31 January 2023
MR. A SHOWN AND PAID EXCESS B2C SALE IN GSTR-1 OF RS. 100 IN F.Y. 2021-22 AND NOW MR. A REDUCED SALE OF RS. 100 IN F.Y. 2022-23 FROM BOOKS OF ACCOUNT(BOOKS SALE-100RS.) INSTEAD OF REDUCING BY AMENDMENT
WHAT ARE THE CONSQUENCES ?
SUPPOSE IF REDUCED THROUGH AMENDMENT THEN WHAT ABOUT DIFFRENCE IN BOOKS AND GSTR-3B.
12 July 2024
Let's break down the scenario and discuss the consequences based on the actions taken:
### Scenario 1: Excess B2C Sale Shown and Paid in FY 2021-22
- **Excess B2C Sale**: Mr. A has erroneously shown and paid Rs. 100 excess B2C sale in GSTR-1 for FY 2021-22.
### Consequences:
1. **Excess Payment in FY 2021-22**: Since Mr. A has already paid GST on this excess sale in FY 2021-22, the tax authorities have received more tax than required for that period.
2. **Rectification in FY 2022-23**: Mr. A decides to reduce the sale by Rs. 100 in FY 2022-23 from his books of accounts instead of amending the GSTR-1 for FY 2021-22.
### Implications:
- **For FY 2021-22**: The excess tax paid on the Rs. 100 sale cannot be claimed back for FY 2021-22 because the tax authorities already received it.
- **For FY 2022-23**: Since Mr. A has reduced the sale in his books by Rs. 100, he should ensure that the correct amount is reflected in GSTR-1 for FY 2022-23 to avoid discrepancies.
### Scenario 2: Reduction Through Amendment (Hypothetical)
- **If Reduced Through Amendment**: Instead of adjusting in books, Mr. A could have reduced the excess sale by amending the GSTR-1 for FY 2021-22.
### Implications:
- **Correct Reporting**: Amending the GSTR-1 for FY 2021-22 would correct the excess sale reporting. However, the GST paid for the excess amount in FY 2021-22 cannot be automatically adjusted or refunded just by amending.
- **Difference in Books and GSTR-3B**: If Mr. A reduces the sale through an amendment in GSTR-1: - **Books of Accounts**: Reflect the correct sale of Rs. 100 less in FY 2022-23. - **GSTR-3B**: Ensure that the reduction in sale is reflected in subsequent GSTR-3B returns to reconcile the tax paid with the corrected sales amount.
### Conclusion:
- **Excess Payment**: The excess GST paid in FY 2021-22 cannot be claimed back automatically. Mr. A has effectively overpaid tax for that period.
- **Corrective Actions**: To rectify such errors, it's important to accurately reflect sales in GSTR-1 and reconcile them with the books of accounts. If adjustments are made through amendments, ensure proper reconciliation in subsequent returns (like GSTR-3B) to avoid discrepancies.
- **Consultation**: It may be beneficial for Mr. A to consult with a tax professional or GST practitioner to determine the best course of action based on his specific circumstances and to avoid further compliance issues.
CAclubindia
