Internal Audit v/s Direct Taxation
This query is : Resolved
27 October 2008
I am a PCC article. My querry is that at this level of CA what is the best field to my pursue articleship into, is it internal audit or direct taxation (basically income tax & all that). Currently I'm doing my articleship in a mid-sized firm.
I have just cleared CPT in June '08, have done my graduation in Eco.(H) from DU and cleared 12th in commerce stream.
So basically which one of them provides us more learning and has more value in the market.
Mostly importantly considering the fact that which one of them would be the best for me to do at current level of being a PCC article.
And is it true as some people say that if at PCC level you do your articleship in internal audit only, then after clearing PCC exams & enter CA final articleship and apply into big 4 firms they would preferably put you into or offer you to continue your articleship into internal audit only and not into taxation, because at PCC level you have done internal audit only so they would offer you that field only...?? Is this true...??
Any replies would be really appreciated.
I have just cleared CPT in June '08, have done my graduation in Eco.(H) from DU and cleared 12th in commerce stream.
So basically which one of them provides us more learning and has more value in the market.
Mostly importantly considering the fact that which one of them would be the best for me to do at current level of being a PCC article.
And is it true as some people say that if at PCC level you do your articleship in internal audit only, then after clearing PCC exams & enter CA final articleship and apply into big 4 firms they would preferably put you into or offer you to continue your articleship into internal audit only and not into taxation, because at PCC level you have done internal audit only so they would offer you that field only...?? Is this true...??
Any replies would be really appreciated.
28 October 2008
i WOULD RECOMMEND YOU JOIN MEDIUM SIZED fIRM AND NOT CONSENTRATE TOO MUCH ON BIG FOURS
29 October 2008
My opinion is Direct Taxation gives you more life. During your articleship, undestand the corporate taxation and various areas indepth. Lern these from the basic. this will help you a lot.
31 October 2008
Mr.Bosu & Mr.Venkat first of all thanks for your reply.
Mr.Bosu I'm already working in a mid-sized firm. But the problem is that the firm I'm working in has internal audits only. That's why I'm doing internal audit only. And that is also the reason why I have raised the above querry of Internal; Audit v/s Direct Taxation.
Mr.Venkat I intended to know about articleship at current level of my PCC articleship because I haven't done taxation yet, as in college too I did Eco.(H).
And that's why I want to know whether if I do only internal audit for the moment and later after PCC apply into big 4 for further articleship with this experience, will they allow me into or offer me my CA Final articleship into taxation department...?? Or they will offer me internal audit only, for the reason that I have did my PCC articleship in internal audit only (& nothing else in it)>>> Is this true of such a thing to happen...??
>>> And most importantly which one of them has more value in the market...??
Your & all other expert's guidance would really be valuable to me. As it would help me in taking some really important career decisions.
Mr.Bosu I'm already working in a mid-sized firm. But the problem is that the firm I'm working in has internal audits only. That's why I'm doing internal audit only. And that is also the reason why I have raised the above querry of Internal; Audit v/s Direct Taxation.
Mr.Venkat I intended to know about articleship at current level of my PCC articleship because I haven't done taxation yet, as in college too I did Eco.(H).
And that's why I want to know whether if I do only internal audit for the moment and later after PCC apply into big 4 for further articleship with this experience, will they allow me into or offer me my CA Final articleship into taxation department...?? Or they will offer me internal audit only, for the reason that I have did my PCC articleship in internal audit only (& nothing else in it)>>> Is this true of such a thing to happen...??
>>> And most importantly which one of them has more value in the market...??
Your & all other expert's guidance would really be valuable to me. As it would help me in taking some really important career decisions.
01 August 2024
Choosing between internal audit and direct taxation for your articleship is an important decision that can shape your career trajectory in significant ways. Here’s a breakdown to help you evaluate your options:
### **1. Internal Audit vs. Direct Taxation**
#### **Internal Audit:**
**Pros:**
- **Broad Exposure:** Provides insights into the functioning of various departments and processes within a company. This can be beneficial if you aim to understand the overall internal controls and risk management.
- **Skills Development:** Helps develop skills in evaluating internal controls, assessing risks, and improving processes. It also enhances understanding of compliance and operational efficiency.
- **Career Path:** Can lead to roles in internal audit, risk management, and compliance. It can also be a stepping stone to managerial roles in these areas.
**Cons:**
- **Specialization:** May not provide in-depth knowledge of direct taxation and other tax-related areas, which could limit your expertise in tax compliance and planning.
- **Market Demand:** While there is a demand for internal auditors, direct taxation and tax advisory roles also have significant opportunities, especially in larger firms or consultancies.
#### **Direct Taxation (Income Tax):**
**Pros:**
- **Specialized Knowledge:** Provides in-depth knowledge of tax laws, compliance, and planning. This is crucial for roles in tax advisory, tax compliance, and tax planning.
- **Career Opportunities:** High demand for tax professionals in accounting firms, corporate tax departments, and consultancies. Can lead to specialized roles in tax planning and advisory.
- **Value in Market:** Tax expertise is highly valued and often comes with opportunities for significant growth and specialization.
**Cons:**
- **Complexity:** Tax laws can be complex and frequently change, requiring continual learning and adaptation.
- **Niche Focus:** Specializing early in tax may limit your exposure to other areas of accounting and finance unless you later diversify your skills.
### **2. Career Implications and Big 4 Firms**
- **Internal Audit Experience:** If you continue in internal audit for your PCC articleship, big 4 firms might offer you roles in internal audit or related fields. However, many big 4 firms also value diverse experience and may allow transitions into other areas, including direct taxation, especially if you show an interest and aptitude for it.
- **Direct Taxation Experience:** If you gain experience in direct taxation during your PCC articleship, you may be better positioned for roles in tax departments of big 4 firms or tax consultancies.
### **3. Value in the Market**
- **Direct Taxation:** Generally considered highly valuable due to the specialized nature of tax roles and the need for expertise in navigating complex tax regulations. Tax professionals often command high salaries and have opportunities in various sectors.
- **Internal Audit:** While valuable, internal audit roles may not have the same level of specialization or perceived prestige as tax roles. However, it offers valuable experience in risk management and process improvement, which can be leveraged in various roles.
### **Recommendations:**
- **Current Experience:** Given that you are already working in a firm with internal audit, you might want to consider gaining some experience in direct taxation if possible, either through additional training or by exploring opportunities to work on tax-related tasks.
- **Future Prospects:** If you plan to work with a big 4 firm, having a diverse experience can be beneficial. Consider discussing your career goals with your current firm and explore possibilities to gain exposure to direct taxation.
- **Personal Interests:** Reflect on your interests and career aspirations. If you are more inclined towards understanding tax regulations and compliance, direct taxation might be more fulfilling. Conversely, if you are interested in evaluating internal controls and improving processes, internal audit could be a better fit.
Ultimately, both fields offer valuable career opportunities, and the best choice depends on your career goals, interests, and the specific skills you wish to develop.
### **1. Internal Audit vs. Direct Taxation**
#### **Internal Audit:**
**Pros:**
- **Broad Exposure:** Provides insights into the functioning of various departments and processes within a company. This can be beneficial if you aim to understand the overall internal controls and risk management.
- **Skills Development:** Helps develop skills in evaluating internal controls, assessing risks, and improving processes. It also enhances understanding of compliance and operational efficiency.
- **Career Path:** Can lead to roles in internal audit, risk management, and compliance. It can also be a stepping stone to managerial roles in these areas.
**Cons:**
- **Specialization:** May not provide in-depth knowledge of direct taxation and other tax-related areas, which could limit your expertise in tax compliance and planning.
- **Market Demand:** While there is a demand for internal auditors, direct taxation and tax advisory roles also have significant opportunities, especially in larger firms or consultancies.
#### **Direct Taxation (Income Tax):**
**Pros:**
- **Specialized Knowledge:** Provides in-depth knowledge of tax laws, compliance, and planning. This is crucial for roles in tax advisory, tax compliance, and tax planning.
- **Career Opportunities:** High demand for tax professionals in accounting firms, corporate tax departments, and consultancies. Can lead to specialized roles in tax planning and advisory.
- **Value in Market:** Tax expertise is highly valued and often comes with opportunities for significant growth and specialization.
**Cons:**
- **Complexity:** Tax laws can be complex and frequently change, requiring continual learning and adaptation.
- **Niche Focus:** Specializing early in tax may limit your exposure to other areas of accounting and finance unless you later diversify your skills.
### **2. Career Implications and Big 4 Firms**
- **Internal Audit Experience:** If you continue in internal audit for your PCC articleship, big 4 firms might offer you roles in internal audit or related fields. However, many big 4 firms also value diverse experience and may allow transitions into other areas, including direct taxation, especially if you show an interest and aptitude for it.
- **Direct Taxation Experience:** If you gain experience in direct taxation during your PCC articleship, you may be better positioned for roles in tax departments of big 4 firms or tax consultancies.
### **3. Value in the Market**
- **Direct Taxation:** Generally considered highly valuable due to the specialized nature of tax roles and the need for expertise in navigating complex tax regulations. Tax professionals often command high salaries and have opportunities in various sectors.
- **Internal Audit:** While valuable, internal audit roles may not have the same level of specialization or perceived prestige as tax roles. However, it offers valuable experience in risk management and process improvement, which can be leveraged in various roles.
### **Recommendations:**
- **Current Experience:** Given that you are already working in a firm with internal audit, you might want to consider gaining some experience in direct taxation if possible, either through additional training or by exploring opportunities to work on tax-related tasks.
- **Future Prospects:** If you plan to work with a big 4 firm, having a diverse experience can be beneficial. Consider discussing your career goals with your current firm and explore possibilities to gain exposure to direct taxation.
- **Personal Interests:** Reflect on your interests and career aspirations. If you are more inclined towards understanding tax regulations and compliance, direct taxation might be more fulfilling. Conversely, if you are interested in evaluating internal controls and improving processes, internal audit could be a better fit.
Ultimately, both fields offer valuable career opportunities, and the best choice depends on your career goals, interests, and the specific skills you wish to develop.
You need to be the querist or approved CAclub expert to take part in this query .
Click here to login now
Click here to login now
Similar Resolved Queries
Unanswered Queries
- Is this income indian or foreign income?
- REGARDING GST ON COMMERICIAL PROPERTY
- 15ca /15cb whose income tax login? remitter or nri seller's login?
- GST on export of services and Input Credit
- TDS U/S. 194NF
- ITC temporary reversal and reclaim
- RCM applicability on Rent Paid by Registered Person to Unregistered Landlord for Residental Building
- Regarding Documentation & Compliances for Opening of Unit of Pvt Ltd.
- Applicable TDS rate for sale of property in Nov 2024
- Should I report my US salary for January, February, March in Schedule FA?
- Can a partnership firm become partner in a LLP ?
- Quiery in relation to GST liability in case of an advocate who has obtained GST registration.
- LAST YEAR 2022-23 ITC IN NEXT YEAR 2023-24 REPORITNG IN GSTR-9
- MIS MATCH OF INVOICE NUMBER
- IGST Credit-Show cause notice issued-confusion
- TDS on purchase of value vouchers for employees ?
- Issue of gst e invoice
- How to adjusted advances given or receipt
- Foreign vendor without PAN unable to to register due to non receipt of OTP on foreign number ?
- 133(6) DIN INVALID format error - ->WHERE TO REPLY 133(6) notice?
Trending Online Classes
CAclubindia
