Job at tata steel or essar steel

This query is : Resolved

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

22 November 2015 Dear all

I joined Tata steel in the month of july 15 wherein they offered me posting n Jamshedpur. But after joining in jamshedpur, i was transferred to Sukinda mines in orissa in the payroll dept. I was unhappy with the location & job profile. Recently i got an offer from Essar Steel in Hazira, Surat in the secondary sales division, where i will be reporting to CFO of that division.

What should I do??

shivaji prasad bhimavarapu

shivaji prasad bhimavarapu (Expert)
Follow

23 November 2015 You may opt for Essar considering the job profile, Location.

Querist : Anonymous

Querist : Anonymous (Querist)

23 November 2015 Thank you sir for your reply. But the confusion is that everybody is saying that the tata is a much more bigger & stable company as compared to essar. Secondly, in the company all the colluages including my seniors are saying that profile or location will change in due course of time, as i have already tried to put down my paper.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

02 August 2024 Given your situation, where you’re weighing between staying at Tata Steel and moving to Essar Steel, here’s a more focused approach to help you decide:

### **1. Job Satisfaction and Career Growth**

#### **Tata Steel:**
- **Current Role:** Payroll department, which may not align with your career aspirations.
- **Location:** Sukinda Mines, Orissa, which you find less desirable.
- **Future Prospects:** There’s a possibility of role or location change in the future, but it’s uncertain.

#### **Essar Steel:**
- **New Role:** Secondary Sales Division, reporting directly to the CFO. This role could offer significant exposure, learning opportunities, and alignment with your career goals.
- **Location:** Hazira, Surat, which you find more desirable.

**Action:** Consider which role aligns better with your long-term career goals. Reporting directly to the CFO might offer better career advancement opportunities and learning experiences.

### **2. Company Stability and Growth Potential**

- **Tata Steel:** Known for its stability and large scale, which can offer job security and a strong brand name.
- **Essar Steel:** While it might not be as large as Tata Steel, it can still offer valuable experience and opportunities for growth.

**Action:** If stability is a significant concern for you, Tata Steel’s reputation might offer more job security. However, weigh this against the potential career benefits at Essar Steel.

### **3. Work Environment and Personal Satisfaction**

- **Tata Steel:** If you’re unhappy with the current role and location, it can impact your overall job satisfaction and performance.
- **Essar Steel:** A new role and location could potentially improve your work satisfaction.

**Action:** Assess the potential improvement in work environment and personal satisfaction at Essar Steel. A more fulfilling role and preferable location might lead to greater job satisfaction.

### **4. Long-Term Career Impact**

- **Tata Steel:** Experience with a large, reputable company can be valuable, but it might come with challenges if you’re not satisfied with your current role.
- **Essar Steel:** A role with direct access to senior management can offer substantial career growth and networking opportunities.

**Action:** Consider how each option aligns with your long-term career goals. The role at Essar Steel might provide a more direct path to achieving those goals.

### **5. Practical Considerations**

- **Job Security:** If Tata Steel is perceived as more stable, it might offer better job security in the long run.
- **Professional Development:** A role with direct interaction with senior management at Essar Steel might offer more learning and development opportunities.

**Action:** Evaluate the immediate and long-term benefits of each option, including job security, professional development, and personal satisfaction.

### **6. Consult with Mentors or Trusted Advisors**

- **Seek Opinions:** Speak to mentors, colleagues, or industry professionals who can provide insights based on their experiences.
- **Consider Personal Preferences:** Make sure your decision aligns with both your professional goals and personal satisfaction.

### **Decision-Making Approach**

1. **List Pros and Cons:** Create a detailed list of pros and cons for each option based on job satisfaction, career growth, company stability, and personal preferences.
2. **Reflect on Long-Term Goals:** Consider which option better aligns with your long-term career aspirations.
3. **Consult with Trusted Advisors:** Gather insights from trusted mentors or professionals who can provide valuable perspectives.

**Conclusion:**

If the role and location at Essar Steel align better with your career goals and personal satisfaction, it might be worth considering the move despite the stability of Tata Steel. However, if stability and long-term security are more important to you, and you believe that your role at Tata Steel might improve over time, staying might be a better option.

Ultimately, weigh all factors carefully and choose the option that aligns best with your career aspirations and personal well-being.