Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

Issue of Shares to Subscribers to Memorandum of Association

Haresh (self employed) (45 Points)

25 May 2010

Dear Members,

We have formed a private limited company last year i.e. on 15 October, 2009, but have not issued any shares to the subscribers to Memorandum and Articles of Association. Further, the consideration amount is still outstanding from the subscribers.

In the said situation, how can we proceed to issue share certificates to them and how stamp duty is to be calculated and paid considering the fact that now stamp duty is paid through franking which bears the current date and time.

Kindly suggest.

Regards,

Haresh Achantani

Reply
Follow
Share

20 Replies

CS MOHIT SALUJA (PRACTICING CS Jalandhar 9914558709) (5155 Points)
Replied 25 May 2010

there is not a big problem sir. as you can allot the shares to the subscribers by taking the application money and issue them the cerificates on the current date. and the stamp duty which will bear over the share certificate will be as per stamp act, as it is .25 per Rs. 100 in state of Punjab and 0.75 per Rs. 100 in Delhi.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Haresh (self employed) (45 Points)
Replied 25 May 2010

You mean to say there is no limitation as to time within which we have to issue shares to the subscribers. Are you sure?

And I doubt there is any requirement for subscribers to apply for shares, since they already have agreed to subscribe through Memorandum, which in itself is a binding agreement and as such there is no need to make application for shares by subscribers.

CS MOHIT SALUJA (PRACTICING CS Jalandhar 9914558709) (5155 Points)
Replied 25 May 2010

ya there may be many reasons like the chairman or managing director may not be present because of which the shares were not issued. so in such case, the shares will be alloted after after he comes to the country. so there is no limitation i think so, others views awaited.

Ankur Garg (Company Secretary and Compliance Officer) (114773 Points)
Replied 25 May 2010

Hi,

Subscribers of MOA are deemed shareholders of the company. They don't need to take shares. As soon as they subscribe the MOA & file it with ROC along with other incorporation documents they become the members as well as shareholders of the company. Appreciate further have you ever filed form-2 for the subscribers? The answer would be No. That itself is a kind of proof that no allotment is required to be made to the subscribers.

Form-2 is not required to be filed for subscribers hence no formal allotment is required in case of subscribers. They are deemed members and shareholders of the Company.

Regarding receipt of payment from subscribers I would say ideally such amount should be deposited by the subscribers after incorporation of the co. in the newly opened bank a/c of the company and record the same in the first BM Minutes.

Alternatively, as there is no tracing (as far as ROC is concerned) of such amount, it may be deposited by them later. As a CS i would suggested you should opt I option to avoid any kind of future problem.

DATE OF ALLOTMENT TO SUBSCRIBERS AND DATE TO BE MENTIONED ON SHARE CERTIFICATE

Date of allotment to subscribers will be the date of incorporation of the company and the same date will also be used for printing on share certificate to be issued to subscribers.

Practically & legally this is very much possible. To conclude you may use Date of Incorporation of the company for the purpose of:

1. Printing on share certificate of subscribers

2. as date of Allotment to subscribers

3. For the purpose of filling the column in register of member to enter the name of subscribers.

Even if you receive the amount from subscribers after 6 months the date of deemed Allotment and date on share certificate would remain the same i.e. date of incorporation of the company.

This is my personal opinion. Wait for other expert opinions.

Best Regards

1 Like

Haresh (self employed) (45 Points)
Replied 26 May 2010

So, Can I go ahead and issue share certificates to the subscribers by franking physical share certificates today?

Please do reply....

Thanks and Regards

Haresh Achantani

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Rasesh (CS CWA MBA (Fin) B.Com LL.B (Spl)) (6501 Points)
Replied 26 May 2010

My views differ from that of Mr. Ankur. Allotment of shares takes place only after the subscripttion money is paid to the Company. Till then, the amount remains unpaid. It is only after the amount is paid by the subscribers, the allotment is to be recorded in the Board Meeting and the share certificates be issued.

Agree with the fact that Form 2 is not to be filed.

Haresh (self employed) (45 Points)
Replied 27 May 2010

Dear Ankur Sir,

But the moot question still remains as to whether I can pay stamp duty today on shares, which were issued to the subscribers to Memorandum and Articles of Association on incorporation date, considering the fact that stamp duty needs to be paid before execution date.

Please do clarify. I am awaiting your reply on the matter.

Regards,

Haresh Achantani

Rasesh (CS CWA MBA (Fin) B.Com LL.B (Spl)) (6501 Points)
Replied 27 May 2010

You may pay consolidated stamp duty on a specimen share certificate and mention this fact on the share certificates that are issued to the subscribers (whenever they are issued)

Haresh (self employed) (45 Points)
Replied 27 May 2010

You mean to say a company incorporated on 15^th October 2009, can issue share certificates today to the subscribers i.e. after a time gap of 7 months. Please let know:

1. Is there no time limit within which a company should issue share certificates to the subscribers?

2. As said by Ankurji, the Share Certificate can be issued by mentioning incorporation date on the physical share certificate, even if the subscribers have not brought in the subscripttion amount. So, my doubt is:

a. If I issue share certificates today with the current date, how will I satisfy payment of stamp duty, which is being paid today, while the certificates bears the date of incorporation on it i.e. 15.10.2009. In short, certificates are issued before payment of stamp duty, which is not possible.

b. And in the absence of subscripttion amount from subscribers, what should be mentioned on the face of the share certificate as to the amount being paid-up on the shares.

Any case law or comprehensive writing on the above matter will be highly appreciated, if possible.

Thanks and Regards,

Haresh Achantani

Rasesh (CS CWA MBA (Fin) B.Com LL.B (Spl)) (6501 Points)
Replied 27 May 2010

Yes, a company incorporated on 15^th October 2009, can issue share certificates today to the subscribers. There is no time limit within which a company should issue share certificates to the subscribers.

As regards Mr. Ankur's view that the Share Certificate can be issued by mentioning incorporation date on the physical share certificate, even if the subscribers have not brought in the subscriptttion amount, I hold a different view.