Go Ad-Free on CAclubindia with Daily Mobile Updates. Subscribe Now!

Best idt teacher

arun nagar (no) (25 Points)

19 May 2011

who id the best teacher for idt Rajkumar sir or Manoj Batar sir plz reply soon

Reply
Follow
Share

13 Replies

(Guest)

arun i have studied from raj kumar sir and he is damm good in clearing the concept.. so i would suggest him only.. i dont know about manoj sir. so cant say..

and i would also suggest u to talk to old students of both and have opinion of senior members..

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA Vaibhav (.) (42 Points)
Replied 21 May 2011

I am also a student of raj kumar but i regret to say that Raj kumar is a SHAM.

He can make u mug up the concepts but his practical knowledge is almost 0.

No practical concepts, wastes a lot of time in class, does not teach any tax planning and also no practical or past exam questions in the class.Moreover ask any ques. out of book, and you will find him avoiding/deferring/ignoring such question.

More than half of the time is wasted in copying.

I have taken amendment class from Manoj batra, he is excellent teacher with exact clarity of concepts.

Putting it priority wise:

1. Best book for self study- Bangar

2.Best teacher- Dippak gupta

If above 2 options are not available.

Go for Manoj batra,

LAST resort- raj kumar.

1 Like

CA. Manoj Joshi (CA, CS and CMA) (134 Points)
Replied 22 May 2011

the best teacher for IDT is no doubt Dippak Gupta...even though i hvnt tkn coachin from him,i hv studied frm his SCANNER and his amendment booklet...n got 65 marks in may 2010...i dont knw abt rajkumar and heard abt manoj batra sir from my frnds dat he is a bakwaas teacher...

KISI SE BHI COACHING LO...STUDY AT D END KHUD HI KRNI PADEGI DOST...

1 Like

CA PuRvI M!$rA (-) (2260 Points)
Replied 22 May 2011

deepak gupta is d best teacher fr idt.............

Raj (Senior Article) (22 Points)
Replied 22 May 2011

first preference is deepak gupta otherwise go for Manoj Batra Sir

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

CA-CWA RAVI (CA-CWA in industry) (5464 Points)
Replied 24 May 2011

dont go for manoj batra

instead do self study at home

first choice : dipak gupta

second : rajkumar

third : study at home from bangar or ajay jain sir's book

MAYANK AGRAWAL (STUDENT) (27 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

who is the best teacher of IDT for Exam preparation

whether we should choose raj kumar or not?if not who is best?

what is the better for unknown person -coaching or self study?

how can get knowledge from self study and book name

MAYANK AGRAWAL (STUDENT) (27 Points)
Replied 17 August 2012

can be possible that audit,law,isca from self study?

best book for understanding language/concept/theory easily?

CA Kapil Sabharwal (CA ) (380 Points)
Replied 08 August 2013

mere dost kisi ki mat sun ghar baith kar khud hi parh le tuitions par time bahut lag jata hai. i have taken classes from CA Manoj Batra & undoutedly he is a master f his subject.

Ganesh (accoutnant) (52 Points)
Replied 21 August 2013

In Mumbai Drugesh Singh from Professional Academy Rules. Great concepts, comprehensive coverage & coming soon to Chennai & other cities in India.

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

shashank singh (none) (37 Points)
Replied 01 June 2016

Deepak gupta is best teacher for IDT

Soni Sharma (Student) (64 Points)
Replied 01 June 2016

hello freinds

what about OSP sir? I heard about him from one of my freind. She had taken classes from Raj Kumar Sir in 2013 but not clear in her attempt, then for revision purpose she go for OSP classes. She gave me positive view about his classes -

complete full idt in just 30 days at affordable fees. helps in learning rules and sections thouroughly.

good in practical knowledge especially in service tax.

whether I go to OSP sir or so called other famous teachers.

Pankaj Mehta (61 Points)
Replied 04 December 2016

Hii all of you . Let me give u all a honest review of the best DIRECT TAX Professor for CA Final and CA IPCC in entire India in todays time.

He is CA Aarish Khan from Professional Academy ( Now Anuj Jalota Education) Mumbai teaching at 4 places at Andheri , Borivali, Ghatkopar and Charni Road and was also a part of ETEN CA earlier.

Undoubtedly the knowledge which he possesses in his subject is unbeatable as compared to any other Professor across India. He gives a detail analysis of each and every section which is there in the entire Income Tax Act.

He gives a complete set of text books with all provisions from BARE ACT ( Some teachers in the market just teach without explaining students the implications of BARE ACT which is absolutely wrong at Final CA ) There are more than 100 chapters in this curriculum which covers smallest of the chapters.

Along with the text book he also gives summary of each and every provision so that a student can revise very fast during exams .

Along with this there are more than 300 questions in his text book along with all the questions from ICAI PM.

Apart from this his books are updated with all the recent amendments plus it has all the recent Case laws in it.

Let me just conclude by saying that if u haven't learned DIRECT TAX from him then u have definitely missed something great in CA Final .
Undoubtedly he is best. Do learn tax from him and u will always cherish it and u will also bless me for making u aware of him. And yes he was also All India highest in Tax in Final CA which in itself is a great achievement.

Thanks all of you.