Noc from ca

This query is : Open

parwani (Querist)
Follow

20 June 2013 I HAVE AUDITED MY BOOKS FOR A.Y 12-13 & OBTAIN REPORT & SINGED B/S FROM MY C.A.
FOR SOME PURCHASE RETURN NOT TAKEN IN ACCOUUNTS WE FILEED REVISED RETUN ,
NOW I HAVE TO CHANGE ME CA BUT HE DENIED FOR SIGNING REVISED BALANCSHEET PAPERS . PAYMENT IS OUSTSANDING. IF WE DONT MAKE PAYMENT HE WILL NOT GIVE NOC.
HE ARGUE THAT SAME CA CAN NOT SIGNED IN ORIGINAL & REVISED RETURN. IT IS RESPOSIBILITY OF CA WHAT HE HAD VERIFY.

MY QUERY IS

IT IS CMPLSRY TO OBTAIN NOC FROM OLD CA

IS THERRE ANY RULE THAT CA CAN NOT SINGED IN REVISED BALANCE SHEET.

WHAT ARE LEGAL ASPECTS IN THIS REGARD
CAN I COMPLAINT IN CA INSTITUE IN THIS MATTER..

PLZ SUGGEST RIGID RULLING FOR REVISED RETURN & BALNCE SHEET MATTER.

THANKS IN ADVANCE

Rupesh Jain

Rupesh Jain (Expert)
Follow

20 June 2013 r/sir

you obtian audit report from
CA and without taking revised audit report
you can not revise audit report of CA.

at present if your case of income tax select for securtiny .
you face problem, due to you already write that CA is not agree for revised audit reprot.

secondly you can change your CA.
but new CA without old CA premission can not do your audit.

CS RAJESH C.CHOUDHARY

CS RAJESH C.CHOUDHARY (Expert)
Follow

20 June 2013 Agree with Rupesh Jain

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

parwani

parwani (Querist)
Follow

20 June 2013 Rupesh sir,

Plz clear one doubt, original return filled with orginal audit repor.

Revised return is filled same audit report with change in Balance sheet Data. With concern of c.a.

As per C.A opinion audit report is not revised only blance sheet & profit & losss account changed.

Now he said he will not signed revises balance sheet.

In case how i check my op bls with rerised data.

& what is other way for such discripancy.