Finance/Compliance Consultant
78081 Points
Posted on 07 November 2026
For FY 2019-20 the position is relatively favourable:
• Sec 16(2)(aa) (ITC only if the invoice appears in the supplier's GSTR-1 / 2B) came into force on 1 January 2022, so it doesn't apply to 2019-20.
• For 2019-20, Rule 36(4) allowed provisional ITC up to 10% (from February 2020, 10% and then 5%) of eligible ITC reflected in 2A, cumulatively adjusted for February–August 2020 in the September 2020 return.
• Where the seller never filed returns or paid tax, the department invokes Sec 16(2)(c) (tax actually paid to the government). The SC upheld the denial of ITC in genuine cases only where the buyer couldn't prove the transaction, and HCs (e.g. Calcutta HC in Suncraft Energy, SLP dismissed) have held that a bona fide recipient with invoice, payment and receipt proof shouldn't be denied ITC; the department should first proceed against the defaulting supplier.
• Reply with the invoice, e-way bill, transport proof, bank payment and stock records. Show you met all conditions in your control.