Rohit (CA-Final) (1485 Points)
31 July 2013According to me CA IPCC Result for May 2013 is 100%.
Because all my friends got cleared in this attempt (1st attempt).
We all gave G1 in May 2013 and our aggregate is as follows:
1. 232 2. 254 3. 262 4. 264 (me)
It's not ICAI which decides passing percentage, it's our own preparation and hard work which decides our future.
utsav poddar
(abc)
(45 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
no offence mate.... i truly agree with your statement.. but consider the plight and trauma of those who didnt succeed despite the hard efforts...
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
I am not pointing towards those who got failed but to those who blames ICAI for their failure.
Siddharth Singh
(CA-Final)
(202 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
| Originally posted by : Siddharth Singh | ||
 |
Nov 2011 ipcc group 2 - 29.58% May 2012 ipcc group 2 - 26.58% Nov 2012 ipcc group 2 - 20% May 2013 ipcc group 2 - 14.83% I GUESS NOW YOU WILL BE ABLE TO SEE THE DECISION BY ICAI. Today i am one of the affected students by the above decision....even though my prepartions and confidence were gud enough to clear group 2 exams... |
 |
Sorry Bhai!! Don't want to hurt your feelings but I am pointing out same thing via my post
that don't blame ICAI for poor result,
might be
100% hard work by you < hard work done by Passed Students
Siddharth Singh
(CA-Final)
(202 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
utsav poddar
(abc)
(45 Points)
Replied 31 July 2013
I totally agree with siddharth... no doubt blaming ICAI is wrong... But u cannot also question the hardwork of those failed students...
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 01 August 2013
| Originally posted by : Siddharth Singh | ||
|
|
Okay then tell me that why pass % is decreasing attempt by attempt inspite of the fact that the difficulty level of papers(recent 4-5 attempts) is average, neither hard nor easy... |
|
Ahhh!! I am not saying that you have not done hard work but might be your hard work was not upto level that ICAI expected, I said that ICAI doen't have personal problem with those who got failed.
I am pointing out same point from starting that it doesn't matter what is passing percentage, it matters how much work you have done.
Checking will be same all over India and not different for those who got failed. (Read this line many times)
ICAI exams are not like CAT or IIT Entrance Exams that only top students will be selected, ICAI says we will select those who complete our passing requirement.
It might be possible that overall result is decreasing and ICAI is manuplating Passing percentage but equally true that they will keep checking same for all students.
If you see my views not as a frustated student, you will agree with me.
But Sorry!! If you got hurt by my words. But I still say ICAI can't decide our career, everyone has equal oppprtunity.
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 01 August 2013
| Originally posted by : utsav poddar | ||
|
|
I totally agree with siddharth... no doubt blaming ICAI is wrong... But u cannot also question the hardwork of those failed students... |
|
I totally agree with you, I am not blaming those got failed but those who blames ICAI for their failure.
sandeep kumar
(student)
(30 Points)
Replied 01 August 2013
S.ASWATH
(Manager)
(704 Points)
Replied 04 August 2013
|
Actually I thoutht I should not participate on this but I want to answer for this
Originally posted by : Rohit |
||
|
|
Originally posted by : Siddharth Singh Okay then tell me that why pass % is decreasing attempt by attempt inspite of the fact that the difficulty level of papers(recent 4-5 attempts) is average, neither hard nor easy... Ahhh!! I am not saying that you have not done hard work but might be your hard work was not upto level that ICAI expected, I said that ICAI doen't have personal problem with those who got failed. I am pointing out same point from starting that it doesn't matter what is passing percentage, it matters how much work you have done. Checking will be same all over India and not different for those who got failed. (Read this line many times) ICAI exams are not like CAT or IIT Entrance Exams that only top students will be selected, ICAI says we will select those who complete our passing requirement. It might be possible that overall result is decreasing and ICAI is manuplating Passing percentage but equally true that they will keep checking same for all students. If you see my views not as a frustated student, you will agree with me. But Sorry!! If you got hurt by my words. But I still say ICAI can't decide our career, everyone has equal oppprtunity. |
|
Rohit if that is the case even I am one of the affected student but I am ready to take challanege for revaluation openely if the correction mechanism is same then no reason to avoid revaluation BOS itself accepted revaluation in professional exams will not be allowed due to the correction point of view of one person will not be same as others hence it is not right to allow
Please I request you don't argue simply against others feelings.............
Rohit
(CA-Final)
(1485 Points)
Replied 04 August 2013
| Originally posted by : S.ASWATH | ||
|
Rohit if that is the case even I am one of the affected student but I am ready to take challanege for revaluation openely if the correction mechanism is same then no reason to avoid revaluation BOS itself accepted revaluation in professional exams will not be allowed  due to the correction point of view of one person will not be same as others hence it is not right to allowPlease I request you don't argue simply against others feelings..(I have mentioned several times but one more time for you "I am NOT against those who got failed but against those who blames ICAI for failure." |
|
|
1. I am not trying to hurt anyone feelings, but I am saying it is wrong to blame ICAI for your failure.
2. Revaluation is allowed in CA Exams. So never think ICAI is against you.
Revaulation in ICAI is allowed w.e.f. Nov. 2011 --> https://www.charteredclub.com/procedure-for-revaluation-of-ca-cpt-pcc-ipcc-final-marks/
Siddharth Singh
(CA-Final)
(202 Points)
Replied 04 August 2013
S.ASWATH
(Manager)
(704 Points)
Replied 05 August 2013
Rohit,
Ya u r right we should not blame ICAI but in the same case we have to accept it is doing for some reason but it is doing this this is fact which we have to accept.
Please brother be clear revaluation will not be allowed it is reverification only not the revaluation it includes
whether all papers having corrected or not signature is same or not on all page and total is correct or not thats all if one question valued it will not be revalued......................
6 days Certification Course on GST Practical Return Filing Process
CAclubindia
