Sir your article are really insipiring pls keep writing

Thanks sir ji ...

a great article for me......

vry nce article sir..!!!u posted dis article on d right tme..wen i was most confused abt d tutns..!!!

Aftr reading dis article i av come to d conclusion dat i shud go for tutns for only dose subjects in vich m strucked..!!!!

well...a big thnx for sharing..!!!

So why only for CA ?? Shut all universities, B schools and institutes of higher learning... And send setudents to work in order to teach them..... 

I feel it is not right to say that coaching classes should not be done. Few benefits according to me

1. There are some coaching classes which teach very well conceptually as many people have already written about
    
2. When people are working in articleship sincerely, it is very tough to go home after work when you are tired a lot and study. Also unless someone is extremely disciplined, its tough to find the focus to sit to study regularly. By going to classes, there is somewhat regular touch with studies throughout the year, even though the students may not pay attention completely which is a possibility but atleast they are in touch with the studies.   
    
3. The fact that fees have been paid in thousands encourage students not to bunk class and study there.
    
4. Some coaching classes have done good research and collected important sums and material from various other exams as well as books, so the coverage is wider.
    
5. Students by studying on their own will obviously be conceptually clear but doing it in classes makes it faster because they have better technique of teaching and proper way while individual student doing it on his own may get lost and take lot of time for the same realisation.
    

Originally posted by : CA Ravi sisodia
	Very long Article........

I also felt the same 

CA course was always tough. Even 20/30 years ago pass percentage was almost same as today's. The course has changed with times but it is as hard now as it was earlier. In our times there was no concept of tutions. We relied heavily on practical training. I myself never took any tution. Yes once or twice I had taken help from my seniors. It is not that I was a brilliant student. But hard work and practical knowledge helped and I was a rank holder in CA exam.

Originally posted by : CA KRISHNA KUMAR DARUKA
	CA course was always tough. Even 20/30 years ago pass percentage was almost same as today's. The course has changed with times but it is as hard now as it was earlier. In our times there was no concept of tutions. We relied heavily on practical training. I myself never took any tution. Yes once or twice I had taken help from my seniors. It is not that I was a brilliant student. But hard work and practical knowledge helped and I was a rank holder in CA exam.

This is a punch. This is lacking now a days CA students. Thank you  sir for putting some light to the above discussion.

you are challenged and want to become A CA , so that you had overcome from all the hurdle race.. thank you once again.

Vivek please dont say nowdays CA students lack anything. Times have changed a lot and the syllabus has increased like hell.

Right from Accounting Stds which hardly were there before 1990, Companies Act many provisions were not there, the whole world of financial management did not exist twenty five years back, due to these three things audit was much easier to do, no CARO, both taxes had much less provisions to learn. So volume of syllabus has increased like a lot

Although percentage of passing may have been same, competition has increased. Although mathematically its the same, but practically, Its not the same to be a part of 10 out of 100 students... and 1000 out of 10000 students. Competition has increased a lot now.

I am not saying whatever Daruka Sir said is wrong. He is undoubtedly hard working to have passed but that doesnt mean nowadays students are not like that. 

Very Nice artcile with True facts.

Totally Agree with your points . Keep writing sir.

thanks a lot sir to boost up moral of students like me who still believe in doing it by self study..

Hello sir,

I think ur article is completely illogical for those students who r doing articleship and hardly get time for studies.Coming from office at 8 pm and concentrating on the institute mat to understand the concepts is just like looking for water in desert.

I dont know about other cities but Kolkata has got so many talented teachers for CA curriculum teaching in completely student friendly manner.

In articleship ,employers want us to do the work even 10 days before the exam i.e  they are least bothered about our exams but the teachers wants us to pass with good marks unlike the employer who wants us to fail.

From the above anyone can understand that tutions are important for concept clearing.

i agreee with you sir 

but for those who clear cpt after 12th exams they normally do not know anything about law,tax and cafm

so what i feel is coaching is must if u are not graduate

hope u will agree with my point sir

cheers

Originally posted by : Arniv Sharda - stroke of wind
	i agreee with you sir  but for those who clear cpt after 12th exams they normally do not know anything about law,tax and cafm so what i feel is coaching is must if u are not graduate hope u will agree with my point sir cheers

take coaching where ever required and try to improve on your own. my idea is never confined to coaching world rather up grade towards ICAI requirement.  Cheers dear