means that he should be punished only on accounts of your waiting till graduation?

Prakash Popat

3134 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

All Positive Things coming out should be well appreciated and encouraged.

qarni

student

1220 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

What about graduates.Are they penalised and punished now with same duration.For this they should cut short the time of articles for them to be justified.

Shashwat Shekhar

Assistant Manager

3528 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

I am not saying anything for 10+ student, ICAI should review that whether graduates should appear in CPT or not.

Shashwat Shekhar

Assistant Manager

3528 Points Posted on 24 October 2007

And mr. qarni, things are not as worse as u think. There is no penalisation/punishment as such. Though its not a good practice that both 10+ and graduates can appear in CPT