Can you please let me know your opinions with regard to the following query.
Q)Mr. X a salaried employee has taken a house loan and purchased the house in his mothers name. The payment to bank is made by Mr. X by transferring the funds to his mothers savings account i.e through her mothers savings account the amount is repaid to the Bank. Mr. X wants to claim deductions of principal and interest which is paid to the Bank. What is the procedure as per the Income Tax Act and Rules ??
28 July 2024
In the scenario where Mr. X, a salaried employee, has taken a house loan but the house is purchased in his mother's name, and he is repaying the loan, here’s how he can approach claiming deductions for principal and interest under the Income Tax Act:
### **1. Eligibility for Deductions:**
#### **Interest on Home Loan (Section 24(b)):**
- **Eligibility:** - Deduction of up to ₹2 lakh per annum can be claimed for interest on a home loan under Section 24(b) of the Income Tax Act. - The property must be acquired, constructed, or repaired with the borrowed funds for which the interest deduction is claimed. - The deduction is applicable whether the property is self-occupied or let out.
- **Condition:** - Since the property is in the name of Mr. X's mother, Mr. X is not the owner. Therefore, he cannot claim the deduction for interest paid under Section 24(b) unless he is the co-owner of the property.
#### **Principal Repayment (Section 80C):**
- **Eligibility:** - Deduction up to ₹1.5 lakh per annum can be claimed for the principal repayment of a home loan under Section 80C. - The loan must be taken for the purchase or construction of a residential property.
- **Condition:** - Similar to interest deductions, Mr. X can only claim the principal repayment deduction if he is a co-owner of the property.
### **2. Procedure for Claiming Deductions:**
- **Ownership and Legal Rights:** - To claim deductions, Mr. X must have a legal interest in the property. This generally means he should be a co-owner of the property. If Mr. X's mother is the sole owner, Mr. X cannot claim these deductions.
- **Documentation:** - **Proof of Ownership:** Mr. X needs to be a co-owner of the property for claiming deductions. Ownership should be reflected in the property documents. - **Loan Documents:** Documentation of the loan agreement and proof of payment. - **Repayment Proof:** Bank statements showing the loan repayments made by Mr. X or through his mother’s account.
- **Tax Filing:** - Mr. X should claim the deductions in his Income Tax Return (ITR) under the respective sections (Section 24(b) and Section 80C). He needs to provide all the supporting documents to substantiate his claims.
### **Alternative Options if Not a Co-Owner:**
1. **Gift Deed:** - If Mr. X's mother is willing, Mr. X can be added as a co-owner through a gift deed. This would allow Mr. X to claim the deductions.
2. **Joint Loan Application:** - In future, Mr. X can apply for a loan jointly with his mother and ensure that both are co-owners of the property, which will allow both parties to claim deductions.
### **Important Considerations:**
- **Income Tax Act Provisions:** - The Income Tax Act mandates that to claim deductions, the individual claiming them must have a legal and beneficial interest in the property. Without co-ownership, Mr. X will not be eligible to claim the deductions.
- **Professional Advice:** - It is advisable to consult a tax professional or chartered accountant for specific advice tailored to Mr. X's situation, especially to ensure compliance with tax laws and optimal tax benefits.
### **Conclusion:**
To summarize, Mr. X cannot claim the interest and principal repayment deductions if he is not a co-owner of the property. He should ensure he is a co-owner to be eligible for these deductions. If he is not a co-owner, he would need to explore the possibility of legal changes such as adding himself as a co-owner to the property.