arree yaar why all of u taking so much interest in the post.....jisne bolna tha wo to bol ke chup ho gaya(H.B.)..iske baad koi post aaya kya uska..leave this bullsh*t..bahar niklo is bakwaas se..respect ur profession, respect ur work and most importantly..RESPECT URSELF..b.coz no one can be like ur self..u are one of its own kind

in my opinion future me aise kisi bhi post pe dont reply..then only these kind of post will stop

regards

Dear all, I am happy to see the positive thoughts flowing in the minds of CCI members about the profession. Even some senior members here de-motivated the Future CAs by making unnecessary comments on recent CA examination passing trends ( One member compared a CA with a Chaufer and the other said this High Pass Percentage is "Not good for CA Industry"). Those are their views. In my personal view they don't respect the efforts put in by recently qualified CAs to pass the examinations. Somewhere I thought that people will blindly agree to them. But opinion differs and I am happy to see the opinion of majority of them here are on positive side. Let us be focussed and positive to take this profession as well as our career to greater heights.

Totally bakawas baat.As number of input is more ,thats why results of CA is better.

2)Student contibuted there 110% in CA exam as compare to other they only laboue one month

So as student are more better perform in CA exam ,as they labour more than 100% ,so it automatically CA results id good.

The more % is due to hard labour of student not other reason u say.

Lastly one Ca is more than 5 MBA (only minus Communicatoin.)

C A    ROCKS............................!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by : CA MANISH AGRAWAL
	Totally bakawas baat.As number of input is more ,thats why results of CA is better. 2)Student contibuted there 110% in CA exam as compare to other they only laboue one month So as student are more better perform in CA exam ,as they labour more than 100% ,so it automatically CA results id good. The more % is due to hard labour of student not other reason u say. Lastly one Ca is more than 5 MBA (only minus Communicatoin.)   C A    ROCKS............................!!!!!!!!

Very True Mr Manish Agrawal input is not only more in terms of number of students joining the course, but also more in terms of efforts students make to clear the examinations. More efforts will always result in good results. And irrespective of pass percentage, I feel that CA will stand seperately and the scope will further expand for CAs. That is the beauty of this profession.

WITH THE INCREASE IN STUDENTS PASSPERCENTAGE ALSO SHOULD INCREASE OTHER WISE PEOPLE WILL GET MAD

I WANT TO ASK 1 QUESTION.....

IS IT FAIR TO COMPARE CA WITH CWA????

No Mr DRP, it is unfair to compare any professional course with another, because the scope, services and area of expertise are altogether different. Also it is constantly changing for all the three professions i.e. CA, CWA and CS. Once CAs are known by majority of people only as tax advisors or person who certifies financial statemens etc but now the scope has increased to many areas. CAs do project planning, assists in designing ERPs, Valuation services etc. Same is the case of CS and CWA as well the scope is increasing and will continue to increase. 

Dear HB

I believe you must be comparing wrt compensation a fresh CA is getting, higher result is because of academic expertise and low compensation is because of lack of practical knowledge.

One can see there are 2 CA out of 5 people in top management of most of the companies...

Feel the value of this profession and pls honor your profession it is source of our bread and butter..

There is no comparison of CA and B.COM, CA more than 100 times what B.COM is. So don't even dare to compare.

My humble request to all members and students of CA fraternity is to avoid and discourage such negative comments.

Originally posted by : CA Vikash Burnwal
	My humble request to all members and students of CA fraternity is to avoid and discourage such negative comments.

Yes Vikash I too agree with you. But the most shocking part is these negative comments are going rounds for quite some time from even some of the senior members of CCI. Why cant they motivate students joining this profession. I believe future is safe for CAs. Also if they feel that the scope of CAs is being reduced they should give some new ideas or areas where we can explore our professional opportunities rather than discouraging students. However I am happy to see most of them are positive

Mr. Satish, I am sure you would agree with the fact that those are critisising are either not CA or lack of skills. As far as demand for CAs is concerned there is still gaap betbeen demand and supply demand is higher than availability the only thing is skilled people required. 

No Mr Vikas, some people who criticized were CAs (Really I don't know whether they lack skills required for profession or whether they are underachievers) and they are very senior members in CCI. I agree with u that there is a demand-supply gap and what is required is only skilled CAs as supply. Some even suggested that ICAI should calculate region-wise demand and restrict the result based on such demand ( I Believe ICAI has more issues to be addressed like convergence with IFRS, Making recommendations for GST etc. rather than doing any statistical research or work of a Planning Commission). Everyone cannot be very optimistic person at all point of time, such negative comments and suggestions coming from them would create more negative thoughts. I urge them to stop this. I still believe what you said Mr Vikas, the scope of CAs and demand will not be curtailed. 

hey guys,

I did both the CA and CWA, and i am very much fond of all the courses including B.com.Please dont rate them as Good and Bad,all these courses are having their own places,education  does not teach us to rate  education itself....act maturely,,CA/CS/CWA each one of them are specialised in their own way,i agree the   y are alike in someways of their style of teaching and content of study.But our commercial world needs all those three courses.As far as concerned with BCOM vs CA,i wud say that this question is wrong,whosoever raised this question is neither  have idea of what CAs are and their contribution to nation nor he is mature enough to raise some knowledgeable and fruitful discussion.

Well said Manish. Each course differs in scope and it is unfair to compare. And all the three are required for National Development as you said.