CA Day celebration 2024 Easy Office
LCI Learning

Perquisite of Educational Facilities

This query is : Resolved 

16 February 2011 Perquisite in respect of provision of educational facilities in the own institution or any other institution because of employment - shall be equal to the value of similar education.

However if the value does not exceed Rs.1000 perq will be "NIL"

Question is - If the preq value exceeds Rs.1000/- the excess over 1000 is taxable (or) the total value itself become taxable??

16 February 2011 Taxable only the amount exceeding Rs. 1000, suppose the value Rs.1500 then the taxable value is R(1500-1000) Rs.500

17 February 2011 Is there any circular or case law in support of this view?


18 February 2011 Hi,
I disagree with the Expert.

The provisions says among other thngs
"IF THE COST OF SUCH EDUCATION OR THE VALUE OF SUCH BENEFIT PER CHILD DOES NOT EXCEED Rs.1000/- P.M, NOTHING SHALL BE TAXED AS PERQUISITE"

which means

"IF IT CROSSES Rs.1000/- P.M THEN EVERY THING SHALL BE TAXED & NOT THE EXCESS AMOUNT ONLY"

Eg.

Value = Rs.1750/- p.m , then entire value of Rs.1750/- p.m shall be taxed.

unlike

CHILDERN EDUCATION ALLOWANCE, WHERE THE PROVISION SAYS

"is exempt UPTO Rs.100/- P.M.P.CHILD UPTO A MAXIMUM OF 2 CHILDREN"

Since the word upto is given, anything over & above the mentioned limits, only the excess shall be taxable.

Eg.
If Allowance of Rs.250/- p.m is given, then only Rs.150/- p.m is taxed

Hope i have resolved the Issue.

Thank you,

Regards
CA. LOHITH.J
B.Com,ACA,CS,(ICWA),SAPM Hons,ITF Hons

20 February 2011 dear mr lohith
thanks so much

20 February 2011 Yes. Checked the provision & Agreed, Mr.Lohith Jagadeesh is correct.& sorry for my first reply



You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries




Answer Query