10 February 2021
1) A Unregistered Partnership Firm Formed between 5 Partners in FY 2009-10 for a Specific Project for development of Open Land into Residential Apartment.
2) Firm carries out Development Work on Land (i.e. Specific Project) From FY 2012-13.
3) Every FY ITR is filed P&L, Balance Sheet is prepared. Out of 5 only Two Partners have signed such Balance Sheet.
4) Partnership Deed has a clause of Interest to be paid to Partner's who brings additional capital other than fixed Capital (i.e.Rs.10,000/-) at 12% or lower as may be mutually decided between the partners depending on the Financial Situation of the Firm, Small Profits or Loss.
5) During the Development Work from FY 2012-13 up to FY 2016-17 No Major Profit has been achieved by the Firm.
6) In FY 2018-19 Project Stands Completed One Partner post completion of Project issues Dissolution Notice to other 4 Partners.
7) In Same FY 2018-19 Tax Planning is done through appointed CA and without capitalizing Interest on Partners Capital, Firm Pays Tax on Maximum Profit Achieved as per the Ready Reckoner Rate of Unsold Inventories. Now, Post filing of ITR and Sharing of Audited Balance Sheet and P&L A/c (3 Partners) raise dispute on capitalizing Interest on Partners Capital from Period (FY 2009-10 To FY 2018-19) at the time of Settling of Accounts between partners as Per Dissolution (u/s 48 Partnership Act).
8) Can as per LAW and Income Tax Act, the Partners can claim Interest from Firm for such Period, will arbitrator allow capitalizing such Interest on Partner's Capital if the Partner's take it to the court for arbitration?
09 July 2024
In the scenario described, where partners in an unregistered partnership firm are disputing the capitalization of interest on their capital contributions, the resolution would generally depend on the terms laid out in the partnership deed, the conduct of the partners, and applicable laws including the Partnership Act and Income Tax Act. Here are some key considerations:
1. **Partnership Deed:** - The partnership deed governs the terms of partnership, including any provisions related to interest on partners' capital contributions. If the partnership deed specifies that partners are entitled to interest on their capital contributions, then partners can typically claim such interest, subject to the agreed rates and conditions.
2. **Income Tax Act Implications:** - Under the Income Tax Act, interest paid to partners on their capital contributions is treated as a deductible expense for the firm if certain conditions are met (such as the interest rate being commercially reasonable and the payment being in accordance with the partnership deed). - If the firm has not capitalized interest on partners' capital contributions and the partners wish to do so, they would need to ensure that this is reflected correctly in the firm's accounts and tax filings.
3. **Partnership Dissolution and Settlement:** - Upon dissolution of the partnership, partners are entitled to settle their accounts as per the terms agreed in the partnership deed or as determined by applicable law (Partnership Act). This includes accounting for capital contributions, profits, losses, and any interest due on capital.
4. **Arbitration or Court Proceedings:** - If partners cannot resolve the dispute internally, they may opt for arbitration or legal proceedings. In arbitration or court, partners would typically present their case based on the partnership deed terms, past practices of the firm, and any applicable legal principles. - Arbitrators or courts would consider the partnership deed provisions, past conduct of the partners, and whether interest on capital contributions was indeed payable and should have been capitalized or paid out.
5. **Documentation and Evidence:** - Partners seeking interest on their capital contributions should ensure they have documentation supporting their claim, including the partnership deed, accounting records, and any communications related to the interest payments or decisions not to capitalize interest.
In conclusion, partners in the unregistered partnership can generally claim interest on their capital contributions if provided for in the partnership deed. The resolution of disputes regarding such claims would involve interpretation of the partnership deed, adherence to the Income Tax Act provisions, and potentially arbitration or legal proceedings if partners cannot resolve the matter amicably. Arbitrators or courts would assess the validity of the claim based on the evidence presented and applicable legal principles.
CAclubindia
