Our intitute sorry members' insitute has come with 2 email ids for complaining about coaching classes and dummy articles. But i feel they will be misused. Some of the cases are:
a) Suppose there are 2-3 top fiercely competitive coaching classes in Mumbai A,B and C. A uses a fake email id and emails icai about B that it runs classes dring noon(every classes that). ICai raids the place and the coaching classes' name gets maligned even though they may not be caught red-handed.
b) ICAI officials or those raiding extorting or taking haftaa from leading coachingwales.(i think this has been going on for long time).
c) There are 2 students X and Y. Suppose both are having exams this November. Suppose Y wants to harass X or wants to disturb X's preparation. He emails to icai that X is dummy and ICAI phones/taunts/threatens X and asks for his bank statement,work diary. It is a well known fact that majority doen't maintain work diary.
X is a genuine student(=bechara,exploited student). Now he will be tensed. Exams are in Nov and he has just been arguing with his principal for a 4 MOTNH leave. So CA will haggle while signing Work report for him before submission for icai( it might expose his exploitation of poor students). Next thing is that our icai doesn't care a DAMN FOR STUDENTS and everything related to students move AT SNAIL'S PACE.it will take minimum 3 months for ICAI to finally announce its verdict on X (he is declared innocent and "genuine"). But by that time the STRESS and TIME WASTE will have very bad effect on his exam prep and he will not be able to study properly evn during the 3 months he gets as leave.
4) Most of the top CAs are involved in dummy articleship. Their children will not be called dummy as they will use their influence to bail them out. If any CA want; they can prove their wards; client's wards to be genuine. Plus the icai rules are very tedious and bendable(only by members of course).
Satyam fraud wales mein to kuch nahi huaa. Abhi bhi kuch nahi hogaa.
CAclubindia
