Ad-Free CAclubindia and Daily Updates on your mobile. Subscribe Now!

Reply by Non-expert in Experts Section ??

CourseCart.in (Mentor at SHAYVIDZ Academy) (3756 Points)

18 December 2009

Dear All,

I want to know that if any one knows the answer of those question which have been asked in EXPERT section but he has not been given right to express his/her opinion on that query.. Is it right? many queries are still open of which an experienced person can answer but he is cannot answer those queries just coz of he has not having degree at this stage.. so he was not accpeted from being an expert n his request to be an expert has been rejected..

One suggestion i want to give to da admin of CACLUBINDIA.COM that there must be seperate space for replies by non-experts and shud be allowed to answer those question.. so that the experienced person not having degree can also share his knowledge to others which is the foremost motive of this website..

Thanks

Adarsh

Reply
Follow
Share

4 Replies

Prabeer (B. COM (H) CA & CS Final) (5484 Points)
Replied 18 December 2009

Good suggestion Adarsh.

But at the same time you can PM your answer to the person who had made the query!

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CourseCart.in (Mentor at SHAYVIDZ Academy) (3756 Points)
Replied 18 December 2009

oh thanks Prabeer !!!

i didn't know about this.. i thought we can send pm to just those who r in our fren list..

now i can answer those queries..

Thanks

Adarsh

CA Mani (Credit Analyst) (2814 Points)
Replied 18 December 2009

i agree with ur point

But who knows that you know the answer right , sometimes we think and confident we are right but reality is different

So after seeing our knowledge and skills caclub gives the right to expert for answering but if they will give an option reply by nonexpert also

what will happen is suppose a query is replied by 1 expert or suppose no answer is given by expert but 5 non expert gives the answer and all are varied , student will be confused more

But that was negitive point , it has positive point also as u suggested, innovative ideas are always appreciable

Anyway lets see

CourseCart.in (Mentor at SHAYVIDZ Academy) (3756 Points)
Replied 18 December 2009

Maninder !!!

I agree wid u that opinion may be varied person to person.. but the opinion of one expert may also vary wid another expert.. if we see in disuccion forum, we get lots of differnt opinion but i dont think that the one who asks the query in forum didn't get his answer.. i think most of forum question gets its answer after various discussion..

I think there must be two space in EXPERTS section's query's for reply.. one for Experts opinion nd another for Non-Experts...

nd 1 more matter on which i would like to invite suggetions from all of the members of CACLUB.. that :-

"There must be some changes in criteria of being an Expert as so many people are having good knowledge but not having degree till now."

Adarsh