Bazeer Ahmed

Sir / Madam,
Our Company has owned one Ground Mounted Solar Plant and get commissioned the plant in the year 2023. While procurement GST rate was 70% of project cost @12% tax and 30% of project cost @18%. And we claimed and utilized the ITC. We are utilizing the full power units generation to our textile unit(Group Captive). Now we propose to sell the entire plant. Kindly advise us what is the correct GST tax rate

Query No 1:
whether 70% of the project cost @5% ( present solar modules tax rate is reduced to 5%) and remaining project cost (30% )@ 18% or

for entire project @ 5% tax rate as it is used and old.

Query No 2:
Kindly advise us whether our understanding is correct or not. While selling the plant we should have to reverse the ITC proportion distributed to 60 months as we are going to sell the plant within 5 years.

Kindly clarify that

whether we have to reverse the ITC proportion or no need to reverse the ITC we claimed on the project.

A lot of Thanks in advance,

With warm regards,
Bazeer L

Answer now

Mahabir Prasad Agarwal
07 February 2026 at 10:52

Purchases from unregistered dealers only

Entire purchases of one of my client is from unregistered dealers and entire sales to registered dealers. How to show the purchases in GSTR ? Whether RCM is mandatory in this case ?

Answer now

Varadarajan TK

Namaskar Sir/Madam
My brother is an OCI card holder with a PAN He has does not have an aadhar card and has not filed returns in India for the last 30 years. His PAN is active but in inoperative state
Since he cannot get an Aadhar since he is not going to spend 180 days in India, how can he make his PAN operative
He wants to sell his house and wants to pay the applicable Capital Gains Tax @12.5
Can you kindly advice pls ?
Thanks

Answer now

VENKATESHWARA CHALLAGALLA

We desire to shift the registered charitable trust with 12AB approval from Chennai (Tamilnadu) to Hyderabad (Telangana). What is the process to do so?

Answer now

Sunil Patnaik

Dear Sir/Madam,

I am seeking your expert opinion regarding the correct GST applicability, rate, and HSN classification for one of our products.
We are dealing with a product named “Millet-Based Probiotic Drink”, which is a packaged, non-alcoholic, fermented beverage made from millets, containing live probiotics. It is marketed as a spicy digestive/probiotic health drink, with zero sugar and zero preservatives.
There is confusion regarding whether this product should be classified as:
• a non-alcoholic beverage under Chapter 22, or
• a functional / probiotic / nutraceutical product under any other appropriate heading,
and accordingly, whether the applicable GST rate should be 5%, 12%, 18% or any other rate.

We request your guidance on:
1. The most appropriate HSN code for this product,
2. The correct GST rate applicable, and
3. Any relevant notifications, circulars, or case laws supporting the classification.
Your professional clarification will help us ensure correct compliance and avoid future disputes.
Looking forward to your valuable advice.

Answer now

TRIBHUVAN PUROHIT

Respected Sir/Madam,
We have only 15G/15H challans in this quarter and no other TDS payments, we have already submiitted form 15G/15H on 15th jan 2026 but while filing TDS Return it ask for challan payments which we don`t have

How to file this return

Please reply

Regards

Tribhuvan

Answer now

DIVYA
12 January 2026 at 16:30

80G deduction eligibility

Dear Sir/Ma'am,
This query is pertaining to AY 2024-25.
I had filed the return u/s139(1) under old regime where I had claimed 100% deduction for donation made to "The National Trust for Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities constituted under sub-section (1) of section 3 of the National Trust for Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Multiple Disabilities Act, 1999". However, few days ago I have received an SMS alert from the income tax department saying that "Our records show that you claimed charitable/relief fund donation deductions in your AY 2024-25 ITR. However, based on the PAN you provided, the organisation you donated to may not be eligible for the deduction you claimed.

You need to update your ITR to either add the correct PAN or remove the deduction. To do this,visit https://www.incometax.gov.in. Once logged in, navigate to “e-File” → “File Income Tax Return → “Select Assessment Year” → “Select Filing Type” → choose “139(8A) - Updated Return” → “ Select ITR Type” → “Continue” and update section 80G/80GGC".
As per the provisions of section 80G, donation to the above entity is eligible for 100% deduction.
Now I am getting a tax payable along with interest u/234A, 234B and 234C to pay the tax on this donation amount.
Can anyone please guide me how to resolve this query.
Also is there any way in which I can verify the PAN of the Donee Entity.

Answer now

Chirag H. Thakkar
05 January 2026 at 16:08

GST on Tobacco - as per new notification

I am a wholesaler of Raw Tobacco. What is the implication of the new notification no. 19/2025 dated 31/12/2025.
how to raise an invoice and how to show the excise?? Weather I have to apply for excise registration?

Answer now

Consultant2b
01 January 2026 at 13:12

Cant amend a 26QB

Hi everyone,

I’m trying to amend Form 26QB on the TRACES website and running into a strange issue.

• I submit the amendment request.
• I get a confirmation saying the request has been successfully submitted.
• When I check the Request Status after about 10–15 minutes, it shows “Declined.”
• The PAN and Acknowledgement Number entered are correct.

This is happening for multiple Form 26QB filings that were filed incorrectly and now need amendments.

I’m trying to understand:
• What are the common reasons for an amendment request getting declined after successful submission?
• Is this usually due to a validation issue, timing issue, or a known TRACES system bug?
• Are there any specific checks or prerequisites I should verify before re-submitting?
• Is there a recommended workaround, like waiting longer, re-filing at a certain time, or using a different correction type?

Any guidance from someone who has dealt with this recently would be really helpful.

Thanks in advance.

Answer now

ARUN GUPTA
30 December 2025 at 12:48

Gst no of supplier cancelled from 2017

Please note that gst no of supplier cancelled from 2017. How will I be impacted by suppliers gst registration cancellation done suomoto by gst authorities? please clarify?

Answer now




CCI Pro
Meet our CAclubindia PRO Members


Follow us



Answer Query