Easy Office
LCI Learning

Tds on pre incor exp

This query is : Resolved 

19 March 2012 Date of Reg aug 2009

pre InCor Exp to professional rs.328000/-

Tan reg on 2010

whenther tds has to be deduct or not

20 March 2012 This is not a easy question and a very practical Question...

Who Will Deduct TDS on Same as Co. is not incorporated yet ?

But i guess, you are not required to deduct TDS before Incorporation of Co. on Expenses which you are not claiming as Expenditure in P&L A/c... but m not Sure and Query is still open...

20 March 2012 A difficult question.I can suggest that promoters can deduct and pay the TDS on behalf of the company as they are the whole and sole till the company is incorporated and they are eligible for reimbursement of the same but as Raghav said even i am not sure.



20 March 2012 i have confirmed that you are not required to Deduct TDS before incorporation as there is no entity which is supposed to deduct TDS

20 March 2012 Raghav can u quote any judgement or a section to support the view

21 March 2012 Piyush, can you quote any section which makes promoter liable to deduct TDS and deposit the same..???

and whose TAN will be used as Co. have no TAN as not incorporated and Promoters might also not have any TAN.

21 March 2012 RAGHAV WHAT IF PROMOTER IS A BODY CORPORATE DONT U THINK THAT TDS SHOULD BE DEDUCTED BY SUCH PROMOTER.CAN U QUOTE A SECTION THAT IN SUCH CASE TDS IS NOT PAYABLE

21 March 2012 Dear Piyush,

whenever govt. have to impose some liability, they have to provide so in act, and if no such thing is provided in act, then we do not have to create liability merely because no sec is there stating not to impose liability.

if u consider the impact of non deduction,

Such expenditure can not be disallowed in the hands of promoter as promoter is not claiming such expenditure,

As such expenditure is not claimed by promoter, he is not liable to deduct TDS

Such expenditure can not be disallowed in the hands of company as well since no default as co. was not in existense..




You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now

CAclubindia's WhatsApp Groups Link


Similar Resolved Queries


loading


Unanswered Queries




Answer Query