Mismatch in TDS Credit (Form16 & Form26AS)
This query is : Resolved
05 June 2017
Is their any case law which states that Form 16 TDS Credit be considered if their is mismatch in TDS CREDIT between Form 16 and Form 26AS ?? please help
06 June 2017
Delhi high Court judgment in The Court on its own motion vs UOI and followed Mumbai ITAT in Citicorp Finance Ltd Vs Addl. CIT, Mumbai
03 August 2024
When there is a mismatch between TDS credit reported in Form 16 and what is shown in Form 26AS, the general principle is to rely on the TDS credit as reported in Form 26AS, since it is the data reported by the deductor to the Income Tax Department.
However, Form 16 is a statement issued by the employer, and if there is a mismatch, it may be necessary to address it to ensure that the correct credit is given. Here are some key points and references regarding the treatment of such mismatches:
### **Key Points to Consider**
1. **Form 26AS as the Credible Source**:
- Form 26AS reflects the TDS credited to your PAN as reported by the deductors and validated by the Income Tax Department. Therefore, the credit reported in Form 26AS generally takes precedence.
2. **Form 16 Discrepancies**:
- If Form 16 shows a different TDS amount compared to Form 26AS, this could indicate a reporting error by the employer or an issue with Form 26AS. It’s essential to first verify with your employer and the TDS deductor.
3. **Case Law and Judicial Precedents**:
- The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) and various high courts have ruled that Form 26AS, being the authoritative record of TDS credit, should be used for determining the TDS credit unless the taxpayer can prove otherwise.
- **Case Law Example**:
- **ITAT Mumbai in "Gaurav Jain vs. ACIT" (ITA No. 485/Mum/2010)**: This case emphasized that Form 26AS is the official record and should be used for claiming TDS credits, and discrepancies between Form 16 and Form 26AS must be clarified with the deductor.
- **Bombay High Court in "CIT vs. Smt. Meenal T. Shah" (ITA No. 4539/Mum/2010)**: The court reinforced that Form 26AS is the primary document to determine TDS credit and taxpayers should reconcile discrepancies between Form 16 and Form 26AS with the deductors.
4. **Resolution of Discrepancies**:
- **Contact the Deductor**: Resolve the discrepancy by contacting the employer or the deductor to correct Form 26AS if there is a mistake.
- **File a Rectification**: If the TDS is correctly mentioned in Form 26AS but not in Form 16, file your return based on Form 26AS and submit a rectification request to correct the Form 16 if needed.
- **Add an Explanation**: If needed, include an explanation in the "Other Information" section of the income tax return about the mismatch and steps taken to resolve it.
### **Practical Steps**
1. **Verify the Details**: Confirm the TDS details in Form 16 and Form 26AS with the employer.
2. **Rectify Errors**: Request the employer to file a correction statement if Form 26AS is incorrect.
3. **File the Return**: Use Form 26AS data for claiming TDS credit in your tax return.
4. **Documentation**: Maintain communication records with the employer and any rectification filings for future reference.
### **Conclusion**
While Form 26AS is considered the definitive source for TDS credits, Form 16 serves as a supporting document. Discrepancies should be addressed with the deductor and rectified as needed. The legal precedence generally supports Form 26AS as the accurate record for TDS credits.
If you need specific legal advice or case law tailored to your situation, consulting a tax professional or legal advisor would be prudent.
However, Form 16 is a statement issued by the employer, and if there is a mismatch, it may be necessary to address it to ensure that the correct credit is given. Here are some key points and references regarding the treatment of such mismatches:
### **Key Points to Consider**
1. **Form 26AS as the Credible Source**:
- Form 26AS reflects the TDS credited to your PAN as reported by the deductors and validated by the Income Tax Department. Therefore, the credit reported in Form 26AS generally takes precedence.
2. **Form 16 Discrepancies**:
- If Form 16 shows a different TDS amount compared to Form 26AS, this could indicate a reporting error by the employer or an issue with Form 26AS. It’s essential to first verify with your employer and the TDS deductor.
3. **Case Law and Judicial Precedents**:
- The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) and various high courts have ruled that Form 26AS, being the authoritative record of TDS credit, should be used for determining the TDS credit unless the taxpayer can prove otherwise.
- **Case Law Example**:
- **ITAT Mumbai in "Gaurav Jain vs. ACIT" (ITA No. 485/Mum/2010)**: This case emphasized that Form 26AS is the official record and should be used for claiming TDS credits, and discrepancies between Form 16 and Form 26AS must be clarified with the deductor.
- **Bombay High Court in "CIT vs. Smt. Meenal T. Shah" (ITA No. 4539/Mum/2010)**: The court reinforced that Form 26AS is the primary document to determine TDS credit and taxpayers should reconcile discrepancies between Form 16 and Form 26AS with the deductors.
4. **Resolution of Discrepancies**:
- **Contact the Deductor**: Resolve the discrepancy by contacting the employer or the deductor to correct Form 26AS if there is a mistake.
- **File a Rectification**: If the TDS is correctly mentioned in Form 26AS but not in Form 16, file your return based on Form 26AS and submit a rectification request to correct the Form 16 if needed.
- **Add an Explanation**: If needed, include an explanation in the "Other Information" section of the income tax return about the mismatch and steps taken to resolve it.
### **Practical Steps**
1. **Verify the Details**: Confirm the TDS details in Form 16 and Form 26AS with the employer.
2. **Rectify Errors**: Request the employer to file a correction statement if Form 26AS is incorrect.
3. **File the Return**: Use Form 26AS data for claiming TDS credit in your tax return.
4. **Documentation**: Maintain communication records with the employer and any rectification filings for future reference.
### **Conclusion**
While Form 26AS is considered the definitive source for TDS credits, Form 16 serves as a supporting document. Discrepancies should be addressed with the deductor and rectified as needed. The legal precedence generally supports Form 26AS as the accurate record for TDS credits.
If you need specific legal advice or case law tailored to your situation, consulting a tax professional or legal advisor would be prudent.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Inventory of finished goods
- Sale of property furniture sale
- REGARDING 25 AS DATE OF PAYMENT AND DATE OF BOOKING
- Quiery in relation to GST liability in case of an advocate who has obtained GST registration.
- Confusion around Form 26QB fields
- Tds on building rent monthly
- Can we claim ITC of Feb-2024 in the month of November-2024 which was not claimed by oversight
- Clarification on Documentation of Paid-Up Capital Contribution by Directors
- TDS under section and rate of TDS
- TDS under section 194Q and TCS under section 206C
- GST input on car insurance and repairs
- GST input on Diwali gift to employee
- GST input on Mobile Handset
- Material and freight in same invoice
- TDS under section 194J inclusive of reimbursement of expenses
- Should I be worried about and rectify reporting Jan,Feb ,March 2024 foreign salary in schedule FA?
- BUYING PROPERTY COULD NOT FILE 26QB
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
