Predetermined E-1 Sales

This query is : Resolved

CA. O.P. Agarwalla (Querist)
Follow

21 August 2009 Dear Sirs,

Apex Court's judgment in A&G Metals case had emerged a debate on the issue that whether a sale in course of Inter state trade and commerce against a sales contract made prior to the movement of goods can get the exemption of section 6(2) of the C.S.T. Act?

Para no. 11 of the said judgment speaks that "The dividing line between sales or purchases under Section 3(a) and those falling under Section 3(b) is that in the
former case the movement is under the contract whereas in the latter case the contract comes into existence only after the commencement and before termination of the inter-State movement of the goods.

I invite your valuable comments on this issue.
O.P. Agarwalla

MAHENDRA

MAHENDRA (Querist)
Follow

21 August 2009 dear sir,
i wanted to know about e filling of income tax return for all categories.
are there free software available on net which can help filling e returns,pls give name of such link so i can downloan.
i have so many employees hows returns for 0809 has to be filled so pls urgently suggest for e filing of there return
thanks in advance
mahendra

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani

CA CS CIMA Prakash Somani (Expert)
Follow

21 August 2009

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

A. Sankaranarayana

A. Sankaranarayana (Expert)
Follow

21 August 2009 Dear Mr. Mahendra,

1. go to www.incometaxindia.gov.in

2. click eReturn Option - in the left hand side.

3. see the option for individuals

4. Select the Form

5. Select the Format in Excel

6. Download

7. Fill up the Form and file the return

A. Sankaranarayana
9448144025
Bangalore

CA CHINTAN AJMERA

CA CHINTAN AJMERA (Expert)
Follow

22 August 2009 www.incometaxindia.gov.in

CA. O.P. Agarwalla

CA. O.P. Agarwalla (Querist)
Follow

22 August 2009 Noreply yet

Asha Kanta Sharma

Asha Kanta Sharma

(Expert)
Follow

10 August 2024 The Apex Court's judgment in the case of **A&G Metals** has indeed clarified critical aspects of the interpretation of Section 6(2) of the Central Sales Tax (CST) Act, 1956, particularly with regard to the eligibility for exemption on inter-state sales.

### **Key Aspects of the Judgment**

1. **Section 6(2) of CST Act**:
- This section provides an exemption for sales that occur in the course of inter-state trade or commerce, specifically sales that are made under the contract of sale that is made before the movement of goods.

2. **Interpretation of Sections 3(a) and 3(b)**:
- **Section 3(a)**: Deals with inter-state sales where the movement of goods is **under the contract** of sale. This means that the sale is linked to the movement of goods from one state to another. The contract is entered into prior to the commencement of the movement.
- **Section 3(b)**: Pertains to inter-state sales where the **contract of sale is made after the commencement** of the inter-state movement of goods but before its termination. This means that the sale is concluded during the movement of goods.

### **Insights from the A&G Metals Judgment**

**Para No. 11** of the judgment is pivotal as it delineates the boundary between the two sections:

- **Sales Under Section 3(a)**: For a sale to qualify for exemption under Section 6(2) of the CST Act, it must be demonstrated that the movement of goods was **under the contract**. This implies that the contract of sale was made **before** the movement of goods began.

- **Sales Under Section 3(b)**: If the contract is concluded **after** the movement of goods has commenced, then the sale falls under Section 3(b). In such cases, the exemption under Section 6(2) may not be applicable, as the contract of sale was not in place before the commencement of the movement.

### **Comments and Implications**

1. **Timing of the Contract**:
- The **timing** of the contract is crucial. For a sale to be exempt under Section 6(2), the contract must be in place before the movement of goods starts. If the contract is established during or after the movement of goods, it falls under Section 3(b) and may not qualify for the exemption.

2. **Documentary Evidence**:
- Proper documentation and evidence are critical. Businesses must maintain clear records showing that the contract was executed before the goods began their interstate movement to claim the exemption.

3. **Impact on Tax Planning**:
- Companies involved in interstate trade should ensure that their contracts are executed and documented in line with the requirements of Section 6(2) to benefit from the exemption. They should also consider how these requirements affect their tax planning and compliance.

4. **Legal and Compliance Risks**:
- Businesses need to be cautious about the timing of their contracts and the movement of goods to avoid disputes and legal issues related to the applicability of tax exemptions.

### **Summary**

The Supreme Court's judgment in the A&G Metals case underscores the importance of aligning the timing of sales contracts with the movement of goods to qualify for exemptions under Section 6(2) of the CST Act. The exemption is available when the contract is made **before** the commencement of the movement of goods. Proper contract management and documentation are essential to ensure compliance with this provision and to avoid potential tax liabilities.

If you are involved in interstate trade, reviewing your contracts and understanding their implications on tax exemptions is crucial. Consulting with a tax advisor or legal expert can provide guidance tailored to your specific circumstances.