TDS
This query is : Resolved
27 January 2011
Dear Experts,
TDS Deducted Date is 06.04.2010 tax Remitted on 04.08.2010, Interest caculation for How much month? 5 months or 4 monts?
Month calculated as date to date or end of the month?
TDS Deducted Date is 06.04.2010 tax Remitted on 04.08.2010, Interest caculation for How much month? 5 months or 4 monts?
Month calculated as date to date or end of the month?
27 January 2011
Month calculated as date to date.
4 months interest.
4 months interest.
Message likes :
1 times
27 January 2011
Mr. Adi..
Going by what you are saying... Just consider a case :
Tax deposited : 25/7/10
Tax paid : 08/08/10
What will be the penal interest ?
Going by what you are saying... Just consider a case :
Tax deposited : 25/7/10
Tax paid : 08/08/10
What will be the penal interest ?
Message likes :
1 times
27 January 2011
Open ??????????????
27 January 2011
What is the difference between tax deposited and tax paid?
If you say tax deducted then one months interest payable.
If you say tax deducted then one months interest payable.
27 January 2011
See...if TDS is deducible & is deducted on 25/7/10 & TDS is deposited on 08/08/10 >
Then going by the date to date count , there should not be any penal interest ?
In my opinion : in this case also... the interest will be 1.5 % for 25/7/10 to 31/7/10
& 1.5 % for 01/8/10 to 08/08/10.
Do you agree ?
Then going by the date to date count , there should not be any penal interest ?
In my opinion : in this case also... the interest will be 1.5 % for 25/7/10 to 31/7/10
& 1.5 % for 01/8/10 to 08/08/10.
Do you agree ?
27 January 2011
date to date means from 06.04.2010 - 05.05.2010 is one month. if tax paid on 08.05.2010 then two months interest will be payable. No doubt on that. Even a fraction of a month is a months delay. However month to be calculated date to date and not calendar month.
27 January 2011
Mr. Adi.
But the point of confusion is still there !
Take my dates & the reply, what will be the answer, date to date or otherwise ? Its just a confusion which I want to get rid of...
Take the dates as : if TDS is deducible & is deducted on 25/7/10 & TDS is deposited on 08/08/10.
because.. if we go by date count, then it is not even 15 days ?
I hope you don't mind keeping this query open for too long....
But the point of confusion is still there !
Take my dates & the reply, what will be the answer, date to date or otherwise ? Its just a confusion which I want to get rid of...
Take the dates as : if TDS is deducible & is deducted on 25/7/10 & TDS is deposited on 08/08/10.
because.. if we go by date count, then it is not even 15 days ?
I hope you don't mind keeping this query open for too long....
27 January 2011
See this link and comment
https://www.caclubindia.com/articles/a-day-s-delay-in-tds-remittance-interest-upto-3--6580.asp
My view is supported by this article also.
https://www.caclubindia.com/articles/a-day-s-delay-in-tds-remittance-interest-upto-3--6580.asp
My view is supported by this article also.
Guest
Guest
(Expert)
27 January 2011
Month is not defined in the IT Act but there will be 5 moths as per definition of month in General Clauses Act
Message likes :
1 times
28 January 2011
Mr. Adi..
Thanks for insisting on date to date calculation.
But I am still not convinced. Take a simple example.
Payment to party was made on 25/7/10 & on the same date TDS was deducted. SO THERE IS NO DELAY IN TDS DEDUCTION.
Agree....???
Now.. the TDS has been deposited on 08/08/10. So if we interpret on date to date principle, its not even 15 days, hence there is no delay !
IS THIS WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY ?
I still stand by my conviction that the interest will be charged @ 1.5 % for 2 Months (25/7/10 to 31/7/10) & (1/8/10 to 8/8/10).
Can you please consider only my dates in the above example & reply to that only.
Thanks for insisting on date to date calculation.
But I am still not convinced. Take a simple example.
Payment to party was made on 25/7/10 & on the same date TDS was deducted. SO THERE IS NO DELAY IN TDS DEDUCTION.
Agree....???
Now.. the TDS has been deposited on 08/08/10. So if we interpret on date to date principle, its not even 15 days, hence there is no delay !
IS THIS WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY ?
I still stand by my conviction that the interest will be charged @ 1.5 % for 2 Months (25/7/10 to 31/7/10) & (1/8/10 to 8/8/10).
Can you please consider only my dates in the above example & reply to that only.
28 January 2011
Dear All.
Under the provisions of section 201(1A) of the Act, a person is liable to pay simple interest at 1.5 per cent for every month or part of month in case of failure of payment of tax after deduction.
Now taking above examples.
Ex 1)
Tax deducted : 25/7/10
Tax deposited : 08/08/10
Due date of payment in above case is 07/08/10 if paid after that interest will be 1.5% upto 24/08/10 (i.e. upto 1 month) after that even if 1 day exceed interest will be 3% for two month(taking part in excess of one month).
Ex 2)
Tax deducted : 06/04/10
Tax deposited : 04/08/10
Due date of payment in above case is 07/05/10 if paid after that TDS 1.5% considering month basis or part in excess of 1 month.
06/04/10 to 05/05/10 (1.5%)
06/05/10 to 05/06/10 (1.5%)
06/06/10 to 05/07/10 (1.5%)
06/07/10 to 04/08/10 (1.5%)
So interest will be levied for 4 months.
Even if Tax deducted on say 31/12/10 due date is 07/01/11 after that upto 30/01/11 interest will be 1.5% p.m.
Another example--
Say TDS deducted on 1st january, 2011 Due date is 07/02/11 even though it crosses 1 month but is TDS deposited on 08/02/2011 Interest will be charged @3% i.e. for two months. as 1 month is crossed and the law say for even a part in excess of 1 month.
Hope it is clear if any further query please do ask.
Under the provisions of section 201(1A) of the Act, a person is liable to pay simple interest at 1.5 per cent for every month or part of month in case of failure of payment of tax after deduction.
Now taking above examples.
Ex 1)
Tax deducted : 25/7/10
Tax deposited : 08/08/10
Due date of payment in above case is 07/08/10 if paid after that interest will be 1.5% upto 24/08/10 (i.e. upto 1 month) after that even if 1 day exceed interest will be 3% for two month(taking part in excess of one month).
Ex 2)
Tax deducted : 06/04/10
Tax deposited : 04/08/10
Due date of payment in above case is 07/05/10 if paid after that TDS 1.5% considering month basis or part in excess of 1 month.
06/04/10 to 05/05/10 (1.5%)
06/05/10 to 05/06/10 (1.5%)
06/06/10 to 05/07/10 (1.5%)
06/07/10 to 04/08/10 (1.5%)
So interest will be levied for 4 months.
Even if Tax deducted on say 31/12/10 due date is 07/01/11 after that upto 30/01/11 interest will be 1.5% p.m.
Another example--
Say TDS deducted on 1st january, 2011 Due date is 07/02/11 even though it crosses 1 month but is TDS deposited on 08/02/2011 Interest will be charged @3% i.e. for two months. as 1 month is crossed and the law say for even a part in excess of 1 month.
Hope it is clear if any further query please do ask.
Message likes :
4 times
28 January 2011
Thanks.....
Its more clear now...
Its more clear now...
28 January 2011
Payment to party was made on 25/7/10 & on the same date TDS was deducted. SO THERE IS NO DELAY IN TDS DEDUCTION.
Agree....???
Now.. the TDS has been deposited on 08/08/10. So if we interpret on date to date principle, its not even 15 days, but there is delay of one month since part of a month even a day is a month 1 months interest leviable.
Agree....???
Now.. the TDS has been deposited on 08/08/10. So if we interpret on date to date principle, its not even 15 days, but there is delay of one month since part of a month even a day is a month 1 months interest leviable.
Message likes :
1 times
28 January 2011
Agreed with the clarification.
28 January 2011
Agreed with Sanjay Ji and Aditya Ji.
TDS Deducted Date is 06/04/2010.
i.e due date of deposit of tax is 7/05/2010
now if it is deposited on 04/08/2010
then interest will be for 4 months
TDS Deducted Date is 06/04/2010.
i.e due date of deposit of tax is 7/05/2010
now if it is deposited on 04/08/2010
then interest will be for 4 months
Message likes :
1 times
28 January 2011
Thanks.. Mr. Bansal
Message likes :
1 times
18 July 2013
ATTN ALL :
AMOUNT PAID AND TAX DEDUCTED BY ME ON 28-04-2012 AND TAX DEPOSIT ON 11-05-12. TDS AMOUNT 215/-.DELAY IS 14 DAYS. BUT IN NOTICE RECD FROM TDS CPC AND IN JUSTIFICATION REPORT DOWNLOADED FROM TDSCPS, ITS SHOWS DELAY OF TWO MONTHS AND DEMANDED INTEREST OF RS. 6/-
AMOUNT PAID AND TAX DEDUCTED BY ME ON 28-04-2012 AND TAX DEPOSIT ON 11-05-12. TDS AMOUNT 215/-.DELAY IS 14 DAYS. BUT IN NOTICE RECD FROM TDS CPC AND IN JUSTIFICATION REPORT DOWNLOADED FROM TDSCPS, ITS SHOWS DELAY OF TWO MONTHS AND DEMANDED INTEREST OF RS. 6/-
18 July 2013
Demand raised is wrong. Interest on late deposit to be paid for 1 month only @1.5% of TDS amount.
18 July 2013
THANKS SANJAYJI AND ONE MORE PROBLEM IS THAT THIER CALCULATION IS ALSO NOT MATCHING. TAX DEDUCTED 27/04/2012 AND PAID 11/05/2012 THAN ONE MONTH INT. COMES 4/- AND TWO MONTHS COME 8/- BUT THEY ARE DEMANDING 6/-.
ONE MORE:
DEDUCTION DATE 28/04/2012 AMT 2694/- PAID ON 11/05/2012. INTEREST AS PER TWO MONTHS COMES 81/- BUT THEY ARE ASKING 77/-
HOW ITS CALCULATED AND HOW ACTUAL CALCULATION SHOULD BE. THANKS IN ADVANCE
ONE MORE:
DEDUCTION DATE 28/04/2012 AMT 2694/- PAID ON 11/05/2012. INTEREST AS PER TWO MONTHS COMES 81/- BUT THEY ARE ASKING 77/-
HOW ITS CALCULATED AND HOW ACTUAL CALCULATION SHOULD BE. THANKS IN ADVANCE
22 July 2013
On Rs 215/- for two months @1.5% comes to Rs 6.45. So that part is ok. But interest should be payable for only 1 month. I think they are taking it on month basis. But this is not correct. For delay of 14 days how could someone be asked to pay interest of 2 months.
In second you are correct interest for two months comes to Rs 81/- but they are showing Rs 77/-. Difficult to say what mechanism they are adopting. It would be best to meet your TDS AO and get the same clarified.
In second you are correct interest for two months comes to Rs 81/- but they are showing Rs 77/-. Difficult to say what mechanism they are adopting. It would be best to meet your TDS AO and get the same clarified.
Message likes :
1 times
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- REGARDING GST ON COMMERICIAL PROPERTY
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- 15ca /15cb whose income tax login? remitter or nri seller's login?
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- TDS U/S. 194NF
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- Regarding Documentation & Compliances for Opening of Unit of Pvt Ltd.
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- VERIFICATION OF REFUND RELATED
- GST Regis.
- ITC c/f from FY2022-23 to FY2023-24 entered the same in table 8C of GSTR9 of FY 2022-23, in FY23-24
- Late filling fees Demand by gst office
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- Short and Excess provision of expenses
- Issue of gst e invoice
- Interchangeable words in accounts
- Adjusted profit/Loss in the case of LLP and Pvt. Ltd.company
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
