Tax on exhange of old jewellery
This query is : Open
24 September 2017
Hello,
Suppose there is a situation where Mr.A (Jewelery Shopkeeper) & Mr.B (Customer), Mr.B went to Mr.A's shop for buying some jewelery worth Rs.10000/- & he exchanged some of his old jewelery for Rs.3000/- & on billing Mr.A charged tax @3% on Rs.10000/- i.e he collected Rs.300/- from Mr.B in form of tax. But, Mr.B argued with Mr.A that you should charge tax on after deducting Rs.3000/- from Rs.10000/- i.e. on Rs.7000/-.
Who is correct Mr.A or Mr.B ?
Please do reply.
Thank You.!
Suppose there is a situation where Mr.A (Jewelery Shopkeeper) & Mr.B (Customer), Mr.B went to Mr.A's shop for buying some jewelery worth Rs.10000/- & he exchanged some of his old jewelery for Rs.3000/- & on billing Mr.A charged tax @3% on Rs.10000/- i.e he collected Rs.300/- from Mr.B in form of tax. But, Mr.B argued with Mr.A that you should charge tax on after deducting Rs.3000/- from Rs.10000/- i.e. on Rs.7000/-.
Who is correct Mr.A or Mr.B ?
Please do reply.
Thank You.!
24 September 2017
Mr.B is correct as on old goods sale you have to pay tax on margin........
Message likes :
2 times
24 September 2017
Yes. I agreed to CA Rashmi Gandhi...
You can collect Tax on leased value... Also you ll pay Tax under RCM basis for the received gold...
Message likes :
1 times
25 September 2017
There are two separate supply transactions -- sale of old jewelry by customer and supply of jewelry by shop-keeper. Mr. A is correct in charging 3% on transaction value of jewelery Rs. 10000/-. In so far as supply of old jewelry by Mr. B is concerned GST liability would depend on whether sale by Mr. B is registered/unregistered and whether the sale in is in the course of business.
Message likes :
1 times
25 September 2017
Mr. B is a normal individual & Mr.A has made the sale to customer i.e. end user.
Now, on what price to charge tax.?
Now, on what price to charge tax.?
Message likes :
1 times
25 September 2017
Thank u CA Rashmi Mam.
Message likes :
2 times
25 September 2017
But Raja Sir, Mr.A has not received goods above Rs.5000/- so he is not liable to pay tax under RCM..??
Message likes :
1 times
25 September 2017
Yes.... You are correct....
If it's above 5k then RCM applicable...
Message likes :
1 times
25 September 2017
Tax chargeable on Rs. 10000/- as per the Valuation Rules and no RCM applicable.
Message likes :
1 times
26 September 2017
You can either pay tax on 7000/- as per margin rule.
Also you can pay at Rs 10000/- @3% & no RCM applicable on purchase
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Manual Rectification through AO
- IT Return filed defective u/s 139 (9)
- Defective Return - Tds on advance
- Fixed Deposit Claim Relinquishment by the Nominee
- TCS ON SOFTWARE SALES
- Not a CA , can we prepare balance sheet
- Income Type for interest from government bonds
- What is meaning of cumulative method of interest
- Interest of FDs is taxable on an accrual basis also
- What is meaning of mismatch of group in accounting
- Gstr 9 2023-24
- GSTR-9 HSN Summary and Credit Note without item
- Interchangeable words in accounts
- Adjusted profit/Loss in the case of LLP and Pvt. Ltd.company
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
- 133(6) DIN INVALID format error - ->WHERE TO REPLY 133(6) notice?
- Query for dubts
- GST RCM not shown in GSTR-3B
- Bill from Dispatched from issue.
Trending Online Classes
-
Landmark Judgments: Important Provisions of the EPF & ESI Act interpreted by the Honorable Supreme Court of India
Mr.Balamurugan Ranganathan15 November 2024
CAclubindia
