Itr3 for professional under presumptive income

This query is : Resolved

Amit Chaudhary (Querist)
Follow

05 June 2019 I am a doctor having some salaried income and some from professional practice. I also have a small income from foreign country as a consultant. I therefore filed ITR 3 in AY 2018-19 as I need to show foreign income in Schedule FSI.
As I do not maintain books of account, I opted for Presumptive Income from Profession (44ADA) and thus selected the No Accounts Case in ITR 3 (General Section).

On Balance Sheet page, I filled only sec 6 (No Accounts Case) as follows:
Sundry Debtors = 0
Sundry Creditors = 0
Stock in trade = 0
Cash balance = 0

On Profits and Loss Account page, I filled only sec 53 (ii) for Professions (No Accounts Case) as follows:
Gross Receipts = 900000/-
Gross Profit = 450000/- (i.e 50% of Gross Receipts to show Presumptive Income)
Expenses = 0
Net Profit = 450000/-

The Schedule BP - Computation of Income from Business or Profession thus reflected:
A: From Business or Profession
1: Profit before tax as per profit and loss account (item 45 and 53 of Part A-P and L ) = 450000/-

4. Profit or loss included in 1, which is referred to in section 44AD/44ADA/44AE/44B/44BB/44BBA/44BBB/ 44D/44DA/ Chapter-XII-G/ First Schedule of
Income-tax Act = 450000/-

36. Profits and gains of business or profession deemed to be under -
ii Section 44ADA = 450000/-

37. Net profit or loss from business or profession other than speculative business and specified business (35 + 36xi)) = 450000/-

38. Net Profit or loss from business or profession other than speculative business and specified business,after applying rule 7A, 7B or 8), if applicable (If rule 7A, 7B or 8 is not applicable, enter same
figure as in 37) (If loss take the figure to 2i of item E) = 450000/-

The computation of income page thus reflected:
PART B - TI (Computation of Total Income)
3. Profits and gains from business or profession
i Profit and gains from business other than speculative business and specified business
(A38 of Schedule-BP) (enter nil if loss) = 450000/-

vi Total (3i + 3ii + 3iii + 3iv + 3v) (enter nil if 3vi is a loss) = 450000/-

However, I still received a notice u/s 139(9) with error code 311 that "Taxpayer having income under the head Profits and gains of Business or Profession but has not filled Balance Sheet and P & L Account...".
The probable resolution that the notice mentions is "The Part B of the P & L account and part B of the Balance Sheet (i.e. No Account Case Section) should be entered in the corrected return.."

But as you can see above, i have indeed filled data for both P&L and Balance Sheet under presumptive income by taking 50% of Gross Receipts.
And I have filled all the other sections to show my salary and other income. Still I am getting this notice. Please help.